Teaching the Horses to Pull Together

Plato's charioteer has a staffing problem.

One horse is noble and responsive. The other is loud, impatient and convinced that every passing pleasure is the destination. The driver has to get both of them up a steep road without ending in a ditch.[1]

Earlier essays in this series looked at the team itself: what the image maps, why the dark horse is not simply the enemy, and what happens when the chariot falls. This essay asks a plainer question. If the soul is a team, how does the team get trained?

Plato's answer is education. Not education as storage, but education as the turning of the whole soul. The prisoner in the Cave has eyes. He has simply spent his life facing the wall.[2] The charioteer has horses. He has simply never taught them to pull together.

Three powers, three kinds of training

In the Republic, Plato divides the soul into three parts: reason, spirit and appetite.[3] The Phaedrus gives the same division a body. Reason drives; spirit is the willing horse; appetite is the unruly one. Scholars debate how neatly the two dialogues line up, but the family resemblance is plain enough for our purposes.

Each power needs its own schooling.

Reason must learn to judge. It has to tell evidence from assertion, and a sound argument from a merely confident one.

Spirit must learn courage and honorable aspiration. Left untrained, spirit turns into touchiness: the man who defends his pride with the energy he should be spending on the truth.

Desire must learn measure. Plato does not ask the dark horse to stop pulling. He asks it to pull in the right direction, at the right speed.

Where the arts come in

The old liberal arts are usually presented as a syllabus. Read beside the charioteer, they look more like a training regimen.

Grammar, logic and rhetoric work mainly on the driver. They teach him what was actually said, what follows from it, and what he has any business persuading others to do. A driver who cannot read the road is a passenger holding reins.

Music and the mathematical arts work on the horses as much as on the driver. Plato took music seriously as a shaper of character, which can sound quaint until one watches a crowd answer a drumbeat.[4] Number and proportion teach that a part is not the whole, and that a strong desire is not automatically a large one.

Astronomy works on scale. It is hard to stay convinced that one's latest inconvenience is the center of the universe after an evening spent with the actual universe.

The full tour of the seven arts, and their place in Masonic symbolism, belongs to another series: The Middle Chamber of the Mind in The Work of Light. Here the point is narrower. The arts are not a cabinet of respectable trivia. They are exercises for a team that has to move as one.

What training cannot do

None of this guarantees anything. A dishonest man can learn grammar. A vain man can study astronomy. A cruel man can become a superb logician. Training improves the team. It does not choose the destination.

What the arts do is shrink the territory where impulse rules unopposed. They give the driver tools and the horses habits. That is not yet wisdom, but it is the ground wisdom needs.

The charioteer and the student

The student of the liberal arts is learning to hold the reins.

He learns not to believe every thought just because it has appeared in his mind.

He learns not to treat every strong emotion as a command.

He learns that a persuasive voice may be wrong, and that an argument may be elegant and false.

He learns that beauty can teach rather than merely be consumed.

He learns that the larger order of things is under no obligation to flatter his private preferences.

The mind grows freer as it grows less governed by impulse. That sounds like a paradox only until one has driven a team that will not answer the reins.

A word on the Masonic reading

Readers who know the Second Degree will hear an echo here: the liberal arts and sciences, and a symbolic ascent toward a chamber of reward. The echo is real, but it is an echo, not a line of descent. Plato's program did not become Masonic ritual. What the two traditions share is a conviction that a person becomes more capable through disciplined effort, and that the one who climbs should become more useful, not just more pleased with the view.

Where the road goes next

The charioteer's problem was never a lack of strong horses. Everyone has strong horses. The question is whether, after all the training, they finally pull the same way.

The next essay follows that question upward, to Diotima's ladder, where desire itself is educated.

Notes

  1. Plato, Phaedrus 246a–254e, on the charioteer and the two horses.
  2. Plato, Republic VII, 518c–d, on education as the turning of the soul.
  3. Plato, Republic IV, 435b–441c, on the three parts of the soul.
  4. Plato, Republic III, 398c–402a, on music and the formation of character.

Continue the Series

This essay belongs to The Chariot Within. After the fall of the chariot, the reading path asks how the soul's powers are trained, then turns to love as a ladder and where the movement of desire might lead.

Previous: The Fall of the Chariot

Next: Love as a Ladder, Not a Trap

View the series overview and reading path

Related Articles

Related reading: The Two Caves and the Work of Light


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Love as a Ladder, Not a Trap

Next
Next

The Fall of the Chariot