Part 1 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Start Here · Next: Morton Lodge No. 63 →
Its 1793 warrant let it meet in Oyster Bay, Queens County, or in Huntington. Its members lived from Setauket to Hempstead. The island's distances wore it out, and its members founded the lodges that outlived it.
In the 1790s, a Long Island Mason who wanted to go to lodge might set out hours before the meeting with a friend and one horse. One man rode ahead to an agreed spot, tied the horse to a tree and walked on. The other walked to the horse, rode past his friend to the next spot, tied it and walked. They swapped like that for miles, sat down at the long table, slept nearby, and went home the next day the same way. They called it "ride and tie."
That image sums up Huntington Lodge No. 26 better than any charter. It was Long Island's first lasting lodge, and its members were spread so thinly across the island that getting to a meeting took two days.
Before the First Lodge
Long Island came out of the Revolution battered. British and Loyalist troops had occupied Kings, Queens and Suffolk counties from 1776 to 1783. Farms were stripped, woodlots cut, and families divided between the two sides. Freemasonry had taken root in New York City, but the island's first attempts at lodges did not last.
In February 1784 three men petitioned to form "Long Island Lodge" in Brooklyn, and nothing more is heard of it. In September 1787 brothers living in Jamaica received a charter for Jamaica Lodge. Its only recorded act was marching in the St. John the Baptist procession in New York on June 24, 1789, and it had surrendered its charter by 1793 (Craftsmen Online).
A President Passes Through
In April 1790 President George Washington toured Long Island for five days to thank the towns that had supported the cause. Masonic writers have long linked two of his stops to what came next. On April 23 he dined at the Widow Blydenburgh's in Smithtown, the house where Suffolk Lodge would hold its first meeting in 1797. On April 24 he visited Hendrick Onderdonk's house and paper mill at Roslyn. Onderdonk's daughter Sarah was married to David Richard Floyd Jones, who became a charter member and master of Huntington Lodge and then the first master of Morton Lodge.
Whether the tour inspired the lodge is a story told afterward. What the record shows is that the men Washington met soon organized Freemasonry on the island.
A Warrant With Two Addresses
The petitioners were led by Moses Blachly (1769 to 1828), Huntington's first postmaster, and they came from Setauket in the east to Hempstead in the west. On March 22, 1793, the Grand Lodge of New York granted their warrant. Its wording is unusual. The lodge was "to be formed in the town of Oyster Bay in Queens County, or in the town of Huntington in Suffolk County," at the option of its officers and brethren (Wikipedia, citing Ronald J. Seifried's Long Island Freemasons). Craftsmen Online describes the warrant as issued for "Huntington Lodge No. 26 Ancient York Masons of Oyster Bay, Queens County."
That detail explains why the Grand Lodge's records treat Huntington No. 26 as a Queens District lodge. Oyster Bay, Hempstead and North Hempstead stayed in Queens County until Nassau County was carved out of them in 1899. Hempstead's Morton Lodge later described No. 26 as "located at Oyster Bay" (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910). The lodge carried the name of a Suffolk town, but in practice it was a lodge for the whole middle of the island.
For four years it was the only active lodge in what are now Nassau and Suffolk counties.
Tavern Tables and a Long Road
Huntington No. 26 never had a building of its own. It most likely met in members' houses and in taverns, as far north as Lloyd's Neck on the Sound. That was normal for the time. An eighteenth-century lodge met around a long table with food and drink, and its dues were owed at every meeting, whether a brother came or not.
The distances were not normal. Setauket and Hempstead are nearly thirty miles apart in a straight line, and farther by sandy cart road. A lodge night meant a day lost from the farm or the shop, a night's lodging, and the ride-and-tie relay home. Hempstead's Masons told a version of the same story at Morton Lodge's centennial in 1897: two brothers from the north side of the island, perhaps twenty miles away, sharing one farm horse to reach the lodge (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897).
The Children Leave Home
The answer to distance was more lodges. On April 7, 1796, Master Floyd Jones read the lodge a petition from Port Jefferson asking for help in forming a lodge there, with Blachly as its first master. The help was "enthusiastically given" (Jephtha Lodge No. 494). Suffolk Lodge received its warrant on December 7, 1796, and held its first meeting on March 9, 1797, at the Widow Blydenburgh's in Smithtown. Seven brothers from Huntington No. 26 attended, along with "Brother Fagen from Ireland."
Six months later the Hempstead men followed. Eight members of No. 26 living there asked for a lodge of their own, citing "the distance they live from Said place of Meeting and the fatigue and trouble which an attendance Thereon creates." The warrant for Morton Lodge No. 63 was granted on June 23, 1797. Morton was instituted the next day at Abraham Bedell's house in Hempstead, with Huntington Lodge assisting, and Floyd Jones became its master for most of the next twenty years.
Of the thirty members of No. 26 known today, sixteen became charter members of these two lodges. The mother lodge had, in effect, divided itself in two.
Mourning Washington
One shared moment survives. In January 1800 Morton Lodge voted to dress in mourning for six months for George Washington, who had died in December. On Huntington Lodge's invitation, Morton then joined it in a memorial service, though the minutes did not record the date (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897). Ten years after the president's ride across the island, the lodge his hosts had built joined its daughter in mourning him.
A Master Mason certificate issued by Huntington No. 26 to David Harrison on December 6, 1801, survives in the archives of Jephtha Lodge No. 494. It is among the last signs of a working lodge.
Fading Out
By 1802 Huntington No. 26 had dropped off the Masonic Register, possibly for not paying its dues, which was common among country lodges of the time. It met only now and then after that. On December 2, 1818, the Grand Lodge reported that the warrant and minute book had been surrendered, "from which it appeared that said Lodge had not met since the 2d of August, 5806" (1806). The late master, Rulef Duryea, reported that its funds and property had been "dispersed and lost." The Grand Lodge's records give March 4, 1818, as the date the warrant was forfeited.
The reasons are not mysterious. The lodge's most active members had moved to Suffolk and Morton, which were closer to home. What remained had no central town, no hall and no money. The island had produced enough Masons for three lodges, but not enough to keep one going across thirty miles.
Huntington itself then had no lodge for more than forty years. In late 1859 a group met in Northport to plan Jephtha Lodge, which was chartered on January 25, 1860, and still meets in Huntington. Its members later helped form lodges in Northport, Babylon, Oyster Bay and Glen Cove.
What the Lodge Left
Huntington No. 26 left no building, and the minute book it handed in has not been reported since. What it left were institutions. Suffolk No. 60 continues at Port Jefferson. Morton No. 63 continues as Wantagh-Morton No. 63 in Baldwin. Through Morton's territory came Jamaica, Cornucopia, Olympia and Massapequa lodges, and through them much of the Masonry of eastern Queens.
That is a strange kind of success for a lodge that failed. It was founded for an island too wide to share one lodge, and it solved the problem by sending its members home to found their own.
Sources
Ronald J. Seifried, "Huntington No. 26 A.Y.M., Long Island's First Masonic Lodge", Craftsmen Online.
Ronald J. Seifried, Long Island Freemasons (Arcadia Publishing, 2020), as cited in Wikipedia, "Jephtha Masonic Lodge No. 494".
Jephtha Lodge No. 494, Lodge History.
"Morton Lodge Centennial," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897, p. 12.
Address of Frederick P. Morris, Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910, p. 6.
Grand Lodge of New York, charter and forfeiture records.