Part 11 of The German District · ← Previous: The German Masonic Temple, Manhattan · Next: The German Masonic Home at Tappan →
The German lodges built a temple in Manhattan and a home in Rockland County. In Queens they danced, picnicked and, in the end, found a home someone else had built.
Most of the series this site has published on Queens lodges include an article on the temple a lodge built. The German District is different. The research gathered so far turns up no Masonic temple built in Queens by any German District lodge. What the German lodges built, they built in Manhattan and in Rockland County. Their story in Queens is one of rented halls, summer outings, and a late move into a building raised by a Queens lodge.
What the German lodges did build
The German Masonic Temple, 220 East 15th Street, Manhattan. In the mid-1870s the German lodges formed an association to build a temple of their own. The cornerstone was laid on July 2, 1879, and the building, designed by Arthur M. Thom, held lodge rooms for twelve German lodges, among them Trinity Lodge No. 12. In 1939 the association was renamed the German Masonic Home Corporation. Friends Seminary bought the building in the late 1990s and finished renovating it in 1998 (Daytonian in Manhattan).
The German Masonic Home, Tappan. The temple's income helped support a home for aged Masons, their wives and widows at Tappan in Rockland County. The German Masons bought a farm with a country house there in 1888, took in their first residents in 1889, and built a three-story brick home from 1906 to 1909. Residents lived there until 1983, when they moved to the Dumont Masonic Home in New Rochelle, which the district's corporation owned until 2010 (The Mason, Winter 2024).
German Masonic Park, Tappan. The district still owns and runs the old fairground at 89 Western Highway, where its lodges hold Traubenfest every October (The Magpie Mason).
A burial plot in Middle Village. The one German District site known in Queens was a cemetery plot, not a building. A 1903 history of Schiller Lodge records that the "cemetery of the German district at Middle Village" was dedicated in 1878 and a monument cornerstone laid there three years later. The plot has not yet been located.
The German District in Queens before Whitestone
German Masonry reached Queens long before the district moved there.
Stimmel's Hotel, Whitestone. In September 1893 the Herder Club, made up of members of Herder Lodge No. 698 of Greenpoint, took the train to Stimmel's Hotel in Whitestone for its annual outing of baseball, football, bowling, foot races and supper.
Astoria Schuetzen Park. In March 1915 Wanderer Lodge No. 884, a German lodge of Astoria and Long Island City, held an entertainment and dance at Astoria Schuetzen Park, a German shooting club's park, that drew "nearly every German Mason of Long Island." Wanderer merged into Herder in 1982.
College Point. William Pauly, the longtime superintendent of Conrad Poppenhusen's Enterprise Rubber Works and president of the village of College Point, was a member of Trinity Lodge No. 12 for more than fifty years. In 1895 Trinity honored him with a gold medal.
Long Island City. A 1923 member list of the German-language districts included members in Long Island City as well as Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn and Staten Island (Freiburg University Library bibliography).
None of these were Masonic buildings. They were the hotels, parks and halls of German New York, which the lodges shared with singing societies, shooting clubs and Turnvereine.
The Whitestone Masonic Temple
The building where the German District now meets was built by a Queens lodge. The Whitestone Masonic Temple at 149-39 11th Avenue is the story of Whitestone Lodge No. 973, told in The Whitestone Masonic Temple on 11th Avenue. By 2010 Forgotten New York identified the building as the headquarters of the Ninth Manhattan Masonic District (Forgotten New York). Today ten German District lodges meet there: Trinity, Knickerbocker, Schiller, Copernicus, Lessing, Herder, Wieland, Uhland, Allemania and Von Mensch (Ninth Manhattan District). Reliance Lodge No. 776, of the old Queens County line, meets there too.
So the Whitestone temple has become what the German Masonic Temple on 15th Street was in 1879: the shared home of the German lodges of New York.
Sources
Tom Miller, "The German Masonic Temple (Friends Seminary), 220 East 15th Street," Daytonian in Manhattan, June 15, 2022.
RW Roy Puckhaber, "Ninth Manhattan Favors Brotherhood Fund," The Mason, Winter 2024.
Schiller Lodge No. 304 golden jubilee history, Brooklyn press, January 1903.
Nick Carr, "Inside an Abandoned Masonic Hall in Tappan, NY," Scouting NY, April 3, 2012.
The Magpie Mason, posts on German Masonic Park.
"The Herder Club's Outing," Brooklyn Daily Times, September 6, 1893.
Wanderer Lodge entertainment, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 23, 1915.
"A Little German Horn Comb Maker," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, September 8, 1895.
Bibliographie der freimaurerischen Literatur, supplement (1926), Freiburg University Library.
Kevin Walsh, "11th Avenue, Whitestone," Forgotten New York, 2010.
Ninth Manhattan District, lodge list, 2026.
Continue Reading
← Previous: The German Masonic Temple, Manhattan · Next: The German Masonic Home at Tappan → · Start Here
Related on BreteMurphy.com