Official seal of Mizpah Lodge No.738, Elmhurst, Queens
Mizpah Lodge No. 738 history, from a law office in old Newtown in 1873 to a three-story temple in Elmhurst that housed lodges from across Queens.
Start Here · Series Hub · Timeline · Previous Article: Geba Lodge · Next Article: Island City Lodge · Related Directory: Mizpah Members · Related Member Profiles: To Be Assigned
The first meeting of Mizpah Lodge was held in a lawyer’s office. That fits what followed. Mizpah Lodge No. 738 history is the story of a lodge that began with nine men, a borrowed room, and the by-laws of another lodge, and that came to own a temple of its own.
Along the way the village of Newtown became Elmhurst, and Mizpah became the lodge that other lodges came to.
Newtown Before Elmhurst
In 1873 Newtown was a farming and residential village of a few thousand people, in a county that held about fifty thousand in all. The center of the village was at what is now the junction of Queens Boulevard and Broadway.
The Civil War was eight years over, and by the lodge’s own centennial account the village had what a village needed: one school, several shops, and five churches. It had no Masonic lodge.
A Newtown Mason who wanted to attend one had to go to Jamaica, Flushing, Hunters Point, or Astoria, each many miles away. The lodge history says the need for a nearer lodge became extremely strong.
A Brooklyn Daily Times article of 1900 adds that Newtown had once had other Masonic lodges, among them a Union Lodge and one said to have met in a barn, but that Mizpah was by then the only one.
What Mizpah Means
The name comes from Genesis 31:49, where Laban and Jacob, about to part, set up a pillar and ask that God watch between them while they are apart. Masons often use the verse as a benediction at the close of a lodge meeting.
The founders’ reason for choosing the name is not established in the material used here. For a lodge formed because its members lived far from other lodges, the association with distance and watchfulness gives the name a particular resonance.
Dispensation, Charter, and a Borrowed Set of By-Laws
Nine Master Masons petitioned the Grand Lodge, and on February 13, 1873, Grand Master Christopher G. Fox granted a dispensation, the temporary permission a new lodge needs while it proves itself.
Garret J. Garretson was named Master, S. Fisk Worthington Senior Warden, and Samuel Douglass Junior Warden. The other members were Thomas Anderton, C. Anderton, James Cating, Robert M. Donaldson, John H. Jebens, and Abel Powell.
The first meeting was held on Thursday evening, February 27, 1873, in Garretson’s law offices.
Most of them, by the lodge’s centennial history, belonged to Island City Lodge No. 586. Island City had been so helpful in getting the charter that Mizpah borrowed its by-laws. The centennial history adds that those same by-laws, amended as needed, still governed Mizpah in 1973.
Within six weeks the lodge had rooms on the top floor of the Jebens Building on Broadway, furnished at a cost of $529.11 supplied by the charter members.
At the first meeting in the new rooms, Island City presented Mizpah with a Bible and a set of Square and Compasses. The Square and Compasses were still in regular use in 1973, and every Master of the lodge had taken his obligation on that Bible.
The Grand Lodge issued Mizpah’s charter on June 20, 1873. Deputy Grand Master Elwood E. Thorne, acting as Grand Master, conducted the ceremony of constitution.
The first officers under the charter were Garretson, Worthington, and Douglass again, with Thomas E. Anderson as Treasurer, Joseph A. Lawrence as Secretary, and John H. Jebens as Tiler, the lodge’s doorkeeper.
Garretson was Master through 1876, and the lodge grew to thirty-nine Master Masons. In 1881 the lodge met on the second and fourth Thursdays of the month.
George M. Williamson, Master in 1881, 1882, and 1883, became District Deputy Grand Master of the First Masonic District, which covered all of Long Island except Brooklyn, in June 1885.
The Only Lodge in Newtown
A jurisdiction dispute shows how seriously the lodge took its territory. In the old town days, according to the Times in 1900, Mizpah had jurisdiction over every Newtown man who applied to join it or any other lodge.
After the 1898 consolidation, lodges in Manhattan and Brooklyn claimed equal jurisdiction and at times initiated Newtown candidates without Mizpah’s consent. The Grand Lodge restored Mizpah’s exclusive authority over Newtown applicants shortly before 1900.
The same article notes that a lambskin apron worn by a member of the old Union Lodge had been given to Mizpah and was kept in its archives.
In 1898 the lodge had its rooms refurnished and redecorated.
By 1900 four of the nine charter members had died. The Times names Anderton, who died in 1876; Cating, in 1893; Jebens, in 1896; and Charles A. Anderson, in 1900.
The paper lists a dozen past masters from Newtown, Maspeth, Corona, and Woodside, which gives some idea of the territory the lodge drew on.
From Village to Something Denser
Newtown became part of New York City in 1898, which was also the lodge’s twenty-fifth anniversary, and Garretson, the first Master, presided once more for the occasion.
By then the Times was already using Elmhurst as the post office name of the old village. The lodge history says the new century brought the usual changes, with farms giving way to houses and the village taking its place in the city.
Mizpah followed. On September 14, 1905, it held its first meeting in Arcanum Hall on Broadway in Elmhurst.
In June 1907 Grand Master Townsend Scudder appointed one of its members, Charles H. Georgi, a Grand Steward. The lodge also took part in public ceremonies, and its officers laid cornerstones for public buildings. When the cornerstone of Public School 11 in Woodside was laid, the lodge called a special communication, and its members filled most of the stations.
In 1915 Joseph N. Wickham became District Deputy Grand Master, according to the centennial history. Grand Master George Freifeld came to his homecoming, the first Grand Master to visit Mizpah.
Wickham, known as Doc, installed the lodge’s officers every year from 1912 to 1946. His name also appears in the account of Advance Lodge’s cornerstone ceremony in November 1915.
The two lodges had taken part together in laying the cornerstone of the Robert J. Marks G.A.R. monument in Mount Olivet Cemetery in 1889.
Building the Elmhurst Temple
The lodge bought a site in 1916 for $6,000 and began building in 1919.
The Brooklyn Daily Times announced on December 31, 1919, that the cornerstone would be laid at 2:30 the next afternoon, January 1, 1920, by Deputy Grand Master Robert H. Robinson, with Judge Townsend Scudder, a past Grand Master, as one of the principal speakers.
Delegations were expected from lodges in Elmhurst, Forest Hills, Flushing, College Point, Richmond Hill, Long Island City, and Astoria. Wickham chaired the arrangements committee.
The $100,000 temple was to stand at Warner Avenue and Ketchum Place, on a plot seventy feet wide and a hundred deep, in red brick, three stories above a basement. Warner Avenue was soon renamed Whitney Avenue, and the building is now 87-11 Whitney Avenue.
The architect was Charles Hendry, a past master of the lodge. The first floor was to be an auditorium for more than five hundred people, the lodge room was to be on the second floor, the dining room on the third, and a bowling alley in the basement.
The builders were the Woodruff Construction Company of Long Island City, and the paper expected several lodges and an Eastern Star chapter to move in.
The Chancellor Robert R. Livingston Masonic Library holds a trowel presented to Robinson at that ceremony.
The event has a separate article in this series: Mizpah Lodge No. 738 and the Laying of the Elmhurst Cornerstone.
The money ran short while the building went up. With the help of Mizpah’s Star Chapter No. 484 of the Order of the Eastern Star, the lodge held a bazaar in the unfinished temple.
A Times report in October 1920 described it as a week-long affair at the new temple and said it was the first time the public could look the building over. Robert H. Robinson, who had laid the cornerstone as Deputy Grand Master and was now Grand Master, opened the bazaar.
Grand Master Robinson dedicated the temple on March 17, 1921, with the entire Grand Lodge staff present.
A Temple for the District
The Times expected several lodges to share the new building, and it was right.
Geba Lodge No. 954 was proposed by Mizpah, met at first in rented rooms in Jackson Heights, and moved into the Mizpah temple in its early days.
Island City Lodge began meeting there in 1938, when the federal court took over its own temple in Long Island City. Service City Lodge and Geba were both meeting at Mizpah in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
The temple also became the district’s schoolroom. The Masonic School of Instruction, where the officers of the district’s lodges learn their work, was held at Mizpah from 1928.
Four Mizpah members served as Assistant Grand Lecturer: William J. McCulloch in 1937 and 1938, Frederick E. Shore in 1942, George F. de Jongh Jr. in 1964, and Robert J. Lawton in 1972.
The lodge supplied a steady line of district officers. Frederick W. Ritter became District Deputy Grand Master of the whole Queens District in 1923, when the lodge celebrated its fiftieth anniversary with Grand Master Arthur S. Tompkins in attendance.
Nathaniel V. Garretson, nephew of the first Master, was appointed in 1933, McCulloch in 1939, Robert R. Scholl in 1945, John G. Bambach in 1959, and de Jongh in 1967.
William E. Schweitzer, Secretary from 1924, became Grand Director of Ceremonies in 1953. His reception that year, at the lodge’s eightieth anniversary, included the burning of the last mortgage on the building.
The building’s longer story continues in Mizpah Masonic Temple in Elmhurst.
Consolidation
Island City and Mizpah had spent nearly half a century under one roof when, in 1987, they consolidated as Island City Mizpah Lodge No. 738, keeping Mizpah’s number.
In 1993 that lodge consolidated with Advance Lodge No. 635 and moved to the Advance Masonic Temple in Astoria, choosing No. 586 in honor of Island City.
In 2018 it consolidated again, with Service City Geba Lodge, to form Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586.
The Elmhurst temple was later sold to a church. The building still stands.
The Merger History follows the two branches into one, while the Timeline places those consolidations beside the charters, buildings, and moves.
Mizpah Lodge No. 738 history begins in a lawyer’s office because the lodge did not yet have a building. Its name still stands in the title of the lodge that meets in Astoria today, which has a building and kept the name of the one that began without.
Sources and Notes
Lodge Histories
- Mizpah Lodge centennial history, “Lodge History,” 1973; author and exact date to be confirmed.
- An 1881 history of Mizpah Lodge, including its list of officers; publication to be identified.
Newspapers
- Brooklyn Daily Times, November 10, 1900.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, December 31, 1919.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, October 25, 1920.
- Brooklyn Eagle, November 21, 1915, for the appearance of Joseph N. Wickham among the Grand Lodge officers at Advance Lodge’s cornerstone ceremony.
[Before publication: add article titles and page references, and identify any additional newspaper sources actually used.]
Object Record
- Chancellor Robert R. Livingston Masonic Library, object record for the Mizpah Lodge No. 738 trowel presented to Robert H. Robinson.
[Before publication: add the catalog identifier and exact record reference.]
Grand Lodge Records
Grand Lodge of New York records supply the charter date and consolidation chronology used in this series.
[Before publication: add the proceedings volumes and page references actually consulted.]
Note 1: Dates, Names, Figures, and Limits of the Record
The charter date is June 20, 1873, following the Grand Lodge chronology used for this series. The centennial history gives June 27, 1873, which it also treats as the anniversary date in 1898. The Times of November 10, 1900, gives 1878, and a summary in the packet gives 1875. Neither date is used here.
The 1881 history says the charter followed two months under dispensation, while the dispensation of February 13 and the June charter are about four months apart.
The nine charter members appear under several spellings: Worthington and Fisk Worthington, Douglas and Douglass, Anderton and Anderson, and Jebens, Jebins, and Jebbens. The centennial list names both C. Anderton and Thomas Anderton, while the 1900 list names Charles A. Anderson. The identification of C. Anderton with Charles A. Anderson remains an inference.
The 1881 history says nine charter members came from Island City Lodge, while the centennial history says a majority did.
The Times of 1900 says the lodge first met at Association Hall and then moved to the Jebens Building. The centennial history places the first meeting in Garretson’s law offices and the move to the Jebens Building within six weeks. This article follows that account.
The Eagle lists Joseph N. Wickham as Deputy Grand Master in November 1915, while the centennial history says he became District Deputy Grand Master that year. His office and the identification across the two accounts require checking against Grand Lodge records.
The temple is placed at Warner Avenue and Ketchum Place, spelled Ketcham in 1920, in the newspapers of 1919 and 1920. Warner Avenue was soon renamed Whitney Avenue, and the address is 87-11 Whitney Avenue.
The centennial history gives no size or cost for the building, only the $6,000 price of the site in 1916. The Times described three stories above a basement in December 1919 and four stories of marble and brick in October 1920. It gave the cost as $100,000 and $200,000 respectively. Whether the later description counts the basement as a story or reflects changed plans or costs is not established here.
The centennial history spells the Grand Master’s name Robertson. This article uses Robinson.
Charles Hendry, the architect, was also a past master of the lodge.
The 1919 Times describes Garretson as a former Supreme Court justice. No other source in hand confirms that description, and it is not used in the body.
The founders’ reason for choosing the name Mizpah is not established in the material consulted. Interpretive claims in earlier drafts about the ceremonial trowel, including what it meant and how it was received, are omitted.
Consolidations are given by year throughout the series. The date of the Elmhurst temple’s sale to a church is not established here, and “later” should not be read as assigning the sale to a particular interval between mergers.
Start Here · Series Hub · Timeline · Previous Article: Geba Lodge · Next Article: Island City Lodge · Related Directory: Mizpah Members · Related Member Profiles: To Be Assigned