The German Masonic Home at Tappan: The German District's Retirement Home and Other Buildings

Part 12 of The German District · ← Previous: The German District in Queens · Next: Series Guide →

Beyond their Manhattan temple, the German lodges of New York built a retirement home in Rockland County, a festival ground beside it, and later a nursing home in Westchester. None of these stood in Queens, but Queens lodges helped fill them.

The German lodges of New York did not stop at building a temple. From the start they meant to build a home as well: a place where aged and needy brethren, their wives and their widows could live out their lives among people who spoke their language. That home stood for nearly a century in Tappan, in Rockland County, just above the New Jersey line and a short ride from the Tappan Zee. Its grounds are still owned by the district today.

This article covers the buildings the German District raised or bought outside Manhattan. Their temple at 220 East 15th Street has its own article, and the halls and parks the lodges used in Queens are covered in The German District in Queens.

The idea: a temple and a home

The two projects were born together. According to a history of the district published by the Masonic Care Community in 2024, the German brethren proposed both a new temple and a home for indigent Masons, their wives and orphans at their annual district meeting in 1875 (The Mason, Winter 2024). The temple came first. Its cornerstone was laid in 1879 and it was dedicated in 1880, and the rents from its lodge rooms became one of the main sources of money for the home.

The lodges gave to the home long before it had a building. A history of Schiller Lodge No. 304, printed for the lodge's golden jubilee in January 1903, lists a donation "to the German Masonic Home" in 1886.

The farmhouse at Tappan, 1888 to 1909

In 1888 the German Masons bought farmland at Tappan with a country house on it. The 2024 district history gives the purchase as nineteen acres; a 2013 Rockland County Times report puts the Masons' holding at more than 100 acres near the hamlet center, west of Greenbush Road (Rockland County Times, 2013). The Times names the house as the large Victorian home of Johanna Reuter.

The farmhouse was renovated, dedicated and cleared of debt within a year, and its first residents were Frederich Mueller of Schiller Lodge and his wife (The Mason, Winter 2024). The Schiller jubilee history says the dedication took place on October 29, and that two years later Schiller Lodge paid to furnish one of the home's rooms.

The home grew quickly. The Rockland County Times reports that around 1890 or 1891 the Masons built a much larger wooden home nearby, and that in 1894 the new Western Highway was cut through their land. The original house site, on one side of the road, was turned into a fairground.

The institution was more than a home for the old. When Allemania Lodge No. 740 made its 1911 outing there, the Brooklyn Daily Times called it the "German Masonic Home for the Aged and Orphan Asylum," and a year later the same paper described Schiller Lodge visiting the "German Masonic Home and Orphan Asylum" (Brooklyn Daily Times, June 22, 1911, and June 10, 1912). The 1905 New York Charities Directory described its purpose as caring for "aged, indigent Masons, their wives or widows" (Daytonian in Manhattan).

The brick home of 1909

By the new century the wooden buildings were not enough. From 1906 to 1909 the corporation built a larger care facility at an estimated cost of $76,000, of which the brethren of the district gave $25,000. It was finished and dedicated in 1909 (The Mason, Winter 2024). The Rockland County Times describes it as a three-story red brick Georgian building on the hillside across Western Highway from the fairground. Its address was 120 Western Highway (Rockland County Genealogical Society).

Residents lived there free of charge. The home also kept a group burial plot in a local cemetery, where its residents were buried for more than fifty years (Scouting NY, 2012).

The Lincoln Chapel and the Klieg light

In 1918 Brother Anton T. Kliegl paid for a chapel at the home, named the Lincoln Chapel after his lodge, Lincoln Lodge (The Mason, Winter 2024). Kliegl and his brother John were the stage-lighting makers whose name lives on in the Klieg light. Lincoln Lodge No. 748 later merged into Schiller Lodge No. 304, so the chapel is a link between Tappan and a lodge that now meets in Queens.

Stained-glass windows in the chapel showed Kliegl and his wife and carried the date April 8, 1928 (Scouting NY, 2012; Dry Pigment).

How the lodges paid for it

The home ran on rents from the Manhattan temple, on dues and gifts from the lodges, and on bequests. Brooklyn probate notices show ordinary members leaving it money. In 1914, for example, Christine Schneller left $100 to German Union Lodge No. 54 "for its home at Tappan" (Times Union, December 6, 1914). A Brooklyn newspaper profile of Lessing Lodge No. 608 praised the lodge for paying its full share to the statewide Masonic Home at Utica while also doing "her full part" for "the distinctly German Masonic Home at Tappan."

The biggest fundraiser was a party. The German lodges' summer festival, the Johannisfest, was held on the grounds of the home until it outgrew them. In June 1902 the Brooklyn Daily Times reported that the festival had been moved to Ulmer Park in Brooklyn because the crowds had grown too large for Tappan, with the proceeds still going to the home (Brooklyn Daily Times, June 24, 1902).

The autumn festival stayed. Traubenfest, the grape festival, has been held at Tappan since 1890 (The Magpie Mason). Even under Prohibition, a Rockland newspaper reported a crowd of 15,000 on the home's grounds, with about thirty lodges represented, at what it called "the same old winefest" (Historical Society of Rockland County).

Queens at Tappan

Queens lodges went up the Hudson often. In May 1915 Wanderer Lodge No. 884, the German lodge of Astoria, held its outing at the "Freemasons Home, Tappan," and that October it joined the Traubenfest at the "German Freemasons Home for the Aged" (Brooklyn newspapers, May 19 and October 4, 1915). In August of the same year about 200 people from the Fellowcraft Club of Tadmor Lodge No. 923 of Ridgewood rode special cars of the West Shore Railroad to the home for a day of music, dancing and children's games (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 21, 1915). When a Tadmor member, Louis Kleuber, died at Tappan in October 1928, he was brought home to Ridgewood for his funeral (Times Union, October 8, 1928).

Not every story from the home was a happy one. In September 1933 the New York Times reported the deaths of two elderly residents, John Ellich and Marie Kiefer, who had secretly married against the home's rules and learned that the board meant to separate them (Scouting NY, 2012).

From home to park

By the late 1960s the New York State Department of Health had ruled that the Tappan home no longer met current standards of care, and the corporation began looking for another way to serve its members (The Mason, Winter 2024). The home closed in 1983. Dominican College later leased the building as a dormitory, and it has stood empty since 1996 (Scouting NY, 2012).

The fairground across the road had a longer life. Over the decades it gained a main pavilion, a dance hall, picnic grounds and athletic fields, and as other picnic parks vanished the Masons began lending it to outside groups (Rockland County Times, 2013). Today it is German Masonic Park, about seven acres at 89 Western Highway, owned and run by the Noble Ninth, Inc. for the district. Traubenfest is still held there on the first Sunday of October, and the Town of Orangetown uses the park for events, including its July 4, 2026 Orangetown USA250 parade ceremony (I LOVE NY).

The Dumont Masonic Home, New Rochelle

The district did not give up caring for its elderly when Tappan closed. In 1978 the German Masonic Home Corporation signed a contract to buy a nursing home, the Dumont, and it owned and operated the Dumont Masonic Home in New Rochelle, Westchester County, from 1982 until 2010 (The Mason, Winter 2024; New York State Department of Health, 2011). The residents of the Tappan home moved there in 1983.

Over time the Dumont became a modern skilled nursing facility serving the public. By 2011 no members of the district were living there, and with falling reimbursement rates the corporation sold it and placed the proceeds in a charitable fund (The Mason, Winter 2024). That fund lives on as the German Masonic Charitable Foundation, which in 2024 gave about $990,000 to more than sixty organizations.

A burial ground in Queens

One German District site did stand in Queens, though it was not a building. The 1903 Schiller jubilee history records that in 1878 the "cemetery of the German district at Middle Village" was dedicated, and that three years later a cornerstone was laid there for a monument to the district's departed brethren. Middle Village was then a German village whose main business was the Lutheran Cemetery, then counted among the most important Protestant cemeteries near New York (Juniper Park Civic Association). The clipping does not name the cemetery, and the plot and monument still need to be located.

The district's buildings at a glance

| Building | Place | Dates | Status |

|---|---|---|---|

| German Masonic Temple | 220 East 15th Street, Manhattan | 1879 to 1880; sold late 1990s | Friends Seminary |

| District burial plot and monument | Middle Village, Queens | 1878; monument 1881 | Not yet located |

| Farmhouse home | Tappan, Rockland County | Bought 1888; first residents 1889 | Replaced |

| Wooden home | Tappan | About 1890 to 1891 | Replaced |

| Brick German Masonic Home | 120 Western Highway, Tappan | 1906 to 1909; closed 1983 | Vacant since 1996 |

| Lincoln Chapel | At the Tappan home | 1918 | Part of the vacant home |

| German Masonic Park | 89 Western Highway, Tappan | Fairground from 1894 | Owned by the district |

| Dumont Masonic Home | New Rochelle, Westchester | Owned 1982 to 2010 | Sold |

Sources


Continue Reading

← Previous: The German District in Queens · Next: Series Guide → · Start Here

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Masonic Temples of Queens, New York: A Guide to Every Lodge Building

Next
Next

The German District in Queens: Halls, Outings and the Whitestone Temple