President Theodore Roosevelt
Part 8 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: James B. Pearsall · Next: James Foote →
In 1926 Theodore Roosevelt Jr. dedicated a stained-glass window in Oyster Bay to mark twenty-five years since his father became a Master Mason. In 2003 firefighters carried it out of a burning building.
At 2:30 in the morning on October 25, 2003, fire broke out in the basement of the old building at 14 West Main Street in Oyster Bay. By dawn, thirteen fire departments and about 120 firefighters were on the scene, and parts of the first and second floors and the roof had collapsed. Standing in the street that afternoon, Matinecock Lodge's historian, John Hammond, watched the firefighters go back in. Then he shouted: "Oh, my God! I don't believe it! They got out the memorial window" (Newsday, October 26, 2003).
The window he meant had been given to the lodge in 1926 by Theodore Roosevelt Jr.
Twenty-five years after
The occasion was an anniversary. On April 24, 1901, Vice President Theodore Roosevelt was raised a Master Mason in Matinecock Lodge No. 806, in its rooms on the third floor of the Oyster Bay Bank Building. The story of that night, and of his three degrees, is told in Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason.
Roosevelt died in January 1919 and was buried in Youngs Memorial Cemetery above the village. In 1926, to mark the twenty-fifth anniversary of his father's joining the lodge, his eldest son, Theodore Roosevelt Jr., dedicated a memorial stained-glass window in the Matinecock lodge building (Newsday, October 26, 2003). The Wikipedia timeline of the Roosevelt family in Oyster Bay lists the same year: "1926, Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Window installed in the Matinecock Masonic Lodge building" (Theodore Roosevelt in Oyster Bay).
The son at the lodge
Ted Roosevelt Jr. was then thirty-nine, a veteran of the First World War, a former Assistant Secretary of the Navy and a public figure in his own right. The National Park Service notes that after his father's death he was active with the Masons at the lodge in Oyster Bay (National Park Service, "Oyster Bay, New York"). By 1926 the lodge had left the bank building and moved into its own home at 14 West Main Street, a former hotel built in 1901 by Charles DeKay Townsend, which it acquired in 1924. The window went into the new building and was set in its east wall, where it hung for the next seventy-seven years.
The fire
The 2003 fire destroyed much of what the lodge had gathered over a century. Hammond and Master Efrain Azmitia told Newsday that books, documents and Masonic medals dating back to the early 1800s were charred, soaked or lost. Some of the rarest Roosevelt items went with them.
But the firefighters stopped their work in the middle of the fight to rescue the lodge's treasures. They saved the Bible on which Theodore Roosevelt had taken his obligations, even though the floor beneath it had collapsed. And they saved the window. "Even while the floor was burning underneath them they were going into the building to rescue artifacts that were important to us," Hammond said. "Quite heroic."
The Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot reported a week later that the building had been demolished and that the lodge promised to rebuild "the same way but with modern safety features," with the Masons full of praise for the firefighters who salvaged the stained glass from the east wall (Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot, as reposted).
A father's lodge, a son's gift
Matinecock Lodge rebuilt at 14 West Main Street, and a marker outside still names it as the "Masonic Lodge of President Theodore Roosevelt" (Historical Marker Database). The window is the rarer memorial. Most tributes to the twenty-sixth president were raised by associations and governments. This one was given by a son to the small lodge of baymen, farmers and shopkeepers where his father liked to sit as just another brother. When fire came for it, the volunteer firemen of Oyster Bay went back in and brought it out.
Sources
Theresa Vargas and Pat Burson, "Fire Destroys Historic Lodge," Newsday, October 26, 2003.
Dagmar Fors Karppi, "Matinecock Lodge Demolished After Fire," Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot, October 31, 2003, as reposted.
"Theodore Roosevelt in Oyster Bay," Wikipedia.
Continue Reading
← Previous: James B. Pearsall · Next: James Foote → · Notable Freemasons of Queens
Related on BreteMurphy.com