Part 9 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: Theodore Roosevelt Jr. Window · Next: McKinley Resolution →
On the hundredth anniversary of Theodore Roosevelt becoming a Master Mason, Matinecock Lodge No. 806 raised the man who had played him for twenty-five years.
For a quarter of a century, James Foote of Sea Cliff had been Theodore Roosevelt. He wore the Rough Rider's uniform into schools and special events across Long Island, gave the speeches, flashed the grin. On the night of April 23, 2001, he put the uniform away and wore black tie instead, because Matinecock Lodge No. 806 in Oyster Bay was about to make him a Master Mason, one hundred years almost to the night after it had done the same for the real Roosevelt (Newsday, April 19, 2001).
April 24, 1901
The original evening was one of the great nights in Long Island Masonry. Vice President Theodore Roosevelt was raised in Matinecock Lodge on April 24, 1901, and the event made headlines around the world. Newsday's Bill Bleyer wrote in 2001 that more than five hundred Masons tried to crowd into the lodge rooms while hundreds of journalists and residents watched from the street. The full story is told in Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason.
The night also left a legend. The lodge met on the third floor of the Oyster Bay Bank Building, and the stairs were said to be so jammed that the brethren lifted Roosevelt over their heads and passed him up to the lodge room. The lodge historian, John Hammond, gave the story its proper weight. "That story persists but considering Roosevelt's bulk, it's doubtful that it actually happened and that the Secret Service would have allowed it," he said. "I don't put much faith in it but it's a nice story."
The centennial plan
The lodge decided to mark the hundredth anniversary in the most Masonic way possible: by raising a new brother. The chairman of the event, Past District Deputy Grand Master Warren Obes, said the ceremony would use the Roosevelt Bible, the same book on which Roosevelt had taken his obligations. The candidate was Foote, then fifty-two.
There was another link to 1901. Roosevelt had been proposed for membership by his secretary and friend, William J. Youngs. Foote's sponsor was Norman Youngs, a descendant of the same family. "I think it's a nice coincidence," Foote told Newsday.
Why he joined
Roosevelt's own reasons for joining were described that week by John A. Gable, executive director of the Theodore Roosevelt Association. Roosevelt valued the lodge, Gable said, because it was a good way to stay in touch with the ordinary people of Oyster Bay. "They were baymen and farmers and he had known most of them all his life. The estate people were not members." Obes put it more simply: the lodge was the one place Roosevelt could be "just another brother."
Foote's own answer was practical. "I like the stuff they do," he said. "It's basically a service organization. They raise millions of dollars for charitable causes."
No one carried him up the stairs
Asked whether he expected to be passed hand over hand to the lodge room, as legend says Roosevelt was, Foote laughed it off. The crowd would be smaller, he pointed out, because he was not the Vice President. "And besides," he said, "there are fire codes today."
Two years later, in 2003, fire destroyed the lodge's building at 14 West Main Street. The firefighters saved the Roosevelt Bible on which Foote had been raised, along with the memorial window Roosevelt's son had given in 1926. The lodge rebuilt on the same spot.
The actor and the brother
There is a particular charm in Foote's story. Most reenactors stop at the costume. Foote followed his subject through the door of the lodge, took the same obligation on the same book, and became, in one small way, exactly what Roosevelt had been: a brother of Matinecock Lodge No. 806.
Sources
Bill Bleyer, "A Centennial Moment: Lodge Honors Roosevelt Again," Newsday, April 19, 2001.
Theresa Vargas and Pat Burson, "Fire Destroys Historic Lodge," Newsday, October 26, 2003.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Theodore Roosevelt Jr. Window · Next: McKinley Resolution → · Notable Freemasons of Queens
Related on BreteMurphy.com