Matinecock Lodge No. 806: Theodore Roosevelt's Lodge in Oyster Bay

Part 2 of Across the County Line · ← Previous: Glen Cove Lodge No. 580 · Next: Massapequa Lodge No. 822 →

Chartered when Oyster Bay was still in Queens County, the lodge raised a sitting Vice President, then watched its landmark home burn more than a century later.

Two Hundred and Fifty Aprons on Main Street

On the evening of June 21, 1893, Oyster Bay saw something new. As the Brooklyn Daily Times put it, 250 white-aproned Masons marched in line through the village. They had come by train, by wagon and by boat.

The occasion was a charter. Matinecock Lodge had worked under dispensation for about a year. Now it was a constituted lodge, Matinecock No. 806, Free and Accepted Masons. The name came from the Matinecock people, the Native nation of the north shore.

Oyster Bay was then a Queens County town, and this was Queens County Masonry: the ceremony belonged to the First Masonic District, which took in Queens and Suffolk. Past Grand Master William Sherer installed the officers, assisted by Townsend Scudder of Glen Cove Lodge, Glen Cove being one of the lodges that had helped Matinecock into being.

The installation was held in the First Presbyterian Church, and the transept filled with guests. Afterward the company walked to Fleet's Hall for the banquet. A special train pulled out at 11:15 that night.

The First Officers

The first Master was William L. Swan. His name runs through Long Island Masonry for the next generation. As district deputy he organized the 1896 district convention in Far Rockaway. As acting Grand Master he laid the cornerstone of Jephtha Lodge's temple in Huntington in 1904 and of Olympia Lodge's temple in Far Rockaway in 1910.

The Junior Master of Ceremonies in 1893 was William J. Youngs. Seven and a half years later, as Governor Theodore Roosevelt's secretary, Youngs would propose Roosevelt for membership.

On March 1, 1894, the lodge dedicated its new lodge room, described as one of the finest outside the great cities of New York and Brooklyn.

A Vice President Is Raised

Theodore Roosevelt had summered in Oyster Bay since boyhood, and Sagamore Hill was his home. He petitioned Matinecock while he was Governor. He was initiated an Entered Apprentice on January 2, 1901. By the time he was passed on March 27, he had been sworn in as Vice President.

He was raised a Master Mason on April 24, 1901. The lodge then met on the third floor of the Oyster Bay Bank Building, where Roosevelt had kept offices as Governor. Secretary Walter Franklin expected some 500 visiting Masons, so he issued tickets. Craftsmen Online's account of the evening describes crowds outside and the lodge treasurer pushing through them to reach the stairs. The Masonic Standard reported that Grand Secretary Edward M. L. Ehlers presided as Master.

The full story of those three nights is told in Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason.

Roosevelt stayed a member through his presidency. The Theodore Roosevelt Center holds a December 1904 summons calling President Roosevelt to Matinecock's annual election.

A Hotel Becomes a Home

In 1924 the lodge bought a building of its own at 14 West Main Street. According to lodge historian John Hammond, Charles DeKay Townsend had built it in 1901 as a hotel and restaurant.

Two years later, in 1926, Theodore Roosevelt Jr. dedicated a stained-glass memorial window there. It marked the twenty-fifth anniversary of his father's raising. In 1987 the Town of Oyster Bay designated the building a landmark. Its history, from the bank rooms to the rebuilt lodge, is told in The Matinecock Masonic Temple.

A New York State historical marker stands at the site today, recorded by the Historical Marker Database. It reads simply: Masonic Lodge of President Theodore Roosevelt, raised to a Master Mason April 24, 1901.

The Fire of October 25, 2003

At about 2:30 on the morning of October 25, 2003, fire broke out in the basement of 14 West Main Street. At its peak, Newsday reported, 13 fire departments and some 120 firefighters fought the blaze. By the time it was contained around 6 a.m., part of the first and second floors and the roof had collapsed. The building was 102 years old, and the lodge had owned it for nearly 80 of them.

The firefighters did something the Masons never forgot: they stopped mid-fight to carry out artifacts. Hammond was standing in the street when he saw them bring out the Roosevelt memorial window. Roosevelt's Bible survived even though the floor beneath it collapsed. Much of the rest of the collection was charred, soaked or lost, including books, documents and Masonic medals going back to the early 1800s.

"It's our home," Master Efrain Azmitia told Newsday. "The family is still intact. We just don't have a place to live."

Until the lodge could rebuild, it met in the Atlantic Steamer firehouse. Azmitia called that ironic, since it was where the lodge had started a hundred years earlier. The ruins were demolished within days. As the Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot reported, the Masons promised to rebuild.

Roome Lodge and Matinecock Today

On November 1, 1988, Roome Lodge No. 746, chartered in New York on June 11, 1874, merged into Matinecock, which kept its own name and number. Matinecock still meets at 14 West Main Street. It now shares the address with Glen Cove Lodge No. 580, which helped found it more than 130 years ago.

Sources


Continue Reading

← Previous: Glen Cove Lodge No. 580 · Next: Massapequa Lodge No. 822 → · Series Guide

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Massapequa Lodge No. 822: Rockville Centre's Queens County Lodge

Next
Next

Glen Cove Lodge No. 580: The Civil War Lodge of Old Queens County