Part 4 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Morton Lodge's Masonic Temple · Next: Queens County Lodge No. 354 →
Newtown Union Lodge appears in the record three times: at its chartering in 1808, on the Brooklyn fortifications in 1814, and in a list of lodges that had "long since passed away." Those three facts are enough to place a village lodge inside the city's wartime emergency.
On the morning of September 1, 1814, the Grand Lodge of New York opened an emergency session in City Hall and marched to the East River. Seventeen city lodges walked behind it in aprons, their officers wearing their jewels, while a band played patriotic airs. In Brooklyn two more lodges fell in. One was Fortitude Lodge No. 84 of Brooklyn. The other had come from the farm town of Newtown: Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 (McClenachan, History, vol. 2, pp. 55 to 57).
That line in the Grand Lodge minutes is most of what survives of the lodge. It deserves a closer look, because it shows a village lodge answering a city's call in the most frightening month of the War of 1812.
Fact One: A Charter in 1808
The Grand Lodge's warrant list records "174 Newtown Union, Newtown, Oct. 1, 1808" (Peter Ross's 1901 report, compiled by Gary L. Heinmiller). The same pages show what kind of year that was for New York Freemasonry. Eagle Lodge in Spencer and Ulysses was warranted in July, and Charity Lodge in Tompkins in September, both in the farming country upstate. The fraternity was spreading fast into rural towns, and Newtown was one of them.
Newtown in 1808 was an old English town of farms that fed the New York market. Its people grew vegetables, fruit and hay for Manhattan and hauled them to the East River landings. The town grew slowly: the 1790 census counted 2,111 people, and forty years later it had added only about five hundred more (James Riker, The Annals of Newtown). Slavery was still legal in New York and would not end there until 1827. In 1809, St. James Church in the village finally became a parish of its own, separate from Jamaica (Forgotten New York).
No source names the lodge's founders, its meeting place, or the meaning of "Union" in its name. Village lodges of the period usually met in a tavern's upper room or a member's house, and Newtown Union probably did the same.
Fact Two: September 1, 1814
The war reached New York's doorstep in late August 1814. On August 24 British troops entered Washington and burned the Capitol and the President's House. New York, the country's busiest port, expected to be next. The city's Committee of Defence, chaired by Nicholas Fish, set citizens to work on earthworks at Brooklyn Heights and Harlem, assigning a trade, a ward or a society to each day.
On August 22 Grand Master DeWitt Clinton, who was also the city's mayor, called the Grand Lodge into emergency session. It resolved to give a day's labor on the fortifications and asked the lodges "and the fraternity in general" to join. The notice in the Evening Post added a line that probably brought Newtown in: "The Fraternities of the Neighborhood are requested to join the Grand Lodge on this occasion" (Evening Post, August 24, 1814). The day assigned was Thursday, September 1.
Queens was already at work. The same week, the Committee thanked the township of Jamaica for 120 wagonloads of fascines, bundles of brush used to shore up earthworks, brought to Fort Green by its citizens under the Rev. Mr. Schoonmaker. The principal of Jamaica's academy and his pupils had helped cut them (Evening Post, August 30, 1814).
The Committee's daily work lists in the Evening Post show the scale of the effort. For Brooklyn on Wednesday, August 31, it listed the Tammany and Columbian societies with 1,150 men, the watchmakers, jewellers and silversmiths with 200, and the inhabitants of the First Ward. The next entry read simply: "Thursday, for Brooklyn, The Grand Lodge of the State of New-York." For a day, the fraternity was a work gang in the city's rota, like a trade or a political society.
The Masons assembled at sunrise in front of City Hall, each lodge providing its own refreshment. "Every brother will be clothed with an apron," the order of arrangements said, and "all superfluous decorations" were to be left at home. They crossed to Brooklyn, where Fortitude and Newtown Union joined them, labored through the day, and returned in procession to City Hall, where the Grand Lodge closed. For the Newtown men this meant a journey of several miles to the Brooklyn works, and then a full day of digging and hauling. The minutes do not say how many came.
What the Masons Were Building
The work Newtown Union joined was part of a line of earthworks across the high ground behind Brooklyn, from Gowanus Creek to Wallabout Bay. Much of it reused the lines of 1776, thrown up before the Battle of Long Island. Henry Stiles, Brooklyn's nineteenth-century historian, records that the old Cobble Hill fort was strengthened in 1814 and called Fort Swift, and that Fort Putnam was strengthened and called Fort Greene (Stiles, A History of the City of Brooklyn). That 1814 Fort Greene, on the site of today's Fort Greene Park, was the largest of the Brooklyn works, mounting twenty-three heavy cannon. Between it and Gowanus Creek stood smaller works: Fort Cummings, Fort Masonic, the Washington Battery and Fort Fireman (FortWiki).
The names are a trap. Fort Masonic was not built at Fort Greene Park. The New York State Military Museum describes it as a rebuilding of the first Fort Greene, a star-shaped fort of 1776 that stood above present-day Bond Street between State and Schermerhorn streets. After the British took the city, that fort may have been renamed Fort Sutherland (New York State Military Museum). When the Revolutionary Fort Putnam was rebuilt in 1814 and given the name Fort Greene, the name moved half a mile north, and the old Fort Greene got a new name of its own. The Bowery Boys have argued that today's Fort Greene neighborhood should really be called Fort Putnam.
Albert Mackey's Encyclopedia of Freemasonry gives the fort's shape: a quadrangle between what became Bond and Nevins streets, its south point on State Street, running north nearly to Schermerhorn Street. It was a redoubt, an enclosed earthwork for infantry and guns, not a stone fortress. The "Heights of Brooklyn" in the 1814 notices meant the whole ridge, not today's Brooklyn Heights neighborhood by the river.
Rain, Roll Books and a Keystone
By September 7 the work already had a name. At its quarterly meeting that night, the Grand Lodge resolved to give another day "towards completing the Fort at Brooklyn Heights, called in honor of the craft, Fort Masonic." Masters were told to assemble their lodges in the Park at sunrise on Saturday, September 17, and march to Brooklyn "in the same order" as on September 1 (Evening Post, September 14, 1814).
The lodges' notices in the Evening Post that week read like a small anthology of Masonic wit. Independent Royal Arch Lodge No. 2 headed its call "From Refreshment to Labor." Adelphi Lodge No. 18 chose "Be not weary in well-doing." Phoenix Lodge No. 11 invited "former members and sojourners" to sign rolls left at three shops on Water, Front and South streets (Evening Post, September 15 and 17, 1814). The appeal reached Masons who no longer belonged to any lodge.
Then it rained. On September 17 the Grand Secretary announced that "the continued bad state of weather" had pushed the work to Monday, September 19. St. John's Lodge No. 1 called its members to City Hall at sunrise to help lay "the key stone to fort Masonic" (Evening Post, September 17, 1814).
The Committee of Defence's list for that Monday shows who else was digging. For Brooklyn it named Neptune's Corps of Sea Fencibles, with 90 men, and "Grand Lodge and Free Masons under it, 700." For Harlem it named "People of Colour, 1000." The Washington Society, the butchers of New York and 200 men from Passaic in Bergen County appear on the same list. On that day's list, Black New Yorkers outnumbered the Masons.
That line deserves a story of its own. In 1814 slavery was still legal in New York. The gradual emancipation law of 1799 freed children born after that year only when they reached adulthood, and final emancipation did not come until 1827. The list does not say whether the thousand men were free or enslaved, or who organized them. In his history of Black Manhattan, A Moment in the Sun, Shane White describes Black New Yorkers turning out in large numbers to build and repair the city's defenses that summer, a first generation of free Black residents eager to show they belonged. That autumn the legislature passed a bill authorizing the governor to accept the service of Black soldiers (William Lloyd Garrison, The Loyalty and Devotion of Colored Americans). The Masons got a bronze tablet for their day at Fort Masonic. The Black volunteers' day at Harlem has no marker at all.
According to McClenachan, the Masons labored on the fort all day on September 19 and returned in procession to City Hall, "when the Grand Lodge retired to a room in the building, and duly closed." He added: "This closed the military work of the Grand Lodge." The Grand Lodge met once more that month, on September 22. No surviving record places Newtown Union at the second day's work.
What Became of the Fort
Fort Masonic never fired a shot. The British struck at Plattsburgh instead and were beaten there on September 11, while the Masons were still waiting for dry weather. The war ended with the Battle of New Orleans on January 8, 1815, and the treaty of peace was ratified that February. Fort Masonic was abandoned as a fortification in 1815 (FortWiki).
Brooklyn's street grid gradually covered the old ridge. A century later, in September 1914, the Temple Club of the Fourth Masonic District marked the centennial with a bronze tablet: "On this block midway between Nevins and Bond Streets stood Fort Masonic, erected September 1814 by the members of the Masonic Fraternity as a part of the defences of New York City during the War of 1812-1815" (Historical Marker Database). FortWiki says the tablet was first placed on the former Harriet Judson YWCA building. It now hangs at State and Nevins streets, near 450 State Street. When Brownstoner noticed it in 2007, it asked whether anyone had ever seen a picture of the fort. As far as anyone has reported, none exists.
Fact Three: "Long Since Passed Away"
The third fact comes from 1901. In a report to the Grand Lodge, Grand Historian Peter Ross listed the lodges of 1814 and noted which had since disappeared. Newtown's lodge is among those that had "long since passed away." Grand Lodge records give the charter date, but the date the lodge surrendered its charter is uncertain.
The likeliest window is the late 1820s and early 1830s. After the disappearance of William Morgan in western New York in 1826, an Anti-Masonic movement swept the state. About two-thirds of New York's lodges, some four hundred, suspended work and became extinct (Templar History). In June 1832 alone, the Grand Lodge declared the warrants of 84 lodges forfeited. A small rural lodge near the city could easily have been one of them, though its name has not yet turned up in a forfeiture list.
What Is Left
Newtown Union left no hall, no minute book, and no member whose name we know. It left a charter date, one day's work in the city's defense, and a line in a historian's list.
That is still enough to correct one assumption. The history of Queens Freemasonry is often told as a story of the late nineteenth century, of temples near railroad stations and suburban lodges. Before any of that, a lodge from what is now Elmhurst walked to Brooklyn with shovels when the city asked.
Five Myths About Fort Masonic
Fort Masonic has gathered a small body of legend in two centuries. Five claims turn up again and again on Masonic websites and in older encyclopedias, and each one breaks down against the 1814 record.
Myth 1: It stood in the Bronx. One widely shared online account puts the fort at "Fort Green in what is now the Bronx." The 1814 notices, Mackey's encyclopedia and the 1914 tablet all place it in Brooklyn, on the block between Bond and Nevins streets near State Street. The confusion probably comes from the name Fort Greene, which in 1814 belonged to a different Brooklyn fort, and from the many Harlem works built the same summer.
Myth 2: Fourteen lodges built it in a single day. Mackey wrote that the fort was built by "members of the fourteen Lodges located in New York City." The Grand Lodge minutes, as McClenachan prints them, name seventeen lodges in the September 1 procession, joined in Brooklyn by Fortitude and Newtown Union, for nineteen in all. The work was not done in a day, either. The Masons gave one day on September 1 and returned on September 19 to finish the fort and lay its keystone.
Myth 3: It was completed on September 17. Several accounts, Mackey's among them, give September 17 as the day the work was finished. That was the day the Grand Lodge planned. The Evening Post of that date announced that bad weather had postponed the work until Monday, September 19, and McClenachan's account of the minutes agrees.
Myth 4: Some 750 Masons did the work. FortWiki gives "some 750" Masons. The only contemporary figure is the Committee of Defence's work list for September 19, which assigned "Grand Lodge and Free Masons under it, 700" to Brooklyn. That was a planned number, not a head count, and no figure at all survives for September 1.
Myth 5: It saved New York from attack. The same online account claims that because the fort existed, "the British army skirted New York City" and attacked Plattsburgh instead. Nothing in the record supports this. The British campaign down Lake Champlain was already under way, and the battle there was fought on September 11, before the Masons' second day of digging. Fort Masonic was one small redoubt among dozens of works around the harbor, built by thousands of volunteers. The fort is a good story about civic duty. It does not need to have changed the course of the war to be worth telling.
Sources
Charles T. McClenachan, History of the Most Ancient and Honorable Fraternity of Free and Accepted Masons in New York, vol. 2 (1892), pp. 55 to 57, drawing on the minutes printed in Early History and Transactions of the Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons of the State of New York, 1781-1815 (1876).
Peter Ross, report in Proceedings of the Grand Lodge of the State of New York (1901), compiled by Gary L. Heinmiller, "Grand Lodge of New York in the War of 1812".
Evening Post (New York), August 24 and 30, and September 14, 15 and 17, 1814.
James Riker Jr., The Annals of Newtown (1852).
Henry R. Stiles, A History of the City of Brooklyn (1867).
New York State Military Museum, "Masonic, Fort" and "Greene, Fort".
FortWiki, "Fort Masonic", "Fort Greene" and "Fort Swift".
Historical Marker Database, "Fort Masonic".
Brownstoner, "Where Fort Masonic Once Stood" (2007).
Albert G. Mackey, Encyclopedia of Freemasonry, "Fort Masonic."
Shane White, A Moment in the Sun: Black Manhattan Before the Civil War (W. W. Norton).
William Lloyd Garrison, The Loyalty and Devotion of Colored Americans in the Revolution and War of 1812 (1861).