Part 1 of The German District · ← Previous: Start Here: The German District · Next: Schiller Lodge No. 304 →
Chartered in 1795, working in German since 1841, and now meeting in Whitestone, Trinity is the senior lodge of New York's German District.
A 1795 charter
Trinity Lodge No. 12 is the oldest lodge in the German District and one of the oldest lodges in New York. Grand Lodge records give its charter date as September 23, 1795, and record that it was renumbered as No. 12 on June 7, 1839. A 1911 item in the Masonic Standard, reprinted in Rochester's Times-Union, described Trinity as working "under a charter dated March 23, 1795," with "a continuous existence" since. The same item traced the lodge's origin further back, to an old Lodge No. 210, without a name, warranted by the Atholl (Ancient) Grand Lodge of England in 1779 to work in New York City, during the British occupation.
From English to German
Trinity did not begin as a German lodge. According to the 1911 account, it "worked in English until 1841, and since that time has worked in the German language." That change made it the senior German-speaking lodge in the country. Brooklyn papers in 1906 called it "the oldest German Masonic lodge of this country."
The historian Andreas Önnerfors, studying German lodges in New York, notes that Trinity grew out of an existing immigrant association, and that German Masons were then forming and reorganizing lodges across the city (Önnerfors, Atlantic Studies, 2019).
The schism years
Trinity was caught up in the split that divided New York Masonry in 1849. Grand Lodge notes record that it joined the breakaway Phillips Grand Lodge on June 5, 1849, and left it in March 1850 to return to the regular Grand Lodge.
A home on 15th Street
From 1880 Trinity met in the German Masonic Temple at 220 East 15th Street, built by an association of German lodges. In October 1906 it held a memorial communication there, attended by delegations "from nearly all the German Brooklyn lodges." Its annual receptions were social events; in March 1897 the lodge held its reception at the Grand Central Opera House (Daytonian in Manhattan).
A Queens member
Trinity's members lived across the city. One of the most notable was William Pauly of College Point. Born in Langenschwalbach, Nassau, in 1818, he was making horn combs in College Point when Conrad Poppenhusen hired him in 1854 as superintendent of the Enterprise Rubber Works, a post he held for 32 years. He served as a village trustee and president, was a director of the College Point Savings Bank, and sat on the board of the Poppenhusen Institute. In 1895 the Brooklyn Eagle reported that Trinity had presented him with a gold medal for fifty years of continuous membership.
Lineage
| Date | Event |
| --- | --- |
| 1779 | Lodge No. 210 warranted by the Atholl Grand Lodge in New York (per the 1911 account) |
| September 23, 1795 | Trinity Lodge chartered |
| June 7, 1839 | Renumbered as Trinity Lodge No. 12 |
| 1841 | Trinity begins working in German; Pythagoras Lodge No. 86 chartered in Manhattan, April 20 |
| June 5, 1849 | Trinity joins the Phillips Grand Lodge |
| March 1850 | Trinity returns to the Grand Lodge |
| June 28, 1866 | Socrates Lodge No. 595 chartered |
| March 21, 1993 | Pythagoras Lodge No. 86 merges into Trinity Lodge No. 12 |
| April 13, 2024 | Socrates Lodge No. 595 merges into Trinity Lodge No. 12 |
Pythagoras had its own unusual history. Önnerfors records that in 1851 part of it became Pythagoras No. 1 in Brooklyn under the Grand Lodge of Hamburg, while a faction returned to New York's Grand Lodge as No. 86 in 1854.
Today
Trinity Lodge No. 12 meets on the first and third Wednesdays at the Whitestone Masonic Temple, 149-39 11th Avenue, Queens (Ninth Manhattan District).
Sources
"Trinity Lodge No. 12," Masonic Standard, reprinted in the Times-Union (Rochester), July 29, 1911.
The Chat, November 3, 1906, and Brooklyn Daily Times, October 30, 1906 (memorial communication).
New York newspaper, March 14, 1897 (Twenty-eighth District notes and Trinity's annual reception).
"A Little German Horn Comb Maker," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, September 8, 1895 (William Pauly).
Andreas Önnerfors, article on German-speaking lodges in New York, Atlantic Studies (2019), doi:10.1080/14788810.2019.1570447.
Tom Miller, "The German Masonic Temple (Friends Seminary)," Daytonian in Manhattan, 2022.
Ninth Manhattan District, lodge list, 2026.
Grand Lodge of the State of New York, charter and merger records for Trinity No. 12, Pythagoras No. 86 and Socrates No. 595.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Start Here: The German District · Next: Schiller Lodge No. 304 → · Series Guide
Related on BreteMurphy.com