The Phillips Grand Lodge: New York's Masonic Schism of 1849 to 1858

Background to Before the Borough: The First Masonic Lodges of Queens · ← Previous: How the Grand Lodge of New York Began · Next: Series Guide →

For nine years New York had two rival Grand Lodges, each claiming to be the real one. Those were the same years in which Queens County Lodge No. 354 was born in Middle Village and moved to Williamsburg.

From 1849 to 1858, New York had two rival Grand Lodges. The breakaway body was named for its Grand Master, Isaac Phillips, a New York lawyer and a past Deputy Grand Master. The larger body, usually called the Willard Grand Lodge after its Grand Master, was the one most other Grand Lodges recognized. The two reunited in 1858. These were exactly the years when Queens County Lodge No. 354 was founded in Middle Village (1854 to 1855) and moved to Williamsburg (1857).

How the Split Happened

New York Freemasonry had split before. From 1823 there were rival City and Country Grand Lodges, and from 1837 a breakaway "St. John's Grand Lodge" operated for thirteen years (A General Register of All the Lodges and Grand Lodges of Freemasons in North America; Encyclopedia Masonica, "Schisms"). The 1849 break came at the Grand Lodge's annual meeting, in a quarrel over a change to the constitution that took away members' voting rights (The Masonic Observer, 1858). The dissenters declared the Grand Lodge dissolved and set up a new one, with Isaac Phillips, "a Past Deputy Grand Master," as Grand Master (Freemasons' Quarterly Review, September 1849).

For nine years the Phillips Grand Lodge performed all the functions of a Grand Lodge, chartering and governing its own lodges. Meanwhile the St. John's Grand Lodge joined the Willard body in December 1850, so the main line grew stronger. Grand Lodges abroad were careful. The Grand Master of England, aware of "the existence of two New York Grand Lodges," declined to receive a representative from either, so as not to take sides (Freemasons' Quarterly Review, December 1850).

Reunion

In 1858 the two bodies made peace. A Masonic paper of September 1858 announced that the craft in New York was "once more united in friendship and brotherly love" (The Masonic Observer). Charles T. McClenachan's 1892 history of New York Freemasonry prints the proceedings of both bodies for 1849 to 1858, along with the terms of the reunion.

Phillips himself came back into the fold with honor. In 1873 he presided over part of the Grand Lodge's annual session as "M. W. Isaac Phillips" and received the Grand Lodge's thanks (The Freemason, July 5, 1873). The Jewish Encyclopedia describes an Isaac Phillips, a lawyer born in New York on June 16, 1812, son of Naphtali Phillips, as a grand master of the state's Freemasons.

Brooklyn, Williamsburg and the Schism

Which Brooklyn and Queens lodges sided with Phillips is not yet clear. Henry Whittemore's 1889 history of the Brooklyn lodges has a chapter on the "Organization of the Phillips Grand Lodge" (full text), and McClenachan's volume of Phillips proceedings should list its lodges.

The lodges in this series appear to belong to the main line. Queens County Lodge's number, 354, granted in 1855, falls in the regular Grand Lodge's sequence, and Cornerstone Lodge No. 367 was chartered the same year. The schism's effects lasted past the reunion. At least one Manhattan lodge had its warrant revived in 1859 by the Grand Master of the Phillips Grand Lodge, as a Fourth Manhattan District history puts it.

Sources


Continue Reading

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Before the Borough Series Guide: Timeline, Lineages and Glossary of Early Queens Lodges

Next
Next

How the Grand Lodge of New York Began Under British Occupation, and Its First American Grand Master