Part 14 of Across the County Line · ← Previous: The Glen Cove Masonic Temple · Next: Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason →
A room over the village bank, a 1901 hotel that burned in 2003, and the lodge building that rose in its place.
Matinecock Lodge No. 806 has had three homes in Oyster Bay: a rented room over a bank, a converted hotel that became a town landmark, and the building that stands on that landmark's ashes. A fourth, a stone temple planned in 1923, was never built. Each tells something about a small North Shore lodge that happened to count a President among its members.
The rooms over the Oyster Bay Bank, 1894 to 1924
Matinecock received its dispensation on July 6, 1892, in the town of Oyster Bay, then part of Queens County (Craftsmen Online), received its charter on June 8, 1893, and installed its charter officers on June 21, 1893. In 1893 the Oyster Bay Bank put up a new building on Audrey Avenue, and Matinecock Lodge laid its cornerstone with Townsend Scudder and William J. Youngs speaking for the lodge. On March 1, 1894, the lodge dedicated its new lodge room in the building, with Grand Master Burnham conducting the ceremony. The Brooklyn Daily Times called it "one of the finest rooms to be found outside of the great cities of New York and Brooklyn."
This third-floor room is where Theodore Roosevelt took all three degrees in 1901. The upstairs location is also why the best-known Roosevelt story exists: the crowd on the night of his raising was so thick that, as lodge lore has it, the brothers passed him up the stairs over their heads. The lodge's own historian doubted it (Newsday, April 19, 2001). The Oyster Bay Bank Building still stands.
The temple that was planned, 1922 to 1923
By the early 1920s the lodge wanted its own building. In July 1922 it staged a two-night benefit, a house-party comedy and musical program, whose proceeds were "to be used for building the new Masonic Temple at Oyster Bay." In March 1923 the Brooklyn Eagle reported that plans were complete for a stone temple, two and a half stories high and costing $35,000, on a plot 119 by 97 feet at West Main Street and Maxwell Avenue. The first floor was to hold a banquet hall, club room, reading room and kitchen. The second floor would be one large meeting room. Dr. Charles S. Geary chaired a 25-member building committee.
14 West Main Street, 1924 to 2003
The stone temple was not built. Instead, in 1924, the lodge bought an existing building at 14 West Main Street. According to lodge historian John Hammond, it had been built in 1901 by Charles DeKay Townsend as a hotel and restaurant. For nearly 80 years it was Matinecock's home. In 1926 Theodore Roosevelt Jr. dedicated a stained-glass memorial window there to mark the 25th anniversary of his father joining the lodge.
On March 10, 1987, the Town of Oyster Bay designated the building a town landmark (List of Town of Oyster Bay Landmarks). The next year, on November 1, 1988, Roome Lodge No. 746 merged into Matinecock, which kept its name and number.
The fire of October 25, 2003
At about 2:30 on the morning of Saturday, October 25, 2003, fire broke out in the basement. At its peak, 13 fire departments and about 120 firefighters fought the blaze. By the time it was contained at about 6 a.m., parts of the first and second floors and the roof had collapsed, and the town ordered the building demolished.
Firefighters paused their attack to carry out artifacts. They saved the 1926 memorial window and the Bible on which Roosevelt had taken his obligations. Books, documents and Masonic medals going back to the early 1800s were burned, soaked or lost. "It's our home," Master Efrain Azmitia told Newsday. "The family is still intact. We just don't have a place to live." Until it found a new home, the lodge met in the Atlantic Steamer firehouse, which Azmitia noted was where the lodge had started a century before (Newsday, October 26, 2003). Within a week, the Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot reported, the rubble was fenced off and the Masons had promised to rebuild (Enterprise-Pilot report, reposted).
The lodge today
They kept the promise. A Matinecock Lodge building again stands at 14 West Main Street, with a marker erected by the lodge: "Masonic Lodge of President Theodore Roosevelt, 26th President of the United States. Raised to a Master Mason April 24, 1901" (Historical Marker Database). The town's landmark list records the original building as destroyed by fire and recommended for de-listing. Glen Cove Lodge No. 580, which helped found Matinecock, now meets at the same address.
Sources
"To Dedicate the New Lodge Rooms To-night," Brooklyn Daily Times, March 1, 1894.
Brooklyn Daily Times, July 21, 1894 (Oyster Bay Bank building and cornerstone).
"Hold Benefit for Masonic Temple," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, July 30, 1922.
"Oyster Bay Lodge Draws Plans for Masonic Temple," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 7, 1923.
Bill Bleyer, "A Centennial Moment: Lodge Honors Roosevelt Again," Newsday, April 19, 2001.
Theresa Vargas and Pat Burson, "Fire Destroys Historic Lodge," Newsday, October 26, 2003.
Dagmar Fors Karppi, "Matinecock Lodge Demolished After Fire," Oyster Bay Enterprise-Pilot, October 31, 2003, reposted online.
Ronald J. Seifried, Theodore Roosevelt and Matinecock Lodge, Craftsmen Online.
List of Town of Oyster Bay Landmarks, Wikipedia.
Matinecock Lodge marker, Historical Marker Database, photographed 2015.
Grand Lodge of the State of New York, consolidation records (Matinecock Lodge No. 806, chartered June 8, 1893; Roome Lodge No. 746, chartered in New York June 11, 1874, merged into Matinecock November 1, 1988).
Continue Reading
← Previous: The Glen Cove Masonic Temple · Next: Theodore Roosevelt Becomes a Freemason → · Series Guide
Related on BreteMurphy.com