Part 13 of Across the County Line · ← Previous: Willard Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 250 · Next: The Matinecock Masonic Temple →
An old family homestead became a clubhouse, and a new lodge room was built into the hill behind it. Glen Cove Lodge's home from 1913.
For almost half a century, Glen Cove Lodge No. 580 met in other people's rooms. In 1913 it finally had a home of its own. The building it made was unusual: a new lodge room joined to an old family house, so that one building held the ritual and the other the social life of the lodge.
Forty-seven years of borrowed rooms
Glen Cove Lodge began working under dispensation on March 16, 1865, in the Odd Fellows' lodge room in the Wilcockson Building, later numbered 39 Glen Street. The first meeting under its charter followed on June 11, 1866, in the same room, with Joseph S. Armstrong as first Master. Henry Isham Hazelton's 1925 history of Brooklyn, Queens, Nassau and Suffolk traces the moves that followed: to the Bowne Building (10 Glen Street), to the Kirk Building (48 Glen Street), and to the Mutual Insurance Company's building. The lodge stayed there until it moved into "its own and present Temple, 29 Continental Place, on February 5, 1913" (Hazelton, via the Nassau County GenWeb transcription).
Glen Cove was then still part of Queens County, and the lodge worked in the First Masonic District alongside the lodges of western Queens. Its roll explains why its new home drew so many dignitaries. Townsend Scudder, Master in 1891 and 1892, became Grand Master of Masons in New York. Paul H. Grimm and Harry L. Hedger both served as District Deputy Grand Master.
A homestead and a hillside
The lodge did not start from an empty lot. It bought the old Edgar Duryea homestead on Continental Place, a house standing on a large piece of land that sloped into a hill at the back. The building committee, chaired by Harry L. Hedger, with Paul H. Grimm, Joseph D. Sayre, William H. Weeks, R. Frank Bowne, Daniel J. Hegeman, James K. Davis and William H. Lang, used the slope. They built the new lodge room on the rise behind the house so that it met the homestead's second floor.
The new room measured 40 by 60 feet inside. The architect was Samuel J. Stammers, whom the Brooklyn Eagle identified as the supervising architect of the Morgan mansion at East Island. Joseph Martin was the builder.
The house itself was renovated as a Masonic clubhouse. It held reception, dining, smoking and billiard rooms, a library, and second-floor rooms for chapter use that could be opened straight into the main lodge room. The arrangement let the lodge seat a larger crowd on special nights without building a bigger hall.
Dedication night, March 5, 1913
The temple was dedicated on the evening of Wednesday, March 5, 1913. More than 400 Masons attended, including Grand Master Charles Smith of Oneonta, Deputy Grand Master George Freifeld, Grand Secretary Edward M. L. Ehlers, Grand Treasurer William H. Miller, and Past Grand Master Townsend Scudder, the lodge's own son. Before the ceremony the grand officers dined at the Nassau Country Club.
Master William H. Lang opened by turning the property over to the Grand Master for dedication. Paul H. Grimm presented an ivory gavel with an inscribed silver band. The lodge then numbered close to 300 members.
The club and the community
Two weeks later, members formed a Masonic club to run the house. Its first officers were Paul H. Grimm, president; R. Frank Bowne, vice president; John D. Montfort, secretary; and Ellwood Valentine, treasurer. The Eagle reported that the club would use "the remodeled Duryea homestead, which adjoins the new lodge room." The same week, the lodge hosted a reception and dance for the 300 young people who had staged a December parade for its benefit.
The building kept growing with the lodge. In December 1922, under incoming Master O. Edward Payne, the lodge announced plans to spend about $25,000 on an addition to the lodge room at the Continental Place temple "which it purchased several years ago."
Where the lodge is now
Glen Cove Lodge never merged with another lodge. It now describes itself as a "Civil War Lodge" founded by returning veterans, and it meets at 14 West Main Street in Oyster Bay, the site of the Matinecock Masonic Temple. Glen Cove helped found Matinecock, so the daughter lodge's building now shelters the mother.
Sources
Henry Isham Hazelton, The Boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens, Counties of Nassau and Suffolk, Long Island, New York, 1609 to 1924 (1925), Glen Cove section, transcribed on Nassau County GenWeb.
"Glen Cove Masons in New Clubhouse," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 6, 1913.
"New Home of the Masonic Lodge Formally Dedicated at Glen Cove," Brooklyn Daily Times, March 7, 1913.
"Masonic Club Organized" and "Masons to Entertain," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 22, 1913.
"Glen Cove Masons Elect," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, December 17, 1922.
Glen Cove Lodge No. 580, lodge history page, and Rob Nobile, "Forged in Memory: A Brother's 9/11 Tribute," Craftsmen Online, 2026.
Grand Lodge of the State of New York, charter records, Glen Cove Lodge No. 580.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Willard Sylvan Grove Lodge No. 250 · Next: The Matinecock Masonic Temple → · Series Guide
Related on BreteMurphy.com