Island City Lodge No. 586 and the Temple That Served the City

the official seal of Island City Lodge No.586, Long Island City

Official seal of Island City Lodge No.586, Long Island City

The history of Island City Lodge No. 586, from a dispensation in 1865 to a Jackson Avenue temple the federal government eventually wanted for itself.

Start Here · Series Hub · Timeline · Previous Article: To Be Assigned · Next Article: To Be Assigned · Related Directory: Island City Members · Related Member Profiles: To Be Assigned


Island City Lodge No. 586 received its charter on June 18, 1866, and built a temple on Jackson Avenue that it eventually lost to the needs of a courthouse.

Lodges lose their buildings in familiar ways: fire, debt, a membership that thins out year by year. Island City’s departure followed a different course.

The federal court rented the ground floor in 1934, took the whole building in 1938, and kept it until the lodge sold.

The history of Island City Lodge No. 586 runs from that Long Island City temple to a long stay in Elmhurst and then to two consolidations. The number outlasted all of it.

When Advance Service Mizpah Lodge meets in Astoria, it meets as No. 586. The 1993 consolidation that brought the branch to Astoria restored Island City’s number to commemorate the oldest Queens lodge in the lineage.

A Lodge Before There Was a City

When the Grand Lodge of New York gave the lodge permission to begin work in June 1865, there was no Long Island City in the municipal sense.

The waterfront settlements along the East River, with their ferry slips, rail connections, and factories, still belonged to the Town of Newtown.

The city of Long Island City would be incorporated in 1870 and absorbed into Greater New York in 1898. The lodge’s name came first.

That suggests “Island City” was already local shorthand, though the sources gathered for this series do not say who chose it or why.

The place was industrial and unfinished, a district of streets still being laid out between businesses that had arrived ahead of the people to staff them.

The lodge worked in two stages.

A dispensation is temporary permission to meet and conduct lodge work. A charter is the Grand Lodge’s permanent grant.

Island City received its dispensation on June 18, 1865, and its charter on June 18, 1866, a year to the day. The lodge’s own 1941 history, “Highlights in History of Island City,” gives both dates.

The series glossary explains these stages of a lodge’s formation.

The material gathered so far does not name the founding officers or establish how many men the lodge counted in its early years.

It first met in Hunters Point. By 1906 it was meeting in Smithsonian Hall at Vernon Avenue and Third Street.

The newspaper clippings in the packet begin in 1900. Until the earlier record turns up, the first decades remain thin on the page.

A Temple in the Civic Center

By the early twentieth century the lodge had put itself in the middle of things.

Its temple went up on Jackson Avenue, near Anable Avenue, in the block that had once held the old City Hall of Long Island City.

The city that built that hall had been folded into New York in 1898, but the neighborhood retained its civic buildings.

The cornerstone was laid on September 8, 1906, and the Brooklyn Eagle reported the ceremony.

That day has its own article in this series. The building was finished in 1907, and Grand Master Townsend Scudder dedicated it on May 10, 1907.

The temple was not only a temple.

A commercial tenant occupied the first floor, bringing rental income from the street level. The lodge room was on the second floor.

Below, in the basement, were a kitchen and a bowling alley. The building combined a meeting place with space for business, dinners, and recreation.

The lodge room was improved over time. An organ was installed in 1922, fifteen years after the dedication.

The companion article on the Island City Masonic Temple follows the building in fuller detail, including its plan, tenants, and later uses.

When the Courthouse Came Calling

The lodge’s neighbor was the Queens County Federal Court Building, and its needs grew.

In 1934 the federal court began renting the temple’s ground floor. In 1938 it took the entire building.

The arrangement eventually ended with a sale to the federal government.

The sequence is worth setting out plainly. The lodge dedicated its temple in 1907 and added an organ in 1922. Twelve years later the court was renting the ground floor. Four years after that, the lodge could no longer use its own lodge room.

The building was not demolished. It survived and later returned to commercial use.

The series map places the Jackson Avenue temple alongside the other selected meeting places in the lineage.

Half a Century Under Mizpah’s Roof

The 1938 takeover left Island City without a home, and the lodge moved its meetings to the Mizpah Masonic Temple in Elmhurst.

Mizpah Lodge No. 738 had laid the cornerstone of that temple in 1920. The building was dedicated in 1921.

Mizpah itself dated from 1873, when it was chartered in Newtown, the village later known as Elmhurst.

The temple became a meeting place for several Queens lodges. Geba met there from its early years, and Service City was meeting there by the late 1970s.

Island City and Mizpah shared the building for roughly half a century.

The lodge notes describe those decades as a period of close cooperation and say little more. The record does not describe what it felt like for a lodge that had owned a temple in the civic center to meet as a guest in Elmhurst.

The Elmhurst temple was later sold to a church. The building still stands.

The geography article follows these movements across Queens, from the waterfront to Elmhurst and then to Astoria.

The Number That Stayed

In 1987 Island City consolidated with Mizpah, the lodge that had hosted it for nearly half a century.

The result was Island City Mizpah Lodge No. 738. The combined lodge kept Mizpah’s number, so No. 586 left use in this branch for six years.

In 1993 that lodge consolidated with Advance Lodge No. 635 and took up residence in the Advance Masonic Temple at 21-14 30th Avenue in Astoria.

For the combined lodge, the members chose No. 586.

The number commemorated the oldest Queens lodge in the line. Island City had received its charter in 1866, a year before Advance received its own.

City Lodge No. 408, chartered in Manhattan in 1856, remained the oldest charter in the wider lineage.

On January 31, 2018, Service City Geba Lodge No. 1009 consolidated with Advance Island City Mizpah Lodge No. 586 to form Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586.

The Merger History follows the consolidations. The Family Tree shows how the six branches connect, and the Timeline places their charters and moves in order.

Island City Lodge No. 586 history comes down to a street and a number.

The street is Jackson Avenue, where the temple passed to court use and later returned to commerce. The number went to Astoria.

The other five original numbers no longer identify the combined lodge. No. 586, belonging to a lodge that began before Long Island City became a city, is the one above its name.


Sources and Notes

Working list from the Island City source packet. Full bibliographic details remain to be completed where not supplied.

Lodge History

“Highlights in History of Island City,” 1941.

Newspapers

Brooklyn Eagle, cornerstone report, September 8, 1906; exact publication reference to be confirmed.

Newspaper clippings on the lodge and its temple, 1900–1974.

Grand Lodge Records

Grand Lodge of New York records for charter dates, lodge numbers, and consolidations.

[Before publication: complete the newspaper citations, identify the specific Grand Lodge records consulted, and verify the temple’s property history.]

Note 1: Dates, Numbers, Places, and Limits of the Record

The lodge’s 1941 history gives June 18, 1865, for the dispensation and June 18, 1866, for the charter. Earlier material in this series sometimes gave 1865 alone as the charter year. The two dates mark different events. The series uses June 18, 1866, as the charter date, following Grand Lodge records.

The lodge numbers, No. 738 in 1987 and No. 586 from 1993, and the consolidation years come from Grand Lodge records. The consolidations of 1973, 1982, 1987, and 1993 are given by year only.

City Lodge’s 1856 charter is the oldest in the overall lineage. Island City’s 1866 charter is the oldest among the Queens lodges in that lineage.

The date on which Island City sold its temple to the federal government is not established in the material gathered so far.

The lodge’s own note places the temple at 246 Jackson Avenue, near Pearson and Annabel. The cornerstone material gives the site as Jackson Avenue near Anable Avenue. Other series material places it between Pearson and Anable Streets.

The street name appears in more than one spelling. The precise historic address and its modern equivalent should be checked against a Sanborn map and property records before publication.

The surviving building’s commercial use requires confirmation if described as current. This page describes its later commercial use without identifying a present tenant.

The material gathered so far does not establish the founding officers, early membership total, cost of the 1922 organ, or who paid for it.

The meeting schedule supplied in the draft has been omitted because it has not been verified as current. The article retains Astoria as the combined lodge’s meeting location.


Start Here · Series Hub · Timeline · Previous Article: To Be Assigned · Next Article: To Be Assigned · Related Directory: Island City Members · Related Member Profiles: To Be Assigned

Related Reading

Island City Lodge No. 586 and the Laying of Its Cornerstone

The Island City Masonic Temple: A Building That Served a Growing Borough

Mizpah’s Watchtower in Old Newtown: The Story of Mizpah Lodge No. 738

Mizpah Masonic Temple: The Watchtower at the Center of Queens

Advance Lodge No. 635: Astoria’s First Masonic Lodge

The Advance Masonic Temple in Astoria: A Lodge Building That Endured

The Merger History of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586

← Return to the Queens History Blog


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Mizpah’s Watchtower in Old Newtown: The Story of Mizpah Lodge No. 738

Next
Next

Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586: A Living Inheritance of Six New York Lodges