Queens County Lodge No. 354: From Middle Village to Williamsburg to Whitestone

Part 5 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 · Next: Where the First Queens Lodges Met →

Chartered in 1855 at a turnpike village midway between Williamsburgh and Jamaica, Queens County Lodge could not hold its members. It followed the road to Brooklyn, renamed itself Progressive, and came back to Queens more than a century later through a chain of mergers.

In November 1856 the members of Queens County Lodge No. 354 were summoned to a funeral in Middle Village. Henry Hadkins, one of their charter members, had died of congestion of the lungs in his fiftieth year. He was to be buried from his house "near the Brick Tavern," and the notice in the Brooklyn Daily Times asked two lodges to attend: Marsh Lodge No. 188 of Williamsburgh, and his own (Brooklyn Daily Times, November 17, 1856).

The notice is the earliest trace of the lodge in the papers. It is also a fair map of its problem. Hadkins lived on a turnpike, beside a tavern, in a village whose reason for existing was that it sat halfway between two other places. Within months of his funeral, his lodge would ask the Grand Lodge for permission to leave.

A Village at the Halfway Mark

Middle Village owed its name to a toll road. The Williamsburgh and Jamaica Turnpike, today's Metropolitan Avenue, opened around 1816, and the hamlet that grew up along it sat roughly halfway between the Williamsburgh ferry landing and Jamaica. Farmers from eastern Queens drove their wagons through it to the Brooklyn and Manhattan markets. Inns, stores and blacksmiths lined the road to serve them.

The largest of the inns was the Brick Tavern, a three-story hotel that Samuel Way built in 1845 on the north side of the turnpike, just west of today's 78th Street (Juniper Park Civic Association). It was the kind of building a lodge of that era might rent a room in, though no source yet places Queens County Lodge there.

In 1852 the village found a second trade. A state law of 1847 had barred new cemeteries in Manhattan, and German churches of Kleindeutschland bought farmland along the turnpike for what became Lutheran Cemetery. Funeral processions, monument cutters and florists followed. By 1880 Lutheran Cemetery alone took more than 3,800 burials a year, and a county history of the day called the cemetery the "principal industry of the people in the vicinity" (Juniper Park Civic Association).

So when ten men organized a lodge here in 1854, they were building on a crossroads that served travelers, farmers and mourners. It had no large settled population of its own.

Ten Men and a County's Name

Queens County Lodge began work under dispensation on October 4, 1854, and the Grand Lodge of New York chartered it as No. 354 on June 13, 1855. An 1877 sketch of the lodge lists its charter members as John Rafter, David Miller, James R. Coffee, P. McBride, J. W. Shaw, F. H. Harper, Henry Hadkins, Chris Staley, Obadiah Smith and John Frost (Brooklyn Daily Times, September 3, 1877).

The name was a claim. In 1855 Queens County still ran from Newtown to the Suffolk line, taking in Flushing, Jamaica, Hempstead, North Hempstead and Oyster Bay. Its older lodges had come and gone. Jamaica's first lodge had folded by 1793, Newtown Union was long extinct, and Morton No. 63 at Hempstead lay dormant until 1859. For a few years, then, a lodge in a turnpike village was the one carrying the county's name on the Grand Lodge register.

The Harper name may be one more thread to pull. In the 1870s a hotelkeeper named Charles Kattenstroh leased "the Harper house" from Lutheran Cemetery for a saloon and hotel serving market farmers (Juniper Park Civic Association). Whether that was the house of charter member F. H. Harper is not yet known.

An Up-Hill Struggle

The 1877 sketch is blunt about what happened next. The lodge "had an up-hill struggle for existence about this time because of the inconvenience of its location." It could not draw new members, and transportation was the trouble.

The turnpike explains both. A lodge meets at night, usually twice a month, and its candidates have to come back three times to take their degrees. In 1855 Middle Village had no rail line and no horsecar. The tracks of the North Second Street and Middle Village Railroad were not authorized to run down the turnpike until 1869, twelve years after the lodge had gone (Juniper Park Civic Association). Members who lived in Maspeth, Newtown or Jamaica faced miles of dark toll road. Members who worked in Williamsburgh faced the same road in reverse.

The Hadkins funeral notice hints at where the pull was. Marsh Lodge No. 188 was a Williamsburgh lodge, and it was named before Queens County. The two lodges seem to have shared men and mourners from the start.

West Along the Road

The lodge petitioned the Grand Lodge for permission to move to Williamsburg, "and the reasons given appearing satisfactory to the grand body," the request was granted. The 1877 sketch names the principal movers as Brother Dunscomb, John Davies, Robert Duncan and George C. Nichols. In the early part of 1857 Williamsburg became the lodge's "adopted home," and its name was changed to Progressive Lodge No. 354.

The destination made sense. Williamsburgh had become a city in the early 1850s and was annexed to Brooklyn on January 1, 1855, as the Eastern District (Wikipedia). The Grand Street ferry had run to Manhattan since 1812. German, Irish and English immigrants were filling the new blocks. A lodge there could recruit from tens of thousands of neighbors instead of a few hundred farm families.

Progressive settled at the corner of Grand and Havemeyer streets and met every Monday evening. The new name kept the old number, which is why the line can still be traced. The name also said something about the move: a county's name had become a word for going forward.

The Williamsburg Years

Twenty years on, Progressive was what Queens County had never been: a full lodge. By 1877 its membership was "close on 200," and the press credited Worshipful Master George W. Decker, then in his second term, with making it "one of the most popular in the city." George T. Crane had been its secretary for twenty years. Charles L. Pickett was a Past Grand Steward, and William Dunscomb, one of the men who had led the move, was still active (Brooklyn Daily Times, September 3, 1877).

The lodge's life shows up in the papers the way most lodges' lives do, through ceremony and grief. In July 1877, with the thermometer "among the nineties," Progressive presented a District Deputy's gold badge to its own Thomas R. Le Count, newly appointed to the Second Masonic District, at a crowded meeting of Baltic Lodge No. 284 (Brooklyn Daily Times, July 24, 1877). In September 1883 the brethren filled their rooms to give Past Master Alfred C. Squires a gold watch from a Maiden Lane maker. Squires had also served as High Priest of Progressive Chapter No. 199 and president of the Williamsburg Masonic Board of Relief, the lodges' shared charity (Brooklyn Daily Times, September 4, 1883).

The funeral notices map the membership. Henry Eggers was buried from Sullivan Street in Manhattan in 1871. Sarah V. Mendes, wife of an Eighteenth Ward member, died of erysipelas in 1872 at about thirty-three, and Progressive's members were invited to her service at a Baptist church on Willoughby Avenue. John F. Buckmaster was buried by the lodge in January 1879. Progressive's men lived across Brooklyn and over the river, which a ferry-district lodge could support and a turnpike lodge could not.

A Williamsburg Master Goes to Rockville Centre

In 1897 the line touched old Queens County again. Massapequa Lodge No. 822 was instituted at Rockville Centre, then part of Queens County. Most of its twenty-eight charter members came from Morton Lodge No. 63 of Hempstead. Its first master was Thomas R. Le Count, whose move ended "thirty-six years' connection with Progressive Lodge No. 354." He had held office in Progressive for ten years and been its master for five (Brooklyn Daily Times, 1897).

Progressive did not take the loss sourly. It made two visits to the new lodge, bringing a silver-mounted gavel the first time. On institution night it sent the largest delegation of any lodge, about seventy-five men, with a silver service of urn and goblets. The Williamsburg lodge that had once left Queens was helping to build a new lodge at the county's southern edge.

The Long Contraction

The twentieth century ran the other way. Brooklyn's Eastern District lodges lost members as the old German and native-born families moved out to Queens and Long Island. After the Second World War the decline sped up, and lodges began to merge rather than close.

Grand Lodge of New York records give the sequence:

| Date | Event |

| --- | --- |

| Aug. 22, 1965 | Progressive merges with Hill Grove No. 540 as Progressive-Hill Grove No. 354 |

| Dec. 22, 1970 | Progressive-Hill Grove, Cornerstone No. 367 and Marsh No. 188 consolidate as Success Lodge No. 1169 |

| 1972 | Seawanhaka No. 678 merges into Success |

| About 1972 | Tyrian No. 618 merges into Reliance No. 776 |

| Mar. 18, 1987 | Success merges into Reliance, which keeps the name Reliance Lodge No. 776 |

One line in that table closes a circle. In 1970 Marsh Lodge No. 188 merged with the Queens County line, by then Progressive-Hill Grove No. 354, and with Cornerstone No. 367, to form Success Lodge. Marsh was the Williamsburgh lodge whose members had been summoned with Queens County's to Henry Hadkins's funeral in Middle Village in 1856. Lodges that had shared members and mourners in the 1850s ended up sharing one charter 114 years later.

Reliance itself was instituted on June 19, 1877, and its own history says it has moved seven times, "originally from Greenpoint Brooklyn to now the Whitestone Masonic Temple in Queens." Early in the twentieth century it met at the Brooklyn Masonic Temple. A newspaper profile of its forty-year members described former blacksmiths and grocery boys who had become boiler makers and grocers, some of them by then living as far out as Rockville Centre.

Back in Queens

Reliance today meets on the fourth Monday of the month at the Whitestone Masonic Temple, 149-39 11th Avenue. It starts with a meal "where the women are welcome" and describes itself as a small, close group. Along with its own name it carries the names of Progressive, Hill Grove, Cornerstone, Marsh, Seawanhaka, Tyrian and Success.

So the charter that left Middle Village in 1857 because no one could reach it is back in Queens, about six miles northeast of where it started. It came back the way most New Yorkers did in the twentieth century: east, toward parking and lower rents, following the people who had already left.

The Brick Tavern is gone, and Metropolitan Avenue is no longer a toll road. Somewhere in the minutes, if they survive, is the night ten men in a turnpike village decided the county deserved a lodge of its own. It took 130 years and seven other lodges to bring that lodge home.

Sources

  • Death notice of Henry Hadkins, Brooklyn Daily Times, November 17, 1856, p. 2.

  • "Progressive Lodge, No. 354," Brooklyn Daily Times, September 3, 1877, p. 3.

  • "Masonic Presentation," Brooklyn Daily Times, July 24, 1877, p. 4.

  • "The Squire Watched," Brooklyn Daily Times, September 4, 1883, p. 4.

  • New York Daily Herald, July 1, 1871, p. 7; Brooklyn Daily Times, April 8, 1872, p. 3; Brooklyn Daily Times, January 13, 1879, p. 3.

  • Institution of Massapequa Lodge No. 822, Brooklyn Daily Times, 1897.

  • Grand Lodge of New York records (charter of June 13, 1855; merger dates).

  • Reliance Lodge No. 776, lodge history.

  • QNS, "Middle Village grew around this old town tavern" (2024).

  • Juniper Park Civic Association, Middle Village and Lutheran Cemetery history.

  • Forgotten New York, "Middle Village, Queens".

  • Wikipedia, "Williamsburg, Brooklyn" and "Grand Street Ferry".


Continue Reading

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Where the First Queens Lodges Met: Taverns, Rented Rooms and Masonic Temples

Next
Next

Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 and Fort Masonic: Elmhurst Freemasons in the War of 1812