Part 1 of Across the County Line · ← Start Here · Next: Matinecock Lodge No. 806 →
Glen Cove Lodge No. 580: The Civil War Lodge of Old Queens County
Nine Masons petitioned for a lodge while the war was still on. Their lodge went on to give New York a Grand Master, help found seven other lodges, and never once merge.
A Petition in Wartime
On January 21, 1865, nine Master Masons met in Glen Cove and signed a petition to the Grand Master of New York. The war was not over. Lee would not surrender for almost three months, and Glen Cove's young men were still in the field.
Glen Cove was then a village in the Town of Oyster Bay, Queens County. It was a harbor town with a mill pond, a starch works and a steamboat landing. The petitioners were merchants and tradesmen. Joseph S. Armstrong was a merchant who had served in the 15th Regiment of the State National Guard, and John W. Campbell was a merchant tailor who already belonged to Jephtha Lodge in Huntington. Craftsmen Online's history of the founding dates the dispensation to February 27, 1865.
The lodge first met under that dispensation on March 16, 1865. In the chair as acting Master was J. L. Babbitt, with Edgar E. Duryea as acting Senior Warden. Their room was borrowed: the Odd Fellows' lodge room in the Wilcockson Building, at what is now 39 Glen Street.
The Soldiers Come Home
What earned Glen Cove its name as a "Civil War lodge" is who walked through the door in its first months. John Weston Campbell Jr., the tailor's son, had served in Company M of the 2nd New York Cavalry, the Harris Light Cavalry. He was initiated, passed and raised in the spring of 1865, while the lodge was still under dispensation.
So was John P. Mackey, another Company M veteran. A year later he was elected the lodge's first Senior Warden under its charter. The younger Campbell became its first Tiler.
The charter came in June 1866, granted under Grand Master Robert D. Holmes. Joseph S. Armstrong was elected the first Master. Several of the founders, including Campbell, Mackey and the Duryeas, now lie close together in the cemetery of St. Paul's Episcopal Church in Glen Cove.
A Duryea of a more famous kind sat on the lodge's roll of past masters. George Duryea, Master in 1874, 1875 and 1878, had been colonel of the 5th New York Heavy Artillery.
Five Rooms and Then a Temple
For almost half a century Glen Cove Lodge rented. Henry Isham Hazelton's 1925 county history, transcribed on the Nassau GenWeb site, traces the moves:
The Odd Fellows' room in the Wilcockson Building.
The Bowne Building, now 10 Glen Street.
The Kirk Building, now 48 Glen Street.
The Mutual Insurance Company's building.
Its own temple at 29 Continental Place, which it entered on February 5, 1913.
The temple was an unusual building. The lodge had bought the old Edgar Duryea homestead on Continental Place, which came with a parcel of land rising into a hill behind the house. The new lodge room was built into that slope so that it joined the homestead's second floor. The house itself was renovated into a clubhouse with reception, dining, smoking, billiard and chapter rooms and a library.
The lodge room measured 40 by 60 feet. Samuel J. Stammers was the architect and Joseph Martin the builder. The Brooklyn Daily Times reported the formal dedication in March 1913. The Grand Master and his staff officiated, and more than 400 Masons came from across Long Island, Brooklyn and the state. Harry L. Hedger chaired the building committee. He would later serve as district deputy grand master and would help dedicate Olympia Lodge's temple in Far Rockaway. The building has its own article, The Glen Cove Masonic Temple.
Townsend Scudder at the Organ
The best-known name in the lodge's history is Townsend Scudder: Master in 1891 and 1892, Deputy Grand Master and then Grand Master of Masons in New York in 1906 and 1907. He also served in Congress and on the State Supreme Court. Scudder has his own article, Townsend Scudder of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580.
Two details from the clippings show his place in the lodge. When he was elected Deputy Grand Master, the brethren turned out to greet him so heavily that the rooms were full before he arrived. Then in May 1923, for the first time since the charter, every living past master was to take part in one Master Mason degree. The papers singled out one detail in advance: former Justice Scudder would preside at the pipe organ.
Glen Cove also gave the Grand Lodge two district deputies, Paul H. Grimm and Harry L. Hedger, and a run of grand officers.
Mother of Seven Lodges
Hazelton credits Glen Cove Lodge with helping to establish seven other lodges:
Matinecock in Oyster Bay
Bethpage in Farmingdale
Meadow Brook in Westbury
Paumanok in Great Neck
Port Washington
Manetto in Hicksville
Mineola
Several of these names come back later in this series. Manetto, Meadow Brook, Mineola and Bethpage all became part of the line that absorbed Hollis Lodge No. 992 of Queens.
The Lodge That Never Merged
Glen Cove Lodge is one of the few lodges in this series that never consolidated with another. It still works under its original number, in the Nassau District of the Grand Lodge. It now meets at 14 West Main Street in Oyster Bay, the home of Matinecock Lodge No. 806, the lodge Glen Cove helped found in 1893.
The lodge still marks the anniversaries that matter to its members. In 2026, the twenty-fifth anniversary of September 11, Worshipful Master Jerry Boertzel built a memorial sculpture using steel recovered from Ground Zero. He took it to the Fabricator Olympics in Kempton, Pennsylvania, as Craftsmen Online reported.
Sources
Craftsmen Online, "From War to Brotherhood: The Civil War Generation That Founded Glen Cove Lodge No. 580"
Henry Isham Hazelton, The Boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens, Counties of Nassau and Suffolk, Long Island, New York, 1609-1924 (1925), Glen Cove section
Brooklyn Daily Times, March 7, 1913, p. 9 (temple dedication)
Newsday and Brooklyn Daily Times notices, 1903-1923 (Scudder receptions; the 1923 past masters' night)
Craftsmen Online, "A Brother's 9/11 Tribute," by Bro. Rob Nobile, Glen Cove Lodge No. 580
Grand Lodge of New York, Past Grand Masters
Continue Reading
← Start Here · Next: Matinecock Lodge No. 806 → · Series Guide
Related on BreteMurphy.com