Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason: Matinecock Lodge, Oyster Bay, 1901

Part 15 of Across the County Line · ← Previous: The Matinecock Masonic Temple · Next: The Massapequa Masonic Temple →

Initiated as Vice President-elect and raised as Vice President: Theodore Roosevelt's three nights in Oyster Bay in 1901, and the lodge he kept for life.

In the winter and spring of 1901, special trains ran to Oyster Bay three times so that Masons could watch a neighbor take his degrees. The neighbor was Theodore Roosevelt: Governor of New York when he petitioned, Vice President-elect when he was initiated, and Vice President when he was raised. Five months later he was President. The lodge he joined, Matinecock Lodge No. 806, was nine years old and met in a room over the village bank.

The petition

Matinecock Lodge had received its dispensation on July 6, 1892, in the town of Oyster Bay, then still part of Queens County. Its name is the Native American name for the hilly North Shore (Craftsmen Online). Roosevelt knew its members. His personal secretary, William J. Youngs, a charter member, proposed him. Theodore A. Swan, a Manhattan attorney and a founding member, was Master in 1900 and 1901.

Craftsmen Online notes that Roosevelt submitted his petition and the $5 fee 22 days after his election as Vice President in November 1900, giving his occupation as Governor and his place of business as Albany. The news stayed quiet until December 22, when invitations went out for a stated communication on Wednesday, January 2, 1901. "The news has just leaked out," the Brooklyn Eagle reported, that the Governor "has been elected a member of Matinecock Lodge."

The first degree: January 2, 1901

The Eagle reported the next day that more than a thousand Masons came, many on special trains that reached the village between 7:30 and 8 o'clock. Grand Lodge officers, among them Deputy Grand Master Elbert Crandall, Grand Secretary Edward M. L. Ehlers, and Past Grand Masters John W. Vrooman and John Stewart, were escorted to "the upper room over the Oyster Bay Bank," the building where Roosevelt had kept offices as Governor. Roosevelt arrived by carriage at about 8 o'clock. The crowd opened a lane for him to the stairway. Other accounts name District Deputy Frank E. Haff as presiding over the degree. Roosevelt left the lodge at 11 o'clock. The Eagle added that he would not take his second degree until after his inauguration as Vice President.

The effect on the lodge was immediate. On January 18 the Brooklyn Daily Times reported "an almost continuous stream of applications." Before Roosevelt, the lodge had about 110 members.

Passed and raised

Roosevelt was inaugurated Vice President on March 4, 1901. He was passed to the degree of Fellowcraft on March 27.

He was raised a Master Mason on the stormy night of April 24, 1901. Admission was by ticket. The New York Times counted about 300 members present and the Eagle more than 350, including Grand Master Charles W. Mead of Albany and his whole staff, Grand Master Fred S. Stephens of Connecticut, and the Grand Master of New Jersey. The crowd, the Eagle wrote, reached "from the upper rooms in the bank building far out into the street." Past Grand Master Wright D. Pownall gave the lecture. Afterward the visitors ate in the village truck house, where Roosevelt thanked the visitors from other districts in a short speech before their special train left.

The story about the stairs

The tale everyone remembers from that night is that the lodge room was so packed Roosevelt could not climb the stairs, so the brothers lifted him over their heads and passed him up. At the centennial in 2001, lodge historian John Hammond doubted it: "considering Roosevelt's bulk, it's doubtful that it actually happened and that the Secret Service would have allowed it. I don't put much faith in it but it's a nice story" (Newsday, April 19, 2001).

Why he joined

Hammond noted that Roosevelt's father had never joined, because of the anti-Masonic feeling of his day, but that the family tree included Masons, among them Archibald Bulloch. John A. Gable of the Theodore Roosevelt Association said Roosevelt valued the lodge as "a good way to keep in contact with the ordinary citizens of Oyster Bay. They were baymen and farmers and he had known most of them all his life. The estate people were not members." Warren Obes, who chaired the 2001 commemoration, said he joined because the lodge was the one place he "could be just another brother."

A working member

Roosevelt kept up with the lodge. Letters in the Library of Congress, catalogued by the Theodore Roosevelt Center, include a 1905 note from lodge secretary Walter Franklin telling the President he owed five dollars in dues, and a 1908 summons to the annual election. He was elected an honorary member of Pentalpha Lodge No. 23 in Washington on April 4, 1904. On January 7, 1907, wearing Masonic regalia, he spoke at the cornerstone laying of the new Masonic Temple at 13th Street and New York Avenue in Washington.

After the presidency he came home to the lodge. On January 19, 1911, he spoke to a packed lodge room in Oyster Bay about his African expedition, drawing Masons from Glen Cove, Cold Spring Harbor and Huntington, and told them he had paid his own and his son Kermit's expenses. In November 1912, a month after he was shot in Milwaukee, he attended the lodge's annual dinner at the East Norwich Hotel, still favoring his right arm, and said he was willing to take an office in the lodge. Members expected to make him Senior Warden.

Memory

In 1926 Theodore Roosevelt Jr. dedicated a stained-glass window at the lodge's building at 14 West Main Street to mark the 25th anniversary of his father's initiation. The window and the Roosevelt Bible survived the fire that destroyed that building in 2003. On April 24, 2001, the lodge marked the centennial of the raising by raising James Foote of Sea Cliff, who had portrayed Roosevelt for a quarter century, on the same Bible. A marker outside the rebuilt lodge reads: "Masonic Lodge of President Theodore Roosevelt" (Historical Marker Database).

Sources

  • "Roosevelt a Mason," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, December 22, 1900; "To Make Him a Mason," Brooklyn Daily Times, December 29, 1900.

  • "Mr. Roosevelt Made a Mason," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 3, 1901.

  • "Boom for Matinecock," Brooklyn Daily Times, January 18, 1901.

  • "Roosevelt a Full Mason," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, April 25, 1901; "Now a Third Degree Mason," New York Times, April 25, 1901.

  • "Roosevelt Tells Masons of His African Travels," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 20, 1911; "Col. Roosevelt at Banquet," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, November 15, 1912.

  • "Masonic Lodge Hears Brooks Talk on the Life of Theodore Roosevelt," Daily Times (Mamaroneck), October 29, 1931, giving the degree dates and the Pentalpha and 1907 Washington events.

  • Bill Bleyer, "A Centennial Moment: Lodge Honors Roosevelt Again," Newsday, April 19, 2001.

  • Ronald J. Seifried, Roosevelt's petition and degrees, Craftsmen Online, and "Enter the Apprentice: The First Degree of Theodore Roosevelt".

  • Herbert S. Hopkins, "Theodore Roosevelt, Master Mason," The Builder, January 1920, reprinted online.

  • Theodore Roosevelt Center, Dickinson State University, Freemasonry correspondence from the Library of Congress.

  • List of presidents of the United States who were Freemasons, Wikipedia.


Continue Reading

← Previous: The Matinecock Masonic Temple · Next: The Massapequa Masonic Temple → · Series Guide

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Massapequa Masonic Temple, Rockville Centre: The History of 28 Lincoln Avenue

Next
Next

Matinecock Masonic Temple, Oyster Bay: The History of 14 West Main Street