General James B. Pearsall: Glen Cove's Foremost Citizen and a 45-Year Mason of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580

A photo of the Home of Civil War General James B. Pearsall

The home of General James B. Pearsall

Part 7 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: George Duryea · Next: Theodore Roosevelt Jr. Window →

Born in 1826, raised on Wall Street when it was still a street of homes, he served on two governors' staffs and in the Assembly, and his lodge made him a life member when he was 85.

In September 1911, Glen Cove Lodge No. 580 did something unusual at its regular communication. It voted to make one of its members a life member, free of dues forever. The honoree was General James Buchanan Pearsall, then in his eighty-sixth year. He had been a Mason for forty-five years, and the lodge wanted that recorded (Brooklyn Eagle, September 22, 1911).

A boy on Wall Street

Pearsall's life began in a world that no longer existed by the time he died. He was born on March 14, 1826, at a family homestead in Locust Valley, where his mother was visiting a relative. His father was Thomas Pearsall, and his mother, Lavinia Coles, was a daughter of Nathaniel Coles of one of Glen Cove's founding families.

He grew up in the Pearsall family homestead on Wall Street in Manhattan, which, as the Brooklyn Eagle reminded its readers at his death, "was then a residential district." The family kept a country place at what became Fifty-ninth Street, then farmland, and his grandfather owned Jones' Woods on the East River, through which whole streets were later cut (Brooklyn Eagle, January 20, 1916).

Charleston, real estate and Glen Cove

As a young man Pearsall spent three years in business in Charleston, South Carolina, then came back to New York and went into real estate brokerage. More than sixty years before his death he moved to Glen Cove for good, building his house, "Afterthought," on Glen Street. Much of his later life went into developing the land around the village into the great country estates that made the North Shore famous.

He was a lifelong Democrat and a power in the party in his district. He served two terms in the State Assembly from Queens County, before Nassau County was created, and treasured a silver service presented by the citizens of the county with resolutions signed by four hundred of them.

The general's title

His title came from the governor's staff, not the battlefield. Pearsall served as aide-de-camp, with the rank of colonel, on the staff of Governor Samuel J. Tilden, and then as engineer-in-chief, with the rank of brigadier general, under Governor Lucius Robinson. For the rest of his life Glen Cove called him the General.

Forty-five years a Mason

The Eagle's obituary placed his Masonic membership alongside his other lifelong loyalties. He had served on the vestry of St. Paul's Episcopal Church in Glen Cove for sixty-eight years, and he "was made a life member of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580, F. & A. M., after forty-five years' membership in the lodge."

Forty-five years before 1911 takes his Masonic life back to about 1866, the year the young lodge received its charter. Pearsall was already forty then, a man of standing joining a lodge started by Civil War veterans in rented rooms on Glen Street. He lived to see it move into its own temple on Continental Place in 1913.

The last years

The General died at "Afterthought" on January 20, 1916, a few weeks short of his ninetieth birthday. His wife, Elena Frost, and his only son had died years before. He was survived by a sister, Mrs. Frances Pearsall Coles, and a granddaughter. The funeral was held at St. Paul's, the church he had served for nearly seven decades.

Pearsall belonged to an older Glen Cove than the Gold Coast that followed him: a village of old families, Democratic politics and Episcopal vestries, where a man could be a general without ever firing a shot and a Mason for most of his life without ever seeking office in the lodge. Glen Cove Lodge noticed, and it told him so while he was alive to hear it.

Sources

  • "General Pearsall Honored," Brooklyn Eagle, September 22, 1911.

  • "Gen. J. B. Pearsall Dies in 90th Year," Brooklyn Eagle, January 20, 1916.


Continue Reading

← Previous: George Duryea · Next: Theodore Roosevelt Jr. Window → · Notable Freemasons of Queens

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

The Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Window: How a President's Son Honored His Father at Matinecock Lodge

Next
Next

Colonel George Duryea: The Zouave Officer Who Became Master of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580