The German Masonic Temple, 220 East 15th Street, Manhattan: The History of a Masonic Landmark

Part 10 of The German District · ← Previous: Von Mensch Lodge No. 765 · Next: The German District in Queens →

A Manhattan temple, not a Queens one: the building the German lodges of New York raised for themselves in 1879, their shared home for sixty years, and now a Quaker school.

The lodges of the German District now meet in Queens, in a temple built by a Queens lodge. Their own building was in Manhattan. For more than half a century the German Masonic Temple on East 15th Street, off Stuyvesant Square, was the center of German Freemasonry in New York. This article is about that Manhattan building. The district's story in Queens is told in The German District in Queens.

An association of lodges

German immigration to New York surged after the upheavals of the late 1840s, and German Masons formed lodges that worked in their own language. By the 1870s there were enough of them to want a building of their own. About 1875, the German lodges organized an association to build a temple. It became known as the German Masonic Temple Association (Daytonian in Manhattan).

The cornerstone, July 2, 1879

The cornerstone was laid on the afternoon of July 2, 1879, on Fifteenth Street near Third Avenue, "in the presence of a very large number of Masons and spectators," as The New York Times reported the next day. In November 1879 the association held a fair in the unfinished building to raise money for the temple fund. The building opened formally on March 4, 1880.

The building

Architect Arthur M. Thom of Thom and Wilson designed a five-story building in the Queen Anne style, built of Baltimore brick with Nova Scotia stone trim, for about $60,000. Stone bands marked each floor, brick piers gave the front depth, and a pressed metal cornice crowned it. The New York Dispatch thought that "though not large enough to be imposing, the building presents a very neat appearance."

Inside, each floor had its purpose:

  • Basement: a restaurant and dining hall.

  • First floor: a lecture room, 28 by 62 feet.

  • Second floor: the Corinthian lodge room, of the same size.

  • Third floor: the Ionic lodge room.

  • Fourth floor: the smaller Doric lodge room and the janitor's apartment.

Each lodge room had its own preparation and examination rooms. Twelve German lodges shared the building.

The German lodges' home

The temple became the place where German Masonry in New York gathered. Trinity Lodge No. 12, the oldest German lodge in the country, had its rooms there; in October 1906 it held a memorial communication at the temple attended by delegations "from nearly all the German Brooklyn lodges." Masonic funerals were held in the lodge rooms for decades, from the brewer Franz Ruppert in 1883 to Alfred Osterland, past District Deputy of the Ninth District, in 1925.

The association's leaders were leaders of the district. Its president, Christian C. Gerhardt, a past master of Teutonia Lodge, answered the toast to "the German Masonic Temple Association" at Schiller Lodge's golden jubilee in 1903.

The temple's income also supported the association's other great work, the German Masonic Home at Tappan in Rockland County, a residence for aged Masons and their widows.

A building for the city

The temple served German New York beyond the lodges. On September 16, 1881, after President Garfield was shot, the German-American Independent Citizens' Committee met there and condemned the "murderous assault" on the President. The Ironsides Council of the American Legion of Honor met there and in 1884 voted to admit women. From about 1884 the Manhattan Liberal Club held its lectures in the building, with speakers who included the journalist T. Thomas Fortune in 1901.

Two remodelings

In 1905 architect Otto L. Spannbake modernized the interior. In 1936 Louis Almendinger and M. Allen Schlendorf remade the front entirely. They lowered the entrance to street level and gave the building a two-part face: a classical temple front with tall Doric columns across the lower floors, and gray cast stone in an Art Deco manner above.

The end of the German temple

On November 15, 1939, the German Masonic Temple Association changed its name to the German Masonic Home Corporation, a sign that its work now centered on Tappan rather than on lodge rooms in Manhattan. The German lodges eventually left 15th Street. Their later homes included Brooklyn halls and, in the end, the Whitestone Masonic Temple in Queens.

In March 1997 The New York Times reported that Friends Seminary, the Quaker school across the street on Rutherford Place, planned to buy the building. Anderson Architects renovated it as classrooms, adding about 15,000 square feet, and the work was finished in 1998. Wikipedia's article on Masonic Hall notes the building as a "former Masonic lodge building at 15th Street, home to a number of German-speaking Masonic lodges," now used by Friends Seminary (Wikipedia). The New York Public Library and the Museum of the City of New York hold photographs of the building (NYPL Digital Collections).

Sources


Continue Reading

← Previous: Von Mensch Lodge No. 765 · Next: The German District in Queens → · Series Guide

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

The German District in Queens: Halls, Outings and the Whitestone Temple

Next
Next

Von Mensch Lodge No. 765 History: A German Lodge Constituted in East New York, 1876