How the Grand Lodge of New York Began Under British Occupation, and Its First American Grand Master

Background to Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Military Lodges in Occupied Brooklyn and Queens · Next: The Phillips Grand Lodge →

The Grand Lodge that chartered Queens' first lodges was founded in British-held New York City by army and Loyalist lodges, under a warrant from London. Within three years it was led by one of the patriot founders of the state.

The Grand Lodge of New York was founded in British-occupied New York City by military and Loyalist lodges. It held a warrant from a London Grand Lodge, and a Loyalist army chaplain was its first Grand Master. After the evacuation, the same body passed into patriot hands. Robert R. Livingston, Chancellor of the State, became Grand Master in 1784 and was the first patriot to lead it. In 1787 it declared itself independent. Whether Livingston was also the first American Grand Master depends on what you mean by American.

Before 1781: The Moderns' Provincial Grand Masters

New York's first Masonic authority came from the Premier, or "Moderns," Grand Lodge in London. In 1730 the Duke of Norfolk appointed Daniel Coxe Jr. Provincial Grand Master for New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania (Wikipedia). Coxe never took active steps to organize a Provincial Grand Lodge (Encyclopedia Masonica). Later warrants went to Francis Goelet (1738 to 1753), George Harison (1753 to 1771) and Sir John Johnson (from 1771). Johnson was a Loyalist, and he is believed to have carried his warrant with him when he fled to Canada, leaving the Moderns' lodges without a Provincial Grand Master (Wikipedia).

1781: Military Lodges Petition London

With the Moderns' authority gone, the lodges in occupied New York turned to the rival "Ancients" Grand Lodge in London. On January 23, 1781, representatives of six lodges met in the city to form a Provincial Grand Lodge, with the Rev. William Walter as Grand Master (qmhs.org). The lodges are named as Nos. 169, 441, 133, 210, Solomon's and Sion. Most were connected to the army. R. F. Gould wrote in 1880 that the Grand Lodge "in its inception, was a purely Military body," and called No. 169 "the leading Army Lodge" (The Freemason's Chronicle). Lodge No. 169 had come to New York from Boston with the British forces in 1776.

On September 5, 1781, the Duke of Atholl, Grand Master of the Ancients, signed the Provincial Grand Warrant, known as the Atholl Charter (Grand Lodge of New York). It took more than a year to cross the Atlantic. The Provincial Grand Lodge met for the first time in December 1782 at Roubalet's Assembly Hall, with Walter presiding. The Grand Lodge of New York dates its official organization to December 15, 1782.

William Walter, a Loyalist Chaplain

Walter was a Harvard man, a classmate of the patriot general Samuel Holden Parsons, and a chaplain in the royal establishment (James R. Case). He led the Grand Lodge while the British still held the city. When the army left, so did he. He resigned as Grand Master on September 19, 1783, and joined the King's troops in the evacuation (Lane's Masonic Records). William Cock succeeded him for a few months.

1784: Livingston and the Patriot Grand Lodge

In February 1784 Robert R. Livingston replaced Cock. Livingston was Chancellor of New York, a member of the committee that drafted the Declaration of Independence, and the man who would administer Washington's oath of office in 1789. He served as Grand Master until 1800. Though the Grand Lodge's charter came from the Ancients, Livingston himself belonged to a Moderns lodge, so the two English traditions came together in New York decades before they united in England in 1813 (Wikipedia).

On June 6, 1787, the Grand Lodge declared its independence and took the title "Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons of the State of New York" (Guttenberg Lodge No. 737). The Grand Masters who followed included Jacob Morton (1801 to 1805), namesake of Morton Lodge No. 63, and DeWitt Clinton (1806 to 1819), who led the Masons to the Brooklyn fortifications in 1814.

Who Was the First American Grand Master?

The answer depends on the question.

  • First patriot Grand Master, and first Grand Master of the independent Grand Lodge: Robert R. Livingston, installed in 1784.

  • First Grand Master born or raised in America: a harder question. Walter was Harvard-educated, which points to a colonial upbringing, but he served the Crown. Sir John Johnson of the earlier Moderns line was a New York colonist and also a Loyalist.

The clearest description is this: Robert R. Livingston was the first patriot Grand Master and the first Grand Master of the independent Grand Lodge of New York.

Why It Matters for Queens

The Grand Lodge that chartered Huntington No. 26 in 1793, Morton No. 63 in 1797 and Newtown Union No. 174 in 1808 was barely a decade removed from its army origins. Morton's 1797 charter bears the signatures of Livingston as Grand Master and Jacob Morton as his deputy, with DeWitt Clinton as Junior Grand Warden.

Sources


Continue Reading

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

The Phillips Grand Lodge: New York's Masonic Schism of 1849 to 1858

Next
Next

Military Masonic Lodges in British-Occupied Brooklyn and Queens, 1776 to 1783