Freemasonry in Queens: Lodge Histories, Masonic Buildings, and People

Map of the Counties of New York, Queens, Kings, and Richmond, by David H. Burr, published by Stone & Clark, c. 1839, in an Atlas of the State of New York. From the David Rumsey Map Collection.

Counties of New York, Queens, Kings & Richmond, by D.H. Burr, c. 1839. David Rumsey Map Collection.[5]

From rented rooms in Hunters Point to the temples of Astoria, Elmhurst and College Point: how the Masonic lodges grew up with the borough, and where they meet today.

Freemasonry in Queens is older than the borough itself. Decades before the 1898 consolidation of Greater New York, Masonic lodges were meeting in Hunters Point, Astoria, Newtown and Flushing. Their members were blacksmiths and printers, ship carpenters and merchants, engineers and politicians. Their lodge minutes, charters, cornerstones and buildings now form one of the best paper trails we have for how the villages of Queens grew into neighborhoods.

This page is the starting point for the Freemasonry in Queens material on BreteMurphy.com. It gives the long view. The lodge histories, buildings and member profiles go into the detail.

Lodges Before the Borough

The lineage of today's Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586 shows how early the work began. Island City Lodge No. 586 worked under dispensation in 1865 and received its charter on June 18, 1866. It met first in Hunters Point. A year later, on July 2, 1867, Advance Lodge No. 635 was chartered in Astoria. Its first hall stood at Main Street and Fulton Avenue, where Main Street now meets Astoria Boulevard at the top of 22nd Street. Several of Advance's charter members had been raised in Island City Lodge only months before.

Mizpah Lodge No. 738 followed on June 20, 1873, and later made its home in Elmhurst. In Flushing, Cornucopia Lodge No. 563 became so central to Masonic life that it is remembered as a mother of lodges. Its members helped start new lodges across northern and eastern Queens. In Jamaica, Jamaica Lodge No. 546 worked from rented rooms and later from its hall on Union Avenue.

These early lodges did not own buildings. They rented rooms over stores, in public halls and in buildings shared with other fraternities. Many of their members also belonged to the Odd Fellows and the other brotherhoods, or to the Ancient Order of United Workmen lodge that Advance member John Allen founded in Astoria (see The Workmen of Astoria). A Mason in nineteenth-century Astoria was usually a joiner several times over.

The Building Years

Between 1906 and 1922 the Queens lodges stopped renting and started building. Island City Lodge laid its cornerstone on Jackson Avenue in Long Island City on September 8, 1906. Grand Master Townsend Scudder dedicated the finished temple on May 10, 1907.

Advance Lodge laid its cornerstone on Grand Avenue in Astoria on November 20, 1915, using a stone donated by past master James Prowse. The three-story Advance Masonic Temple opened with a fair in April 1916 and was dedicated on November 14, 1916. Its lodge room, built to prints by Arthur E. Wenige's firm, Wenige & Nelson, is still in use.

Mizpah Lodge laid its cornerstone in Elmhurst on January 1, 1920. Grand Master Robert H. Robinson dedicated the temple on March 17, 1921. Whitestone Lodge finished its temple in 1922. Cornucopia built and ran the Flushing Masonic Temple on Northern Boulevard, where other lodges, including Service Lodge No. 1009, rented space.

The new buildings came with a wave of new charters. Geba Lodge No. 954 was chartered on May 7, 1919. King David Lodge No. 994 followed on May 3, 1922 and Service Lodge No. 1009 on May 3, 1923. Maspeth Lodge No. 1089 and Rufus King Lodge No. 1091 were both chartered on May 3, 1928. Some new lodges were formed by members who left older ones. In 1920 James Prowse Jr. left Advance to become a charter member of Astoria Lodge No. 963. See The Thirteen Who Left Advance.

Masons in Public Life

The lodge room and the civic life of Queens overlapped all the time. Horatio S. Sanford, the reform mayor of Long Island City, was raised in Advance Lodge in 1893. Henry Clay Johnson, an Advance past master, served as postmaster of Astoria and in the State Assembly, and gave the oration at the 1915 cornerstone. George U. Harvey, Queens borough president, was twice Master of Cornucopia Lodge. Charles W. Froessel rose from the East of Tadmor Lodge No. 923 in Ridgewood to the Grand East. Edward J. Smith became known as Mr. Mason of Queens.

Grand Lodge officers came to Queens too. Townsend Scudder, who was raised in Glen Cove Lodge No. 580 and never belonged to a Queens lodge, still shows up again and again: dedicating the Island City temple in 1907 and pouring the corn, wine and oil at the Advance dedication in 1916. The lodges' names tie them to Queens history as well. Francis Lewis Lodge No. 273 honors the Flushing signer of the Declaration of Independence, whom Masonic tradition counts as a brother. Advance Lodge took its name from the USS Advance.

More lives are collected in Notable Freemasons of Queens.

Consolidation

After World War II, and especially from the 1970s, membership fell and lodges began to merge. The mergers often took months, with two lodges meeting together while they settled bylaws and bank accounts, so this site usually gives them by year.

The Advance Service Mizpah line is a good example. In 1987 Island City and Mizpah consolidated and kept Mizpah's number, 738. In 1993 that lodge merged with Advance, and the combined lodge chose No. 586 to honor Island City, the oldest Queens lodge in its line. Service, City and Geba lodges later joined through consolidations of their own. See the timeline and family tree.

Other lineages followed the same path. Wakefield Lodge No. 1110 merged with Richmond Hill Lodge No. 892 on January 1, 1978. On November 21, 1990, three lodges with roots across western and northern Queens became Harmony Lodge No. 241.

Buildings changed hands as well. Island City Lodge lost its temple to a federal courthouse, which rented the ground floor from 1934 and the whole building from 1938. The lodge moved to Mizpah's Elmhurst temple and later sold the building to the government. Mizpah's own temple was sold to a church. The name MIZPAH is still displayed above the door. The full list is in Masonic Buildings in Queens.

Freemasonry in Queens Today

The lineages followed on this site run through seven active lodges: Advance Service Mizpah No. 586, Francis Lewis No. 273, Cornucopia No. 563, Tadmor No. 923, Anchor-Astoria No. 729, Harmony No. 241 and Springfield Gardens No. 1057. Together they carry thirty-three charters, thirty-one of them first granted in Queens. Begin with The Seven Lodges of the Queens District.

Two buildings hold much of that history now. The Advance Masonic Temple on Grand Avenue in Astoria is home to Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586, Tadmor Lodge No. 923 and Parthenon Lodge No. 1101. The Anchor-Astoria temple in College Point took in Cornucopia and Harmony in September 2024 and Francis Lewis in September 2025. Springfield Gardens Lodge No. 1057 meets outside the borough, at the Scottish Rite temple in Rockville Centre: see A Queens Lodge Outside Queens.

Where to Go Next

Sources

Image:

[5] "Map of the Counties of New York, Queens, Kings, and Richmond," by David H. Burr, in An Atlas of the State of New York ... under the superintendence of Simeon DeWitt (Ithaca, N.Y.: Stone & Clark, republished 1840; map dated 1839). From the David Rumsey Map Collection, David Rumsey Map Center, Stanford University Libraries. Accessed via: David Rumsey/ Map of The Borrough of Queens

Charter, dispensation and merger dates on this page come from Grand Lodge of New York records unless stated otherwise. Where a lodge history, newspaper or later article gives a different date, the individual article explains the conflict in a footnote. Building, member and lineage details are documented in the linked articles above. Corrections and new records are always welcome.


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Masonic Buildings in Queens: Temples, Lodge Rooms, and Lost Meeting Places

Next
Next

How Long Island City Was Created in 1870