Part 1 of 5: Advance Lodge No. 635 Notable Members · ← Advance Lodge No. 635 History · James Ingram →
He was raised in Advance Lodge at twenty-six while serving as Astoria's postmaster. Over the next forty years he ran for sheriff, sat at three Republican National Conventions, and kept turning up in William Steinway's diary asking for money.
On April 3, 1883, the piano maker William Steinway made a note in his diary about a shipment of shoes. He had bought $299.50 worth and consigned them to "Th. H. Burden our Astoria Postmaster" (Steinway Diary, April 3, 1883). Twelve weeks later, on June 26, 1883, the same postmaster was raised a Master Mason in Advance Lodge No. 635. The Grand Lodge of New York's records, as examined by the author, recorded him as twenty-six years old, by occupation a postmaster. It was the start of a long public life, much of it lived in the space between Steinway's mansion and the Republican clubrooms of Queens.
The young postmaster
Theron H. Burden was born in 1857, a date the Library of Congress uses in cataloging his papers (Theodore Roosevelt Center). By his mid-twenties he held the post office that served Steinway's company village, the planned community of workers' houses, factories and stores the Steinways built around their piano works in Astoria. A postmaster there was a man everyone knew, and William Steinway knew him well. In September 1883 the diary records "Geo. H. Smith + Burden" calling on William at his office (Steinway Diary, September 17, 1883). George H. Smith and Burden would turn up together in Steinway's pages for years.
A Republican in a Democratic town
Long Island City was a Democratic stronghold, ruled for years by Mayor Patrick Gleason. Burden was a Republican, and an ambitious one. In October 1891 the Queens County Republicans nominated Judge Garret J. Garretson for county judge and T. H. Burden for sheriff (New York Times, October 7, 1891).
He did not win that race, but he did not give up on it. In September 1894 Steinway wrote that "Theron H. Burden again called & borrowed $350. having best chance for nomination for Sheriff" (Steinway Diary, September 21, 1894). The word "again" is telling. Two years earlier Steinway had written, a little wearily, "Have to help Burden with $1000. Cash again" (Steinway Diary, October 24, 1892).
Steinway's diary
The diary shows a relationship that was close, useful and sometimes trying. In June 1896 Steinway gave "Smith + Burden a guaranty of $5000 to Queens County Bank" (Steinway Diary, June 20, 1896).
Steinway was the great patron of Astoria, and everyone who wanted something came to him. Burden came often. But he also brought the piano maker news from the political world. On June 12, 1895, writing at New York and Astoria, Steinway set down what "Theron H. Burden told me" about a letter from East 125th Street: a post for general improvement had been denied and given instead to Walter C. Foster, another brother of Advance Lodge (Steinway Diary, June 12, 1895).
The federal man
Burden's party loyalty paid off in federal posts. By the early twentieth century he was deputy collector of Internal Revenue for the Second District, and he was elected president of a local Republican organization (Brooklyn Eagle, via Newspapers.com). In January 1908, Commissioner of Internal Revenue John G. Capers wrote to President Theodore Roosevelt's secretary, William Loeb, that he had "directed the appointment of Theron H. Burden," who had been endorsed by Representative William W. Cocks (Theodore Roosevelt Center).
He rose in the party's national councils too. Burden was a delegate from New York to the Republican National Conventions of 1908, 1912 and 1916, and in 1916 he ran for Congress in New York's 2nd District (Political Graveyard). In the bitter year of 1912, when Roosevelt's Bull Moose revolt split the Republicans, the regulars of Queens named him their choice for sheriff, and the Brooklyn Eagle reported that the applause "lasted several minutes" (Brooklyn Eagle, 1912). He lived then at 449 Ditmars Avenue in Steinway.
Forty-three years a brother
Burden died on March 7, 1926. He had been a member of Advance Lodge for more than four decades, through the lodge's years in rented halls and into the new temple on Grand Avenue. His story is one the lodge records alone could never tell: a young postmaster in a company town who made himself a fixture of Queens Republican politics, borrowed from the richest man in Astoria, and was still being cheered by his party more than twenty years after his first run for sheriff.
Sources
Grand Lodge of the State of New York membership records for Advance Lodge No. 635, as examined by the author (Theron H. Burden, raised June 26, 1883, age 26, postmaster).
The William Steinway Diary, 1861 to 1896, Smithsonian National Museum of American History: entries of April 3, 1883; September 17, 1883; October 24, 1892; September 21, 1894; June 12, 1895; June 20, 1896.
"Queens County Republicans: Judge Garretson for County Judge and T. H. Burden for Sheriff," New York Times, October 7, 1891.
Letter from John G. Capers to William Loeb, January 4, 1908, Theodore Roosevelt Center, Dickinson State University.
Brooklyn Eagle, Republican organization report (Newspapers.com) and 1912 Queens Republican nominations (Newspapers.com).
Continue Reading
Previous: ← Advance Lodge No. 635 History
Next: James Ingram →
Series home: Advance Lodge No. 635 Members Directory
Related on BreteMurphy.com