Seven Lodges, Thirty-Three Charters: What the Whole Set Shows About Queens

Three Manhattan charters, six nineteenth-century Queens village lodges, twenty-one boom-era lodges and three postwar additions: the thirty-three charters behind the Queens District's seven lodges trace a changing metropolitan landscape.

The Seven Lodges · Lineage 8

The Seven Lodges: Series Guide · Connecting Stories · Queens History Blog

Thirty-Three Charters, Seven Continuing Lodges

This series follows seven continuing lodges in the Queens District:

Behind them stand thirty-three charters: the seven present lodges and the earlier lodges carried into them.[1] One more, Atwood No. 208, matters to the story without belonging to the count.

Some remain visible in a present lodge's name or number. Others appear in consolidation records, anniversary booklets, newspaper notices or buildings that no longer serve their original purpose.

Read as a set, they offer a way to read the growth and reorganization of metropolitan New York: Manhattan institutions connecting with Queens, village lodges becoming city lodges, a surge of new foundations and a later gathering into fewer organizations and meeting places.

The count is specific to the histories examined here. It is not a count of every lodge that has operated in Queens.

What the Count Includes

  • Manhattan charters: 3
  • Queens village lodges chartered in the 1860s and 1870s: 6
  • Lodges chartered from 1912 through 1931: 21
  • Postwar additions: 3
  • Total: 33

The total counts only charters carried into the seven present lodges. Atwood No. 208 stands outside it: its departing members helped form Metropolitan No. 273, but Atwood itself was never absorbed.

this is am iportant distinction.

Atwood's warrant continued separately as Cyrus. It appears in this essay as a founding connection, not as part of the count and not as a merger.[2]

Every one of the thirty-three can be checked against the consolidation records. The total still cannot be turned straight into a merger count, for reasons explained below.

Ridgewood No. 710 is excluded. The Grand Lodge compilation used for the series places its consolidation in the Brooklyn District.[3]

The Manhattan Inheritance

Three of the charters, and the Atwood antecedent, begin in Manhattan in the 1850s:

  • Atwood No. 208, admitted at the December 27, 1850 union and warranted on March 4, 1851 (the antecedent; not counted).
  • Oscar Coles No. 241, later Constitution, chartered in 1851.
  • Metropolitan No. 273, chartered in 1852.
  • City No. 408, chartered in 1856.[2]

Their early settings belong to the rented halls of lower Manhattan. Crosby and Broome Streets appear in the Atwood and Oscar Coles accounts; Metropolitan's later meeting history includes several Manhattan halls.

Atwood belongs to this section because its division helps explain Metropolitan's beginning. Its separate continuation should not be mistaken for a later move into Queens.

The other three Manhattan lines connected with Queens institutions through consolidations between 1972 and 1974: Metropolitan with Whitestone, Constitution with Maspeth, and City with Service.[1]

Those transactions establish institutional movement. They do not establish that every member had already moved east, or that residential migration alone caused the combinations.

They do show why present Queens lodges carry numbers and histories older than many of the neighborhoods with which they are now associated.

Read Francis Lewis's Historical Members Directory →

The Village Lodges

Six charters belong to the Queens of separate towns before the creation of the consolidated city:

Their settings were distinct: Jamaica's county-town institutions, Flushing's village center, the industrial waterfront at Hunters Point, Astoria, College Point and Newtown.

The series records meetings in town halls, borrowed rooms and other premises before purpose-built temples became part of these histories.

Cooperation also preceded permanent buildings. Cornucopia's anniversary account records borrowed regalia at its beginning. Anchor's history remembers Cornucopia brothers traveling to College Point to assist with its work.[1]

These were not interchangeable representatives of a single borough identity. They began in communities with their own industries, institutions and local relationships.

Their later histories preserve something of that older geography.

Read Cornucopia's Connections →

Read The Tuesday Night Visitors →

The Boom-Era Majority

Twenty-one of the thirty-three charters, nearly two-thirds of the set, date from 1912 through 1931.[2]

Charter dates should not be confused with the dates when clubs organized, dispensations were issued or lodges were instituted. Several of these institutions were working before their charter year.

This concentration belongs to the same broad period as the Queensboro Bridge opening and major rapid-transit extensions into Queens.[5]

The correspondence is significant, but it does not prove that a particular railway extension caused a particular lodge to form.

The individual histories supply the closer view: Masonic clubs organizing, members petitioning for charters, building committees raising money and new lodges looking for suitable rooms.

Contemporary newspaper reports indicate the scale of activity. A January 1925 account counted twenty-six Queens lodges. Reports surrounding Tadmor's 1928 temple ceremonies described a gathering of the masters of thirty-two lodges.[4]

Those figures are dated snapshots, not an established peak count for the borough.

The surviving rosters also reveal overlapping neighborhood, occupational and family connections. They should not be treated as a complete demographic survey of either the lodges or Queens.

Read Springfield Gardens' Nine-Lodge Lineage →

Read Woodhull Lodge No. 982 →

Read Dunton Lodge No. 1017 →

The Postwar Additions

Three charters in the set came after the Second World War:

North Shore and Cardozo belong to the later development of northeastern Queens. Brandeis was chartered at Floral Park when that area belonged to the Queens District.

Their presence is a reminder that these histories are not defined entirely by present borough boundaries.

They also complicate a simple story of uninterrupted decline after the prewar boom. New lodges were still being chartered even as older institutions approached the consolidations that would reshape the district.

Consolidation and the Meaning of a Number

The consolidation sequence assembled for this series runs from 1963 to 2024.[1]

It includes two-lodge combinations and combinations involving several existing branches. Counting those transactions requires care.

A single event joining three bodies reduces the number of separate institutions by two. A name change does not necessarily add another constituent. A founding connection, such as Atwood's relationship to Metropolitan, is not a consolidation.

For those reasons, the thirty-three-charter total cannot simply be used to calculate a merger count.

The surviving numbers nevertheless make institutional continuity visible.

Harmony's No. 241 preserves a Manhattan history beginning in 1851. Francis Lewis's No. 273 preserves Metropolitan's nineteenth-century number. Springfield Gardens' No. 1057 represents a continuing body with nine constituent lodge histories.[1]

A lodge number is therefore not a straightforward measure of how long the present name has existed, or how many earlier institutions it represents.

Explore Springfield Gardens' Historical Members Directory →

Fewer Institutions, Fewer Rooms

The buildings provide a second record of change.

The series follows former temples through sale, conversion, reuse and, in some cases, demolition. Those property histories do not all share the same cause or chronology.

A sale should not automatically be explained as membership decline unless the lodge's records establish that reason.

The present meeting pattern is clearer. As of November 2026:

Francis Lewis, Cornucopia and Harmony moved to the College Point temple.

On that account, six of the seven lodges meet in two Queens buildings. The seventh meets across the county line.

District affiliation and physical meeting location are not the same thing.

Read Where the Lines Meet: The College Point Temple →

The Network Before the Consolidations

The family trees show formal succession. The connecting stories reveal relationships that a consolidation chart cannot.

Hillside provided premises for younger institutions. Advance housed other lodges. Tadmor became a host after beginning in another lodge's room. Degree teams traveled, experienced officers helped with ceremonies, and architectural work passed between building projects.

Those connections crossed lines that later diagrams place in separate branches.

They do not prove that mergers were inevitable or easy. They show that institutional independence had long coexisted with practical cooperation.

Read Lending a Hand: Degree Teams and Borrowed Rooms →

What the Whole Set Shows

The thirty-three charters reveal several patterns.

First, the present district preserves more than a history of Queens alone. Its institutional connections reach into Manhattan and across the Nassau boundary.

Second, the largest concentration of new charters belongs to the early twentieth century. Twenty-one of the thirty-three date from 1912 through 1931.

Third, separate charters did not mean separate worlds. Shared rooms, visiting teams and individual service connected lodges before formal consolidation.

Finally, continuity does not require an unchanged name or address. A number may survive several combinations. A lodge may leave its building while retaining records, relationships and an institutional identity.

The seven continuing lodges are the starting point for this series, not the limit of its history.

Behind them are constituent institutions, an antecedent charter, borrowed rooms, changing neighborhoods and generations of members whose connections reached beyond the lodge named on their dues cards.

Thirty-three charters provide the frame. The relationships between them tell the story.

Source Notes

1. Institutional Lines, Consolidations and Meeting Places

The seven series in The Seven Lodges and their Grand Lodge of New York record compilations by Brete Murphy:

Present meeting places of Cornucopia and Harmony, Francis Lewis moved to College Point temple.

2. Charter Dates and the Thirty-Three-Charter Count

The institutional compilations supply the charter chronology.

The count used here comprises:

  • Three Manhattan charters (Oscar Coles, later Constitution; Metropolitan; City).
  • Six Queens village-era charters.
  • Twenty-one charters from 1912 through 1931.
  • Three postwar charters.
  • Total: thirty-three.

Atwood No. 208 entered the Grand Lodge at the December 27, 1850 union and received its warrant on March 4, 1851. It is discussed as Metropolitan's antecedent and not counted: its warrant continued separately as Cyrus.

Institution, dispensation and charter dates remain distinct.

3. Ridgewood No. 710

An earlier draft included Ridgewood Lodge No. 710 of Brooklyn, following a 2014 Landmarks Preservation Commission press release.

The Grand Lodge compilation used for this series instead places Ridgewood's consolidation with Cypress Hill No. 1069 and Star of Hope No. 430.

Ridgewood is excluded from the thirty-three-charter total.

4. Contemporary Counts of Queens Lodges

Brooklyn Daily Times, January 4, 1925.

Brooklyn Eagle and Brooklyn Daily Times, May 1928.

Anchor-Astoria Article 1 supplies the April 19, 1926 district-division reference.

The newspaper counts are treated as dated reports, not proof of the borough's historical maximum.

5. Transportation Context

The original research notes cite nycsubway.org and station histories for rapid-transit expansion.

This essay uses that material at a broad chronological level. It does not assign a specific transit project as the cause of a lodge's formation.

The disputed exact January 1928 opening date for the Main Street extension is not required for the argument and is omitted.

6. Scope and Research Status

This essay synthesizes the author's research across the seven series.

The thirty-three-charter framework treats Atwood as an antecedent outside the count and excludes Ridgewood No. 710.

Individual charter dates, consolidation transactions, newspaper references and property histories should retain their supporting records in the relevant lodge articles.


The Seven Lodges: Series Guide · Connecting Stories

Springfield Gardens' Nine-Lodge Lineage · The College Point Temple · Queens History Blog


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

The Borough in One Room: Thomas J. Towers and the Queens Masonic Association

Next
Next

A Manhattan Number, Six Lodge Histories: The Lineage of Harmony No. 241