Part 3 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Morton Lodge No. 63 · Next: Newtown Union Lodge No. 174 →
Morton Lodge waited 113 years for a building of its own. When it finally raised one on Fulton Avenue in 1910 and 1911, Hempstead was already in Nassau County, but the lodge still belonged to a Masonic district that ran from Astoria to the East End.
On Saturday, August 20, 1910, one of the largest crowds Hempstead had seen for any ceremony gathered on Fulton Avenue. In the northeast room of an unfinished building, Grand Master Robert Judson Kenworthy opened a Grand Lodge with his whole staff of officers. Out front, sixty of the best singers from the village's Sunday schools sang between the parts of the ceremony. Then the Grand Master laid the cornerstone of the first building Morton Lodge No. 63 had ever owned (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910).
The lodge was 113 years old. It had met in Abraham Bedell's house in 1797, in rooms at Main and Front streets after its revival in 1859, and by 1888 in a room on the east side of Main Street over Peter Tomas's business. Now it was building on the south side of Fulton Avenue, east of Main Street, opposite the railroad depot. A photograph of the cornerstone ceremony survives in the New York Heritage digital collections.
A Nassau Village, a Queens District
Hempstead had left Queens County eleven years earlier. When Nassau County was created in 1899 from Hempstead, North Hempstead and Oyster Bay, the old county's western towns became the borough of Queens. Masonic boundaries did not follow the new line right away. In the first decades of the twentieth century, Morton belonged to a district that still joined the lodges of Queens to those of Nassau and Suffolk.
The papers show this plainly. When Jamaica Lodge No. 546 dedicated its Union Avenue temple in 1902, the district deputy was B. Frank Wood of Jamaica, and the expected guests were "representatives of all the lodges in Queens, Nassau and Suffolk." In January 1908, Flushing police magistrate Joseph Fitch announced his official visits as district deputy. His schedule ran: Advance Lodge in Astoria on February 4, Riverhead on February 11, Mizpah in Elmhurst on February 27, Morton in Hempstead on March 9, Anchor in College Point on March 10, Island City in Long Island City on March 23, and Babylon on March 25 (Brooklyn Daily Times, January 23, 1908). A Flushing magistrate made his round of lodges from Astoria to Riverhead, and Hempstead was one stop among them.
That was the district in which Morton built its temple. Harry L. Hedger, the district deputy who came to the new temple's first meeting in February 1911, spent the same season presiding over the birth of a Queens lodge. He presented Richmond Hill Lodge with its dispensation at Arcanum Hall in Richmond Hill and congratulated its members on plans for "a fine Masonic building" of their own. The same official was blessing a temple in Hempstead and encouraging a new lodge in Queens to build one.
The Cornerstone
The credit for the building went to Morton's master, Walter R. Jones, who had worked for years to give the lodge a home. Charles L. Phipps, a past district deputy, presented the trowel to the Grand Master, who promised that the lodge would keep it when the ceremony was over. After the stone was laid, Jones invited everyone to the lodge room for a spread for "members and guests from lodges all over the Island and Brooklyn," with a large delegation from Brooklyn's Anglo-Saxon Lodge (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910).
The address of the day came from Frederick P. Morris, who represented the Grand Lodge of England. He opened with a joke for the non-Masons in the crowd: he was not there to reveal the mysteries, he said, or "to request the ladies not to give their husbands the grip." He then gave a long history of the lodge. He told how its petitioners came from Huntington Lodge, how Jacob Morton fetched the Bible for Washington's inauguration, and how Morton had paid its $726 share of the Grand Lodge's $450,000 debt in the 1880s. The building, he said, would let the brethren say they were "at home in your own temple."
A Plain, Handsome Room
The temple was two stories, and the lodge first met in it on Monday, February 27, 1911, with District Deputy Hedger making his official visit (Brooklyn Daily Times, February 27, 1911). The Eagle described the lodge room as about fifty feet square; the Times said about sixty. It seated two hundred, and in an emergency twice that number could be crowded in. Both papers praised its plainness. The Eagle called the room "very plain, but handsome in its simplicity," with only the lodge's own paraphernalia for ornament (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, February 27, 1911). It was meant to be second to none on Long Island, and big enough for the crowds Morton drew, which the Eagle said were "as large as any in the cities."
Dedication Night
Grand Master Kenworthy came back on April 17, 1911, to dedicate the building. Long before eight o'clock the rooms were "taxed to their utmost capacity," with large delegations from Brooklyn, Manhattan and the villages of Long Island (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, April 18, 1911). Charles Phipps presented the Grand Master with an ivory gavel bound in silver. Kenworthy gave the lodge a silver trowel in return.
A building is properly dedicated on its roof, which is rarely practical, so the Grand Lodge set up a miniature lodge room in the hall and performed the rite on the box's cover, which stood for the roof. The Junior Grand Warden poured corn, for nourishment. The Senior Grand Warden poured wine, for refreshment. The Deputy Grand Master poured oil, for joy. A double male quartet sang, conducted by Dr. Francis P. Hamlet with T. Alden Skidmore at the organ, and the ceremonies ran more than an hour and a half before the collation.
The Grand Lodge officers that night included District Deputy Hedger, Senior Grand Warden Earl J. Adams, Junior Grand Warden John J. McCrum, Grand Chaplain William R. Watson, Grand Secretary Edward M. L. Ehlers and Grand Marshal Jacob C. Klinck.
The Building at Work
The temple soon earned its keep. During the First World War, Hempstead sat beside Camp Mills, and Morton held special communications for soldier Masons on their way to France. Membership rose from 346 at the start of 1918 to 625 at the end of 1919. By 1920 the Eagle valued the temple "opposite Hempstead Railroad Depot" at more than $75,000 and called Morton the largest lodge outside the city (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920).
Queens Masons kept coming. In May 1922 the Hempstead Board of Education presented a Bible to Morton Lodge, every lodge in the district was invited, and more than a thousand Masons were expected. The visitors listed included F. B. Sprague, Theodore F. Archer, S. M. Johnson, George Burnham and William J. End Jr. of Jamaica Lodge No. 546, and M. D. Gould of Cornucopia Lodge No. 563 of Flushing. Others came from Glen Cove, Jephtha in Huntington, Seawanhaka in Brooklyn, Alcyone in Northport, Meridian and Babylon (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, May 6, 1922).
That November, more than six hundred people filled the lodge room for Morton's 125th anniversary. The Grand Master burned the mortgage, which had started at $22,000 when the lodge bought the property eleven years before. On the altar lay the Bible Jacob Morton had given the lodge (Brooklyn Daily Times, November 12, 1922).
Outgrowing It
Within three years the lodge was planning again. In January 1925 Morton advertised the auction of a fourteen-room house at the northeast corner of Fulton and Terrace avenues. The house had to be moved off the lot, the notice explained, because "a Masonic Temple will be erected on the site" (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 7, 1925). Whether that second temple was built, and what became of the 1911 building, are questions this history has not yet answered.
Morton Lodge itself carried on. In 1989 it merged with Wantagh Lodge No. 1112, formed in 1931, and today Wantagh-Morton No. 63 meets at the Baldwin Masonic Temple on Prospect Street (Wantagh Morton Lodge No. 63).
The Fulton Avenue temple belongs to a short and particular moment. Hempstead had already left Queens County, but its Masons had not yet left the Queens lodges behind. For a few decades a building in Nassau stood at the center of a district that took in Jamaica, Flushing, Astoria and College Point, and on its big nights the Queens lodges came out to fill it.
Sources
"Laid Cornerstone of Masonic Temple," Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910, p. 6.
New York Heritage, "Masonic Temple, Hempstead (Village) N.Y.", cornerstone photograph.
"Masonic Visitations," Brooklyn Daily Times, January 23, 1908, p. 4.
Jamaica Lodge temple dedication notice, October 1902.
"Masons in New Home," Brooklyn Daily Times, February 27, 1911, p. 9; Brooklyn Daily Eagle, February 27, 1911, p. 6; Brooklyn Daily Times, March 4, 1911, p. 16.
Dedication report, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, April 18, 1911.
"Morton Lodge, 642 Strong," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920, p. 62.
"A Notable Masonic Event," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, May 6, 1922, p. 24.
"Masons Celebrate," Brooklyn Daily Times, November 12, 1922, p. 8.
Auction notice, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 7, 1925, p. 17.