Part 6 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Queens County Lodge No. 354 · Next: Military Lodges in Occupied Brooklyn and Queens →
Huntington, Morton, Newtown Union and Queens County lodges laid no cornerstones inside today's Queens. They met in houses, taverns and rented rooms. The temples came a generation later, built by the lodges that grew up in their territory.
If you go looking for the buildings of Queens' first lodges, you find almost nothing. Huntington Lodge No. 26, Morton Lodge No. 63, Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 and Queens County Lodge No. 354 built no temples inside today's borough. The earliest of them met in parlors and taverns. The latest met somewhere along a turnpike for two years and then left.
That is not a failure of the record. It is how lodges lived before the Civil War. A lodge needed a room that could be closed off, a table, a few pieces of furniture and a landlord who did not ask questions. Owning a building came later, with railroads, real estate companies and members who had mortgages of their own. The four early lodges show the first stage. Their daughter lodges show the second.
At a Glance
| Lodge or line | Meeting place | Where | Dates | Today |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Huntington No. 26 | Members' houses and taverns | Oyster Bay, Huntington, as far as Lloyd's Neck | 1793 to 1806 | No building identified |
| Morton No. 63 | Abraham Bedell's house | Hempstead, then Queens County | 1797 | Not identified |
| Morton No. 63 | Rooms called the Masonic Temple | Main and Front streets, Hempstead | From about 1860 | Not identified |
| Morton No. 63 | Room over Peter Tomas's business | East side of Main Street, Hempstead | 1888 | Not identified |
| Morton No. 63 | Masonic Temple, two stories | South side of Fulton Avenue east of Main Street, opposite the Hempstead depot | 1910 to 1911 | Unknown |
| Newtown Union No. 174 | Unknown | Newtown (Elmhurst) | From 1808 | No building identified |
| Queens County No. 354 | Unknown, near the Brick Tavern | Middle Village | 1854 to 1857 | Brick Tavern demolished |
| Progressive No. 354 | Lodge rooms | Grand and Havemeyer streets, Williamsburg | From 1857 | Unknown |
| Reliance No. 776 (the line today) | Whitestone Masonic Temple | 149-39 11th Avenue, Whitestone | Today | Standing, in use |
| Jamaica No. 546 | Union Avenue temple, a rebuilt chapel | Jamaica | 1902 | See the Jamaica temple article |
| Cornucopia No. 563 | Masonic Temple | Broadway (now Northern Boulevard) at Union Street, Flushing | 1908 to 1990 | Demolished 2018 |
| Far Rockaway | Masonic Temple | 1845 Mott Avenue, Far Rockaway | By 1932 | Unknown |
Huntington: A Lodge of Borrowed Tables
Huntington Lodge No. 26 had a warrant that let it meet in Oyster Bay, in Queens County, or in Huntington. As far as anyone can tell, it met in members' houses and local taverns, as far north as Lloyd's Neck on the Sound (Craftsmen Online). An eighteenth-century lodge night meant food and drink around a long table, which made a tavern the natural host.
No building has been tied to the lodge. The house most often pictured with it, the Widow Blydenburgh's at Smithtown, belongs to its daughter Suffolk Lodge No. 60, which first met there in 1797. Suffolk No. 60's archives hold a late nineteenth-century photograph of the house.
Morton: Two Hundred Years of Rooms
Morton Lodge's buildings stood in Hempstead, which was part of Queens County until 1899. The lodge was instituted in Abraham Bedell's house on June 24, 1797 (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910). A later summary says it met in Hempstead for about fifty years until a fire destroyed its building, which would place the loss around the time it went dark in the late 1830s.
After its revival in 1859 the lodge met at the corner of Main and Front streets, in rooms "afterward called Masonic Temple" (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897). By 1888 it rented a room on the east side of Main Street over Peter Tomas's business (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 9, 1888). In 1897, with no hall big enough for its centennial, it borrowed Liberty Hall for supper and pitched a tent on a ten-acre field behind the lodge room.
The lodge's first owned building rose in 1910 and 1911 on the south side of Fulton Avenue east of Main Street, opposite the railroad depot. It has its own article in this series. It was two stories, with a lodge room that seated two hundred people (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, February 27, 1911). By 1920 it was valued at more than $75,000, and the $22,000 mortgage was burned in 1922. In 1925 the lodge bought the northeast corner of Fulton and Terrace avenues and sold the house there for removal, planning a new temple on the site (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 7, 1925). Whether that temple was built is still an open question.
Newtown Union: A Fort, Not a Hall
No meeting place for Newtown Union Lodge has been found. The only structure the lodge is known to have worked on is not in Queens at all. On September 1, 1814, its members joined the Grand Lodge's labor on the Brooklyn fortifications. One of those works, finished by the Masons later that month, was named Fort Masonic. It stood between Bond and Nevins streets near State Street, where a 1914 tablet still marks the block (Historical Marker Database). The full story is in Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 and Fort Masonic.
Queens County: The Tavern on the Turnpike
Queens County Lodge left one small clue. When charter member Henry Hadkins died in 1856, his funeral was held from his house "near the Brick Tavern" in Middle Village (Brooklyn Daily Times, November 17, 1856). The tavern, built by Samuel Way in 1845, was three stories of handmade brick on the north side of the turnpike just west of today's 78th Street, the largest inn in the area (QNS). It was later sold to John Schneider, who ran it as the Middle Village Hotel. It would have been the obvious place for a village lodge to rent a room, though no record yet says it did.
After 1857 the line met at Grand and Havemeyer streets in Williamsburg, later in Brooklyn temples, and today at the Whitestone Masonic Temple, 149-39 11th Avenue, as Reliance Lodge No. 776.
The Daughters Build
The Queens temples in this family were built by the lodges that grew up in Morton's old territory.
Jamaica. In 1902 Jamaica Lodge No. 546 left its rooms in the Jamaica Town Hall and moved into its own temple on Union Avenue, a church chapel it had bought, moved and rebuilt. In 1909 it contracted with M. P. Möller for a $2,500 organ. The building has its own article: Jamaica Lodge on Union Avenue.
Flushing. Cornucopia Lodge No. 563, whose charter members came mostly from Morton, laid the cornerstone of its temple on Broadway, now Northern Boulevard, at Union Street in 1908. The building, later 137-70 Northern Boulevard, also housed Service Lodge No. 1009. Cornucopia sold it in 1990, and it was demolished in 2018. See the Flushing Masonic Temple.
Far Rockaway. Olympia Lodge No. 808, chartered in 1892, was Far Rockaway's lodge from Morton's territory. By the 1930s Far Rockaway had a Masonic Temple at 1845 Mott Avenue. Rockaway Lodge No. 1036 held funerals and degree work there, and in 1918 the First Masonic District's past masters met in "the Masonic Temple at Far Rockaway" with an Olympia officer in the senior warden's chair (Brooklyn Daily Times, December 27, 1918; Times Union, August 2, 1932). Olympia has since merged and now meets on Long Island as Guiding Light Olympia No. 808.
What the Pattern Shows
The early lodges met where their members already went: a neighbor's parlor, an inn on the market road, a room over a store. Their buildings were borrowed because their towns were small and their members spread out.
The temples came when Queens changed. Jamaica's and Flushing's lodges built in the decade after consolidation in 1898, when rail lines and real estate money were turning villages into neighborhoods. The oldest lines left the fewest buildings. The lodges they spawned left cornerstones, and some of those cornerstones are now gone too.
Sources
Ronald J. Seifried, "Huntington No. 26 A.Y.M.", Craftsmen Online.
"Morton Lodge Centennial," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897, p. 12.
Brooklyn Daily Times, August 9, 1888, p. 4; August 22, 1910, p. 6.
Brooklyn Daily Eagle, February 27, 1911, p. 6; March 14, 1920, p. 62; January 7, 1925, p. 17.
Brooklyn Daily Times, November 17, 1856, p. 2; November 12, 1922, p. 8; December 27, 1918, p. 9.
Times Union, August 2, 1932, p. 7.
Historical Marker Database, "Fort Masonic".
QNS, "Middle Village grew around this old town tavern"; Juniper Park Civic Association, Brick Tavern history.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Queens County Lodge No. 354, From Middle Village to Whitestone
Next: Military Masonic Lodges in British-Occupied Brooklyn and Queens →