Willard Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 250: A Grand Master's Namesake, a Charter Scandal, and a Home in Rockville Centre

Part 12 of Across the County Line · ← Previous: Baltic, Heritage and America Lodge No. 284 · Next: The Glen Cove Masonic Temple →

Seven Manhattan lodges of the 1850s, one named for the Grand Master who led New York Masonry through the schism of 1849, became a single lodge that now meets in the old Massapequa temple.

Named for a Grand Master

John Dwight Willard was born in Lancaster, New Hampshire, in 1799. He graduated from Dartmouth, practiced law in Troy and edited the Troy Sentinel. He sat as associate judge of the Rensselaer County Court and served in the State Senate. As his Wikipedia biography records, he was Grand Master of Masons in New York from 1846 to 1849.

Those were not quiet years. Willard presided during the bitter quarrel that split the Grand Lodge in 1849, when a faction broke away and formed what became known as the Phillips Grand Lodge (see The Phillips Grand Lodge and New York's Masonic Schism). The 1880 History of Rensselaer County remembered him as Grand Master "at the time of the memorable troubles in the order." Charles T. McClenachan's history of New York Masonry gives the period a chapter of its own, the "Historical Narrative of the Willard Grand Lodge."

When a new Manhattan lodge was chartered on December 8, 1852, it took his name: John D. Willard Lodge No. 250.

Seven Lodges of the 1850s

Willard Sylvan Grove Lodge is the sum of seven lodges, most of them chartered in a single burst of growth in the early 1850s. The Grand Lodge records list:

| Lodge | Chartered |

|---|---|

| Charter Oak Lodge No. 249 | June 4, 1852 |

| John D. Willard Lodge No. 250 | December 8, 1852 |

| Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 275 | December 10, 1852 |

| Arcturus Lodge No. 274 | March 5, 1853 |

| Doric Lodge No. 280 | early 1850s |

| New York Lodge No. 330 | 1850s |

| Puritan Lodge No. 339 | 1850s |

In their early decades several of these lodges shared rooms in Odd Fellows' Hall at the corner of Grand and Centre Streets. The 1850s and 1860s papers are full of their funeral summonses: Willard, Charter Oak and Doric brethren called to meet "at their rooms, Odd Fellows' Hall," to bury a brother. Later they moved to the Masonic Hall at Sixth Avenue and Twenty-third Street.

By the 1890s Charter Oak was holding entertainments in the Commandery Room for more than five hundred guests, according to the New-York Tribune.

The Shang Draper Affair

The most dramatic moment in the line's history belongs to Doric Lodge No. 280. In the spring of 1903, Doric was preparing to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of its institution. Then Grand Master Elbert Crandall learned that the lodge had initiated, passed and raised "Shang" Draper.

Draper had been proposed as a "broker." He was in fact a notorious figure of the city's underworld, known for years as an associate of "Red" Leary, Jimmy Hope, Billy Porter and other well-known bank burglars. Draper's undoing was his ambition. When he applied to a Royal Arch chapter, its investigating committee recognized him and informed the Grand Lodge.

Crandall arrested Doric's charter. The anniversary celebration was canceled. Newspapers as far away as Utah reported that Grand Lodge officers were "filled with dismay and indignation," and that other lodges in Manhattan and Brooklyn were being investigated too.

At the Grand Lodge's annual communication in May 1903, Crandall told the delegates that he had ordered charges against everyone involved in Draper's admission. He also asked for mercy for the lodge. Most of Doric's members, he said, had known nothing of the candidate's history, and forfeiting the charter "would be a great wrong to the 150 good brethren of that Lodge." Once the roll was purged, he recommended, the charter should be restored. Doric survived. It was still conferring degrees and sending lecturers to other lodges in 1920, and it merged with Sylvan Grove seventy-six years after the scandal.

A Queens Thread

The lodges were Manhattan lodges, but Queens men belonged. Edward T. Kassel of the Ridgewood and Glendale sections was a member of Doric Lodge for fifty years. He was a founder of the old Evergreens Board of Trade and a past president of the Newtown Exempt Firemen's Association. When he died in 1937, his family held services at a daughter's home on 70th Avenue in Ridgewood.

Doric's 1875 reception was managed by a Fred Kassel. Later members were buried from funeral homes in Woodhaven, Queens Village and Flushing.

The Consolidations

As Manhattan lodges shrank after the Second World War, the seven charters came together one by one:

  1. March 17, 1964: New York Lodge No. 330 and Charter Oak Lodge No. 249 became New York Charter Oak Lodge No. 249.

  2. November 2, 1969: John D. Willard Lodge No. 250 and Puritan Lodge No. 339 became Puritan Willard Lodge No. 250.

  3. December 19, 1979: Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 275 and Doric Lodge No. 280 became Doric Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 275.

  4. 1985: Arcturus Lodge No. 274 merged into Doric Sylvan Grove.

  5. October 1, 1987: Puritan Willard and Doric Sylvan Grove consolidated as Willard Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 250, per the Grand Lodge list. The combined name was already appearing in death notices by 1985.

  6. Later: New York Charter Oak Lodge No. 249 merged in, completing the seven.

From Twenty-third Street to Rockville Centre

For years Willard Sylvan Grove met in Manhattan as part of the Fifth Manhattan District, which it still belongs to. In the twenty-first century it moved east, first to the Kismet Shriners hall in Hicksville. It now meets at the Scottish Rite Building, 28 Lincoln Avenue, Rockville Centre. That building, whose history is told in The Massapequa Masonic Temple, is the former Rockville Centre Club that Massapequa Lodge No. 822 dedicated as its temple in 1921.

So a lodge named for the Grand Master of 1849 now works in a temple that a Queens County lodge bought in 1921, alongside Guiding Light-Olympia No. 808, whose number goes back to Far Rockaway in 1894.

Sources

  • Wikipedia, "John D. Willard"

  • Nathaniel Bartlett Sylvester, History of Rensselaer Co., New York (1880), John D. Willard biography

  • Grand Lodge of New York, Past Grand Masters

  • Grand Lodge of New York charter and consolidation records (Charter Oak, Willard, Sylvan Grove, Arcturus, Doric, New York and Puritan lodges)

  • New York Herald, 1850s-1870s (funeral summonses, Odd Fellows' Hall)

  • New-York Tribune, February 16, 1896, and December 4, 1898 (Charter Oak Lodge)

  • Brooklyn Union, January 8, 1875, p. 3 (Doric Lodge reception)

  • New York Herald, May 6, 1903, p. 5, and Brooklyn Daily Eagle, May 5 and 6, 1903 (Doric charter and Grand Master Crandall's address)

  • Utah Digital Newspapers, "Masons Indignant at Sports Election" (March 1903)

  • Brooklyn Daily Eagle, January 19, 1937, p. 11 (Edward T. Kassel)

  • Daily News, May 14, 1989, and Poughkeepsie Journal, January 17, 1987 (Willard Sylvan Grove notices)

  • Grand Lodge of New York, Willard Sylvan Grove #0250 lodge page


Continue Reading

← Previous: Baltic, Heritage and America Lodge No. 284 · Next: The Glen Cove Masonic Temple → · Series Guide · Start Here

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Glen Cove Masonic Temple: The Duryea Homestead and Clubhouse on Continental Place

Next
Next

Baltic, Heritage and America Lodge No. 284: A Williamsburg Charter's Journey Through Queens