Part 2 of Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: Huntington Lodge No. 26 · Next: Morton Lodge's Masonic Temple →
Chartered in 1797 at Hempstead, then in Queens County, Morton Lodge outlived its mother lodge, survived a fire and twenty years of silence, and watched a dozen lodges grow up in its old territory, from Flushing and Jamaica to Far Rockaway.
On the altar of Morton Lodge there is a Bible with an inscription on its flyleaf: "Presented to the worshipful master, wardens and brethren of Morton Lodge No. 63 by their affectionate brother, Jacob Morton, deputy grand master of masons of the state of New York. New York, January 8, 1798" (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 11, 1897). In 1900 the lodge said it had used that Bible at every initiation since its founding. It was on the altar again in 1922, when the lodge burned the mortgage on its temple at its 125th anniversary.
The Bible is older than most of the institutions around it. It is older than Nassau County, which did not exist when it was given. Morton Lodge was chartered at Hempstead, "County of Queens," and for most of the nineteenth century it was the lodge that held Freemasonry together across that old county.
A Charter From the Founders
Morton was born out of Huntington Lodge No. 26, whose members were scattered from Setauket to Hempstead. In 1797 a group of its Hempstead members asked for a lodge closer to home, citing "the distance they live from Said place of Meeting and the fatigue and trouble which an attendance Thereon creates" (Craftsmen Online). The Grand Lodge granted the warrant on June 23, 1797.
The charter, printed in full in 1888, carries famous signatures. Robert R. Livingston, Chancellor of the State and Grand Master, had administered the oath at Washington's first inauguration eight years earlier. The Junior Grand Warden was a young DeWitt Clinton. The charter named David Richard Floyd Jones as master, Jacob Seaman Jackson as senior warden and Thomas Carman as junior warden, of a lodge "to be held at the town of Hempstead, County of Queens" (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 9, 1888).
The lodge took its name from Deputy Grand Master Jacob Morton, a New York lawyer and militia officer. Hempstead's Masons loved one story about him. At Washington's inauguration in 1789 no Bible could be found, and Morton, master of St. John's Lodge No. 1, ran to its rooms and brought back the lodge Bible for the oath. St. John's still keeps that Bible. Morton gave his namesake lodge one of its own.
On June 24, 1797, Morton came out to Hempstead and instituted the new lodge in the house of Abraham Bedell, with Huntington Lodge assisting. Floyd Jones served as master for most of the next twenty years.
A Lodge of Village Notables
The early lodge met by moonlight. Its first rules had members gather on the Saturday before the full moon, when the roads were easiest to travel at night (Brooklyn Daily Times, November 12, 1922). Members came long distances. At the centennial in 1897, the brethren told of two brothers from the north side of the island, perhaps twenty miles away, who shared a single horse to reach the lodge.
In January 1800 the lodge voted to dress in mourning for six months for George Washington, and joined Huntington Lodge in a memorial service. A Master Mason certificate the lodge issued to Silvanus Smith in December 1802, engraved by "Bror. Rollinson," survives in the Scottish Rite Masonic Museum and Library.
The centennial also preserved a story about a man who never joined. Platt Stratton, who lived near what is now College Point, rode into Hempstead to be made a Mason. Waiting at the hotel, he asked the cook what the huge gridiron over the kitchen fire was for. The cook told him it was for the candidate when the lodge met. Stratton went back to the barn, got on his horse, and was never seen at the lodge again (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897). The joke was old even then, but it puts a College Point man on the road to Hempstead's lodge.
The Silent Years
The lodge's list of masters runs without a break from 1797 to 1838, then jumps to 1859 (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920). The lodge's own accounts explain the gap only briefly. An 1888 report said the lodge "was suspended for a time and was resuscitated in 1860." A later summary says it met in Hempstead for about fifty years "until a fire destroyed the building," and was revived in 1859.
Morton was not alone. After the Morgan affair of 1826, the Anti-Masonic movement emptied lodges across New York, and about two-thirds of the state's lodges stopped work. Suffolk Lodge No. 60, Morton's sister, ceased around 1824 and was revived only in 1856 (Grand Lodge Proceedings, 1904). For a generation, Freemasonry in old Queens County was close to dark. Queens County Lodge No. 354, chartered in Middle Village in 1855, briefly carried the county's name while Morton was silent.
The revival came under Daniel Raynor, who acted as master at the first meeting under dispensation. Augustus R. Griffin, proposed for membership at that meeting, was still the lodge's oldest member in 1897. The revived lodge met at the corner of Main and Front streets, in rooms afterward called the Masonic Temple. The Long Island Rail Road's branch from Mineola, the railroad's first, had reached Hempstead on July 4, 1839, so the revived lodge was easier to reach than the old one had been.
The Mother Lodge of the Old County
After 1860 old Queens County filled with lodges, and Morton's members liked to count them. In 1920 the lodge listed those that had "taken root and flourished within its original territory" (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920):
| Year | Lodge | Place |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1860 | Jephtha No. 494 | Huntington |
| 1864 | Cornucopia No. 563 | Flushing |
| 1864 | Jamaica No. 546 | Jamaica |
| 1866 | Glen Cove No. 580 | Glen Cove |
| 1868 | Meridian No. 691 | Islip |
| 1887 | Babylon No. 793 | Babylon |
| 1892 | Olympia No. 808 | Far Rockaway |
| 1892 | Matinecock No. 806 | Oyster Bay |
| 1897 | Massapequa No. 822 | Rockville Centre |
| 1919 | Spartan No. 956 | Freeport |
Three of those lodges are in today's Queens. The link to Flushing is direct: when Cornucopia Lodge began under dispensation in September 1864, most of its charter members came from Morton, and Morton and Jamaica Lodge recommended it to the Grand Lodge. Massapequa was another direct offshoot: most of its twenty-eight charter members in 1897 came from Morton. For the others, "within its territory" is the safer claim. In 1900 a newspaper called Morton "the maternal parent of nearly all the Masonic lodges in this section" (Brooklyn Daily Times, November 20, 1900).
Morton's members went into public life as well. B. Valentine Clowes sat in the Assembly, Robert Seabury became county judge and Charles L. Phipps county treasurer. Three members, Samuel C. Seaman, Robert A. Davison and Phipps, served as District Deputy Grand Masters. In the 1880s, when the Grand Lodge was paying off a debt of $450,000 on its Manhattan hall, Morton paid its share of $726 and helped make the First District the first outside New York and Brooklyn to pay in full (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910).
By 1888 the lodge was meeting in a room on the east side of Main Street, over Peter Tomas's business, with about 120 members.
One Hundred Years
Morton celebrated its centennial on June 23, 1897, and the village treated the day as a holiday. Grand Master William A. Sutherland came out with his staff, escorted by Morton Commandery No. 4, the Knights Templar body also named for Jacob Morton. Special cars ran from Flatbush Avenue and Long Island City. The parade included the Grand Army post, the fire department and the Odd Fellows. Supper was served in Liberty Hall, and the evening exercises were held in a tent on a ten-acre field behind the lodge room, lent by Edward Cooper. In its first hundred years the lodge had had twenty-seven masters, seven treasurers and nineteen secretaries (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897).
The master that year was Robert A. Davison, a Brooklyn lawyer born in Rockville Centre in 1843. Within months, Massapequa Lodge opened in his hometown with Morton men at its core.
In November 1900 a District Deputy's visit drew 126 visitors from twenty-eight lodges. Island City Lodge No. 586 of Long Island City exemplified the Master Mason degree, with Townsend Scudder, later Grand Master, presiding. Island City later became part of today's Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586.
A Temple by the Depot
Morton had rented rooms for more than a century. Under Master Walter R. Jones it finally built its own home. Grand Master Robert Judson Kenworthy laid the cornerstone on August 20, 1910, before one of the largest crowds the village had seen, while sixty Sunday school children sang. The two-story temple, on the south side of Fulton Avenue east of Main Street, opened for its first meeting on February 27, 1911. Its lodge room seated two hundred, and twice that number in an emergency. Kenworthy dedicated it on April 17, 1911, consecrating it with corn, wine and oil. The building has its own article in this series.
Camp Mills
The First World War changed the lodge more than anything since 1797. Hempstead sat beside Camp Mills and the army airfields of the Hempstead Plains, where divisions gathered before sailing to France. Morton opened its doors to soldier Masons. While the 42nd "Rainbow" Division was at Camp Mills, more than two thousand soldier brethren came to one meeting, and a roll call found thirty-nine states represented, along with Scotland and Alaska. Under special dispensations, the lodge held soldier communications to confer the degrees on men about to go overseas (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920).
The lodge grew with them. It started 1918 with 346 members and ended 1919 with 625, with seventy more waiting for degrees. By 1920 the Eagle called it the largest lodge outside the city, and valued its temple opposite the Hempstead depot at more than $75,000. In November 1922 the lodge burned its $22,000 mortgage. In 1925 it bought the northeast corner of Fulton and Terrace avenues and auctioned off the fourteen-room house standing there, because "a Masonic Temple will be erected on the site" (Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 7, 1925).
Into Nassau
By then Morton's world was no longer Queens County. Nassau County had been carved out of Hempstead, North Hempstead and Oyster Bay in 1899, and the old county's western towns had become a borough of New York City. Morton became a Nassau lodge, and its members' obituaries in the 1950s and 1960s show the suburb it served: a general superintendent of the Long Island Rail Road, an illustrator at Fairchild Republic, a Hempstead fire chief, a roofing contractor, a past district deputy who sold oil for Mobil (Newsday, 1957 to 1979).
Today the lodge is Wantagh-Morton No. 63. Wantagh Lodge No. 1112 was formed in 1931, and the two lodges merged in 1989. They meet at the Baldwin Masonic Temple on Prospect Street (Wantagh Morton Lodge No. 63).
Morton's story is easy to file under Nassau. Its charter says otherwise. For a hundred years it was a Queens County lodge, and the lodges in Flushing, Jamaica and Far Rockaway that grew up in its territory are part of the Masonic history of Queens.
Sources
"Morton's Centenary," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 11, 1897, p. 4; "Morton Lodge Centennial," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, June 20, 1897, p. 12; New-York Tribune, June 20 and 24, 1897.
Charter text and officers, Brooklyn Daily Times, August 9, 1888, p. 4.
"Morton Lodge, No. 63," Brooklyn Daily Times, November 20, 1900, p. 8.
Cornerstone report and address of Frederick P. Morris, Brooklyn Daily Times, August 22, 1910, p. 6.
Brooklyn Daily Eagle, February 27, 1911, p. 6; dedication report, April 18, 1911.
"Morton Lodge, 642 Strong," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 14, 1920, p. 62.
"Masons Celebrate," Brooklyn Daily Times, November 12, 1922, p. 8.
Auction notice, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 7, 1925, p. 17.
Ronald J. Seifried, "Huntington No. 26 A.Y.M.", Craftsmen Online.
Scottish Rite Masonic Museum and Library, Silvanus Smith certificate, 1802.