"Our Brother, William McKinley": How a Rockville Centre Lodge Answered the 1901 Assassination

A portrait of President William McKinley

President William McKinley

Part 10 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: James Foote · Next: Sanford A. Davison →

When an assassin shot President McKinley, the Masons of Massapequa Lodge No. 822 met, wrote to his wife and prayed for "our afflicted brother." He died days later.

On the afternoon of September 6, 1901, President William McKinley was shaking hands in the Temple of Music at the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo when a man with a bandaged hand stepped forward and shot him twice. For a week the country waited. In Rockville Centre, then a village in Queens County, the Masons of Massapequa Lodge No. 822 did what lodges did in those days. They met, wrote a resolution, and sent it to the President's wife.

The resolution

The Brooklyn Daily Times printed the text under the heading "Sympathy for the President." At a regular meeting, the paper reported, the lodge adopted a preamble and resolution, "and a copy of the same was forwarded to Mrs. William McKinley":

"Whereas, a murderous assault has been made upon our Brother, William McKinley, President of the United States.

"Resolved, That as Masons and citizens of our beloved republic, Massapequa Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons hereby expresses its abhorrence for the deed and its perpetrator, and offer its supplication to the Supreme Grand Master, that he heal the wounds of our afflicted brother and spare him to the country, our fraternity and his family, by all of whom he is deservedly loved."

It was signed by William H. Holdsworth, Master (Brooklyn Daily Times, September 10, 1901).

Why "Brother"

The word was not a figure of speech. McKinley was a Freemason, and the story of how he became one was famous among American Masons. As a young Union officer in the winter of 1864 to 1865, quartered at Winchester, Virginia, he was struck by the sight of a Union surgeon giving money and help to Confederate prisoners, men who were Masons like himself. He asked to join the fraternity that could do that across the lines of war. He was initiated on May 1, 1865, passed on May 2 and raised on May 3 in Hiram Lodge No. 21 at Winchester, a Southern lodge, with a Confederate chaplain among those present (Phoenixmasonry; Historical Marker Database). He later became a charter member of Eagle Lodge No. 431 in Canton, Ohio.

To the brethren in Rockville Centre, then, the shooting was an attack on a member of their own fraternity, as well as on the President.

A young lodge's voice

Massapequa Lodge was only four years old. It had been instituted in Odd Fellows' Hall in Rockville Centre in June 1897, its founders drawn largely from old Morton Lodge of Hempstead, and it was growing fast. By the end of 1900 it counted eighty-two members, and that October it was preparing to raise its hundredth. Holdsworth, the Master who signed the resolution, had been elected in December 1900 and hosted the officers' supper at Munk's Hotel.

A small-town lodge addressing the First Lady might seem presumptuous. It was in fact a common practice of the period. Lodges, churches and civic clubs across the country passed resolutions in those days and mailed them to Buffalo. What makes Massapequa's notable is the choice of words. The lodge wrote as "Masons and citizens," and it called the President its brother.

The end

The prayers were not answered. McKinley seemed at first to be recovering, but infection set in, and he died in Buffalo early on September 14, 1901. Theodore Roosevelt, raised a Master Mason in Matinecock Lodge at Oyster Bay just five months earlier, became President. In the space of a week, the brethren of old Queens County had written to one Masonic president's widow and seen another of their own neighbors take the oath. After McKinley's death, his home lodge in Canton renamed itself William McKinley Lodge.

Sources


Continue Reading

← Previous: James Foote · Next: Sanford A. Davison → · Notable Freemasons of Queens

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Sanford A. Davison: The "People's Champion" of Rockville Centre and Massapequa Lodge No. 822

Next
Next

James Foote: The Theodore Roosevelt Reenactor Raised in Roosevelt's Own Lodge