Advance Lodge could not find an architect for its new temple. Arthur E. Wenige, a brother it had raised in 1903, had already drawn a lodge room for Hillside in Woodhaven. His firm sent the plans to Astoria, and the room built from them is still at work.
Part 6 of The 273 Line · A Connecting Story of the Seven Lodges
The lodge room on the upper floor of the Advance Masonic Temple, at 21-14 30th Avenue in Astoria, was drawn for somewhere else first.
According to Advance Lodge's records, its plan had already served Hillside Lodge No. 894 in Woodhaven. The link between the two lodges was Arthur E. Wenige, an engineer whose firm designed Hillside's temple and then handed the same lodge-room blueprints to Advance when Advance could not find an architect of its own.[1][2]
Tadmor Lodge No. 923 gives the story an unexpected symmetry. By its own account it began work in Hillside's building in 1914. Today it meets in Advance's. The buildings are different. The plan is the thread.
A Brother From Woodhaven
Wenige was raised a Master Mason in Advance Lodge No. 635 on December 15, 1903. The register made him the lodge's 294th member and gave his age as twenty-six.[1] Advance had been chartered in 1867. It still met in rented rooms, and its history counts ninety-seven Master Masons on the roll in 1900.[2][3]
He did not live in Astoria. A Times Union profile of December 1906 found him in Woodhaven, a civil engineer by profession and an assistant engineer in the Queens Borough President's office.[28][2] It caught him at a busy moment. He was a first lieutenant on the staff of the Fourteenth Regiment, a veteran of the Seventh Regiment in Manhattan, a member of the Kings County Democratic Club and the German Liederkranz, and president of a new Democratic club in his election district, which had just turned a two-to-one Republican vote into a Democratic majority of forty-eight. At the club's first smoker, the paper reported, President Wenige spent the evening making sure every guest had tobacco and a corncob pipe.[28]
He also practiced in a partnership, Wenige & Nelson. Who Nelson was, and how the two men divided the work, has not yet been traced.
Brooklyn Manor Builds a Temple
North of Jamaica Avenue, lots were being sold under the name Brooklyn Manor, and in 1911 the neighborhood got a lodge.[21] Hillside was instituted on May 29, 1911, and chartered as No. 894 on May 8, 1912.[3] It began with about thirty members and met at first in Arcanum Hall in Richmond Hill.[6][19] Advance's history says Wenige dimitted from Advance to become one of its charter members.[2]
Hillside did not rent for long. In September 1913 the Brooklyn Daily Eagle described plans for a temple on Willard Avenue, now 96th Street, just north of Jamaica Avenue. The design was to be "somewhat after the style of the Temple of Diana," and the architects were Wenige & Nelson.[4] The lodge formed a holding company to own the property, with Wenige as its secretary.[4][6]
Ground was broken on October 2, 1913.[5] Six weeks later, on Saturday afternoon, November 15, Grand Master Charles Smith arrived with his staff to lay the cornerstone. The list of officers in the ceremony names Wenige twice: once as Senior Warden and again among the trustees on the finance committee.[6] He had drawn the building, helped pay for it, and now walked in the procession to its foundation.
The finished temple was a hollow-tile building faced in stucco, about thirty-seven feet wide and a hundred feet deep. Four heavy columns stood across the front, and a red-cement stair led up to the entrance. The banquet hall was below. The lodge room was upstairs, and it had no windows.[7] Whatever happened in it, Willard Avenue was not going to watch.
By the last week of January 1914 the lodge was holding a fair for its building fund in what the Brooklyn Daily Times called the "handsome new temple on Willard avenue," and the paper reported the hall packed on opening night. Wenige was now Master. Mrs. Arthur Wenige ran the table for smokers' articles. The fair was opened by the Deputy Grand Master of the state, George Freifeld, who congratulated the lodge on its building.[8]
Master of the Room He Drew
For most of 1914, then, Wenige presided in a lodge room his own firm had designed. At the close of the year, as retiring Master, he reported on a lodge barely three years old whose property was valued at close to $25,000 and whose roll had reached about 150. The same election made him a trustee for three years.[9] When Hillside installed its officers in January 1916, he served as a past master and as deputy grand marshal for the evening.[10]
His name ran through Woodhaven's civic life as well. In 1912 he sat on the executive committee of the Nameoke Democratic Club and was listed among the Queens organizers of the Empire State Democracy. The next year he was treasurer of the Woodhaven Independent Democracy, and The Chat remarked that he had always given time and money liberally to public projects.[11] In the Democratic primary of 1916 he won the nomination for alderman in the Seventieth District, defeating Bernard F. McCabe.[12]
A Hard Season
The record does not allow a tidy portrait. In March 1912, while Hillside was still meeting in Arcanum Hall, the Adjutant-General's office announced that Captain Arthur E. Wenige of the Fourteenth Infantry had resigned from the National Guard "for the good of the service." The charge was that he had allowed outsiders to answer for absent men of his company at the annual inspection.[13]
The Eagle added that he was a Yale graduate. A month later it withdrew the degree, Yale having reported that he had never been enrolled.[13]
The matter did not end there. In May 1917 the legislature passed an act authorizing the governor to restore him to his former rank and place him on the reserve list, and the law was printed in the papers that summer.[14] What happened in the five years between, the clippings do not say.
Tadmor Starts in Woodhaven
Hillside's new building soon housed another lodge's beginning. According to a thirty-first-anniversary history published in the Ridgewood Times in 1946, thirty-one Masons signed the petition for Tadmor Lodge on June 9, 1914, and the lodge was instituted under dispensation in Hillside's temple on August 26.[15]
That account was written more than thirty years after the event, and Tadmor's original petition and institution records would be firmer ground. Until they are checked, the Woodhaven setting rests on the lodge's own memory. The two lodges stayed in touch. In May 1925 The Chat announced that Hillside's Fellowcraft team would travel to Ridgewood to work the third degree at Tadmor.[16]
Astoria Asks for Help
Advance had wanted a building of its own for years. Its rooms over a tavern at Main Street and Fulton Avenue had a landlord who, in 1901, put up a fire escape that made the lodge room easy to reach for intruders and eavesdroppers, then told the trustees the lodge could leave whenever it liked. A building committee was formed in 1907. In December 1909 the trustees agreed to buy a lot 40 by 143 feet on the south side of Grand Avenue, about a hundred feet east of Van Alst Avenue, from the Rapalye estate for $4,000. A brother lent the money, title passed in February 1910, and the debt was paid off by January 1912.[2]
That April the lodge appointed a Committee of Eleven, which estimated the cost of a temple at $13,500. In June the trustees were authorized to issue $15,000 in four-percent bonds.[2]
The lodge's printed history says several architects were invited to submit plans and that Wenige & Nelson's were accepted, adding that the interior layout of the Astoria temple closely resembled Hillside's.[2] Another account in Advance's records is more specific. It says the lodge had trouble finding an architect, and that Wenige's firm, as a favor, prepared the prints at a reasonable rate, supplying for the lodge room the same blueprints it had used at Hillside. The rest of the building was drawn for Astoria.[1] The favor did not mean working for nothing: the building committee's final accounting included the architect's fee.[2]
The choice made practical sense. A lodge room is not a free-form hall. Its stations, chairs and floor have to fall where the ritual expects them, and by 1915 Hillside's room had been in use for more than a year.
By then Wenige was no longer on Advance's roll. He had dimitted to join Hillside, so the help came from a former member.[2]
What a Shared Plan Proves
The evidence supports a reused plan. It does not show that the two finished rooms were identical. Builders depart from drawings, furnishings change, and Hillside's building was enlarged within a decade. No saving in fees or time is recorded, either. Proving that the two interiors matched in their dimensions and details would take the original drawings, construction records or measured surveys of both rooms, and none has yet been found.
What the record does show is narrower and still unusual: one lodge's building project carried a finished piece of another's.
Grand Avenue, 1915 and 1916
Drawings were the easy part. Money was slower. Brethren who had promised to buy bonds hesitated, and a year passed with the fund still short. In 1914 a Bond Finance Committee launched what it called a "Whirlwind Campaign," with Brother John W. Owen driving committeemen from one member's house to the next in his three-seated Cadillac, and the fund soon reached $12,700. When the Building Committee still held back, Master William K. Brown discharged it and appointed a new one under Joseph Gelson. Bids were opened on September 24, 1915. The contract went to H. H. Vought and Company for $15,989, and ground was broken three days later.[2]
On Saturday, November 20, 1915, some eight hundred Masons marched behind the Mecca Temple band and Knights Templar from the lodge's old rooms to the Grand Avenue site, where Grand Master George Freifeld, who had opened Hillside's fair as Deputy Grand Master less than two years before, laid the cornerstone. Henry Martin read the lodge's history and Henry C. Johnson gave the oration.[29][17] The stone itself was the gift of James Prowse Jr.[2]
The three-story temple opened with a week-long fair beginning April 24, 1916, its electric lighting among the attractions, and the lodge held its first meeting there on May 30.[2] Members supplied much of the finish themselves. One gave the stone columns of the entrance porch; the Stockton brothers and Archibald Munro cut and fitted the limestone for the facade; others gave the altar, the Master's jewel and a letter G built from hundreds of pieces of stained glass.[2] The building committee's final report that September put the cost of the building, including extras and the architect's fee, at $17,905.15, with another $3,157.77 for fittings and furniture. All of it had been paid, and the balance went into a fund to retire the bonds.[2]
On November 14, 1916, during the mastership of William T. Blunt, the temple was dedicated. Past Grand Master Townsend Scudder officiated by authority of Grand Master Thomas Penney, assisted by Acting Deputy Grand Master Oscar F. Treder.[2] The room plan was one contribution among many: land, bonds, trustees, a contractor, gifts from members and a great deal of committee work.
Bayside Took Another Road
Not every Queens lodge borrowed its plans. Bayside Lodge No. 999 built its temple at Bell and Lamartine Avenues in 1923. The Bayside Historical Society names Herbert O. Wiegand as the architect and the Gabler Construction Company as the builder, and gives the dedication as December 10, 1923.[22] Joan Brown Wettingfeld's history says Wiegand supplied plans and specifications and supervised the work without charge.[23] A newspaper report that spring gave the lodge room as 33 by 53 feet.[24]
Nothing in those sources connects Bayside's design to Wenige's. The two stories describe different routes to a finished room, though both ran through a brother's profession.
Two Buildings, Two Fates
Hillside soon outgrew its temple. In August 1920 the Eagle recalled that the building had once been thought "large enough for all time." Membership had climbed from about thirty to nearly five hundred, and an enlargement was planned to seat four hundred, with Wenige on the finance committee.[19] Whether the windowless upper room survived that work, or was enlarged or replaced, is not known. By 1925 the temple also housed Prosperity Lodge No. 962.[20]
The lodge and the building then went separate ways. Hillside consolidated with Council Lodge No. 979 in 1963, and Council-Hillside joined Springfield Gardens Lodge No. 1057 in 1994.[3] The building was sold to Queens Tabernacle in 1986, according to Joel Steven Kuszai's history; that date has not been checked against the deed.[21] The church gives its address as 86-03 96th Street. Above the entrance, a sculpted open book still displays Psalm 133: "Behold how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity."[25] How much of the old lodge room lies behind it has not been surveyed.
The Astoria building stayed in Masonic hands. Advance consolidated with Island City Mizpah in 1993 and took in Service City Geba in 2018, becoming Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586.[3] As of November 2026, Advance Service Mizpah, Parthenon Lodge No. 1101 and Tadmor Lodge No. 923 all meet there.[26] That is continuing use, not an untouched 1916 interior; later repairs, furnishings and alterations have yet to be documented.
Tadmor's road to Astoria ran through Ridgewood's temples and, by 2011, an American Legion hall in Forest Hills.[27] When it arrived at Advance has not been confirmed from its minutes.
The Drawing That Outlasted the Man
Wenige left a thin paper trail: a line in a register, a few committee lists, a primary result, a resignation and a law passed in Albany to undo it. Even his dates of birth and death have not been found.
His most durable work carries no signature. Masons in Astoria still open lodge in a room whose lines were first set down for a lodge in Woodhaven.
Notes and Sources
- Records of Advance Lodge No. 635, examined by Brete Murphy: register entry for Arthur E. Wenige (raised December 15, 1903; 294th member; age 26); the lodge's account of its search for an architect and of Wenige & Nelson's prints and lodge-room blueprints. Privately held by the lodge; not publicly accessible.
- The History of Advance Lodge No. 635 (lodge booklet; edition and page numbers to be added). Membership in 1900; Wenige's 1906 post; his dimit and charter membership in Hillside; "The Building Era, 1900–1916" (from p. 26): the 1901 fire escape, the 1907 committee, the Rapalye lot and its price, the Committee of Eleven, the bonds, the architects invited and Wenige & Nelson's plans accepted, the Whirlwind Campaign, Gelson's committee, the Vought contract, ground breaking, cornerstone, first meeting, members' gifts including the cornerstone from W. Bro. James Prowse, the September 1916 final report, and the dedication under Master William T. Blunt by Townsend Scudder for Grand Master Thomas C. Penny (the booklet's spelling).
- Grand Lodge of the State of New York records, compiled by Brete Murphy: Advance Lodge No. 635 chartered July 2, 1867; Hillside Lodge No. 894 instituted May 29, 1911 and chartered May 8, 1912; Hillside and Council consolidation, 1963; Council-Hillside into Springfield Gardens No. 1057, 1994; Advance and Island City Mizpah, 1993; Service City Geba into Advance Service Mizpah No. 586, 2018.
- Brooklyn Daily Eagle, September 28, 1913, p. 5.
- The Chat, October 4, 1913, p. 55.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, November 14, 1913, p. 10 (advance notice of the cornerstone ceremony and officers); Brooklyn Daily Eagle, November 16, 1913, p. 67 (the ceremony).
- Brooklyn Daily Times, January 5, 1914, p. 8.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, January 27, 1914, p. 8.
- Brooklyn Daily Eagle, December 19, 1914, p. 4.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, January 7, 1916, p. 12.
- Daily Long Island Democrat, August 5, 1912, p. 1; The Chat, November 29, 1913, p. 53.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, August 23, 1916, p. 12; Brooklyn Daily Eagle, September 20, 1916, p. 8.
- Adjutant-General's Office, State of New York, General Orders No. 12, March 12, 1912; Brooklyn Daily Eagle, March 25, 1912, p. 1; Brooklyn Daily Times, March 25, 1912, p. 6; Brooklyn Daily Eagle, April 23, 1912, p. 5 (correction concerning Yale).
- Laws of the State of New York, 1917, chapter 639; Brooklyn Daily Eagle, August 27, 1917, p. 13; The Post-Star (Glens Falls), September 7, 1917, p. 10.
- Ridgewood Times, June 14, 1946 (Tadmor Lodge thirty-first-anniversary history; page to be added).
- The Chat, May 9, 1925 (page to be added).
- Henry Martin, "Historical Data of Advance Lodge No. 635 F&AM," address at the laying of the cornerstone, Grand Avenue east of Van Alst Avenue, November 20, 1915. Lodge collection.
- Building committee final report, Advance Lodge No. 635, September 1916, as summarized in the lodge history (note 2). Lodge collection.
- Brooklyn Daily Eagle, August 30, 1920, pp. 16 and 20.
- Brooklyn Daily Times, January 4, 1925 (page to be added).
- Joel Steven Kuszai, "Hillside Temple," August 29, 2026, Hillside Temple
Hillside Temple By Joel Steven Kuszai
Once the home of Jamaica 41
- Bayside Historical Society, "Masonic Lodge," Masonic Lodge
Masonic Lodge Explore the history of Bayside, Queens, through Bayside Historical Society’s collection of vintage photographs culled from our archives.
- Joan Brown Wettingfeld, "Our History: Masonic Temple Symbolic of Cultural Landmark," QNS, February 8, 2007. URL to be recovered.
- Brooklyn Daily Eagle, May 31, 1923, p. 26.
- Kevin Walsh, "Woodhaven to Forest Hills 2022," Forgotten New York, October 29, 2023 (URL to be recovered); Queens Tabernacle, Home Page - Queens Tabernacle
(present address). 26. Present meeting arrangements as of November 2026, confirmed by the author, who is Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586. 27. Daily News, June 28, 2011 (page to be added). 28. "Arthur E. Wenige," Times Union (Brooklyn), December 2, 1906, p. 14. 29. "Lay Cornerstone for Masonic Temple," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, November 21, 1915, p. 81.
Follow the 273 Line. Part 1: The 273 Line, Start Here · Part 2: Atwood Lodge and the 1852 Division · Part 3: Metropolitan Lodge No. 273 · Part 4: Whitestone Lodge No. 973 · Part 5: Bayside Lodge No. 999 · Part 6: The Engineer's Room (you are here) · Part 7: Francis Lewis Lodge No. 273 and Brandeis
← Part 5: Bayside Lodge No. 999 · Part 7: Francis Lewis and Brandeis →
More connecting stories: The Seven Lodges: Start Here · Connecting Stories Across the Seven Lodges
Continue reading: The Hillside Temple in Woodhaven · A Cornerstone, a Dinner, and a Borough in a Hurry · Masonic Buildings in Queens