Isaac E. Ditmars, Sacred Heart Basilica, New Jersey.
Freemasonry in Queens › Notable Freemasons of Queens › Queens Masonic Lodge Histories › Advance Lodge No. 635
Raised in Astoria in 1873 as the lodge's ninety-first member, a young man from Nova Scotia went on to run one of New York's busiest architectural offices. His firm's work still stands on Park Avenue, Prince Street, and 14th Street.
Ninety-First on the Roll
Isaac E. Ditmars was initiated an Entered Apprentice in Advance Lodge No. 635 on March 4, 1873. The Astoria lodge was only seven years past its dispensation, and he was about twenty-three. On the first of November that year he was raised a Master Mason, the ninety-first man on the rolls of a lodge that was still writing its first chapters. Nothing in the entry hints at what came next. The young Nova Scotian in the lodge room that year would spend the next half-century in the trade that gives Freemasonry its whole vocabulary. His name would appear on drawings for seminaries and hospitals, churches and mansions, and one of the best-known facades on 14th Street.
The lodge's own record holds a small puzzle. It lists his residence as Nova Scotia even at the moment he was raised. That points to a young man who had not yet settled where home would be. The record does not say how he came to knock on an Astoria door, and it is better not to guess. What it does show is that Advance took him in at the very beginning of his career. In the years right after his raising, he seems to have been an active member, not a name entered once and forgotten.
Learning the Trade by Hand
Ditmars had come to New York as a youth to study architecture. At that time the profession had no tidy academic path, and most young men learned it the way apprentices always had: at a drafting table in someone else's office. His teacher was the New York architect John F. Miller. Under Miller he learned the practical side of the work, including specifications, elevations, and the slow job of turning a client's wishes into something a builder could put up.
By 1878 his work was in print. He was one of the designers whose ornamental plates appeared that year in the Art-Worker, a New York journal devoted to design for industry. It published patterns meant for wallpaper, textiles, and decorative trades, at a time when American designers were absorbing the English design reformers. For a young man only five years past his raising, it was a modest but real sign that his hand was getting noticed.
He had a double education in those years. In the lodge, the square, the level, and the plumb were emblems, tools turned into lessons about conduct. In the drafting room, they were simply how the work got done. Ditmars was learning both meanings at the same time.
The Office at 111 Fifth Avenue
In the mid-1880s Ditmars joined William Schickel.
Schickel was German-born, had worked briefly under Richard Morris Hunt, and already had loyal patrons among New York's German-American families and the Catholic Church. His Dominican convent on Lexington Avenue, now the St. Vincent Ferrer Priory, dates from 1880–81. The firm's early dates differ by source. Ditmars's obituary dated the partnership to 1885, while city landmark researchers place him in William Schickel & Co. by 1887. Another architect, Hugo Kafka, joined at the same time but stayed only a short while. By the mid-1890s the firm was Schickel & Ditmars, with offices at 111 Fifth Avenue, and the partnership lasted until Schickel's death in 1907.
The two men split the work cleanly. Schickel was the principal designer. Ditmars ran the business: clients, contracts, and accounts, which meant keeping a busy office solvent and on schedule. Some of the firm's contract books from the mid-1890s survive, and the details in them show his side of the practice. When the firm hired builder Thomas J. Brady in 1897, the contract set a fine of $100 a day if the job ran past September 1. The deadline was met.
Merchants, Bankers, and the Faithful
The office took on an unusually wide range of work. In 1888 it finished a Romanesque Revival building for John Jacob Astor III on Prince Street. It was far more ornate than its industrial neighbors, and it has since become the Mercer Hotel. Next came the department stores of the Ladies' Mile: the Ehrich Brothers store on Sixth Avenue in 1889, and an addition to Stern Brothers on West 23rd Street in 1892.
The firm's most loyal commercial clients were Isidor and Nathan Straus of R. H. Macy & Co. For them it designed a nine-story annex on 13th Street, and in 1897 a second annex at 56 West 14th Street. That building is only twenty-five feet wide, clad in limestone and topped with copper acroteria, a confident Beaux-Arts design squeezed onto a narrow lot. It cost $94,470. In 2011 New York City designated it a landmark.
The firm also did residential work for wealthy clients:
an apartment house on Madison Avenue at 83rd Street in 1898, which has since become a diplomatic mission
town houses for E. G. Jennings on East 82nd Street and William Baumgarten on Riverside Drive
in 1900, a new front on a 57th Street brownstone for Samuel W. Bowne, a manufacturer of cod liver oil. A century later a New York Times columnist wrote that it looked like a Baroque-style refrigerator, and he meant it fondly.
Alongside all this ran the work for the Church. On Baxter Street, the firm designed the lower church of Most Precious Blood,
begun in 1891 for an Italian parish that worshipped in its basement for years while it raised money for the rest. At Dunwoodie in Yonkers, St. Joseph's Seminary rose between 1891 and 1896 as a massive Romanesque pile of stone. On Park Avenue at 84th Street, the Church of St. Ignatius Loyola was built between 1895 and 1900. It is now a city landmark and is widely counted among the firm's finest work.
Under His Own Name
Schickel's death in 1907 left Ditmars in charge, and he kept going for more than two decades. In 1908 Bowne hired him again, this time for a twelve-story apartment house on West 81st Street, facing what is now the American Museum of Natural History. It offered full-floor apartments behind a Beaux-Arts front with balconies. Today it is known as Hayden House.
The institutional work grew. His obituary credited him or his firm with buildings at Lenox Hill Hospital and St. Vincent's Hospital, the Roman Catholic chapel at Bellevue, and the Roman Catholic Orphan Asylum at Kingsbridge. It also listed the Cathedral of the Sacred Heart in Newark,
described as "recently erected" when he died. The firm had taken over that design after the cathedral's first architect, Jeremiah O'Rourke, was dismissed in 1910.
The business side produced at least one public dispute. Ditmars had promised a draftsman named Varney an extra five dollars a week and, at year's end, a "fair share" of the profits. In 1916 the case reached New York's highest court, which held that the promise was too vague to enforce. Varney v. Ditmars
still appears in contracts casebooks, so the business partner's name has outlived the case in an odd way.
A Fellow of the Profession
Through all of this, Ditmars lived in Brooklyn's Park Slope for forty years. He was a Fellow of the American Institute of Architects. He was also a founder and later president of its Brooklyn Chapter, part of the generation that turned architecture from a craft learned at someone's elbow into a profession with standards, officers, and yearbooks. The chapter's 1908 yearbook
lists him on its board of directors. The Holland Society of New York, which admitted men descended from the early Dutch settlers of New York, carried him on its rolls by 1890. That membership tied the man from Nova Scotia back to one of the oldest family lines in the city.
He retired in 1930 and moved to Scarsdale. At the end of February 1934, after a week's illness, he died at his home on Reimer Road at the age of eighty-four. He was survived by a son, Harold Edward Ditmars, and a daughter, Mrs. Pompeo M. Maresi, both of Brooklyn.
The First Entry
None of these buildings belongs to Advance Lodge, and it would be wrong to claim them. What the lodge does have is the beginning. In 1873 a young man with a Nova Scotia address and no reputation yet was entered on its rolls as number ninety-one. Over the next six decades he spent his working life with the real versions of the tools the lodge used as symbols. He ran an office, kept its contracts, and saw stone, brick, and limestone go up across the city. The lodge record of him is brief, and it comes at the very start of his career, before any of the buildings that later carried his name.
Endnotes
Lodge and Grand Lodge Records
Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons of the State of New York, membership records for Advance Lodge No. 635: Isaac E. Ditmars, Entered Apprentice March 4, 1873; Master Mason November 1, 1873.
Advance Lodge No. 635, lodge records (now held by Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586), as consulted by the lodge historian.
Newspapers
"Isaac Edward Ditmars; Retired Architect Designed Many Important Buildings," New York Times, March 2, 1934, p. 19.
Christopher Gray, "Streetscapes," New York Times, February 13, 2000, and October 30, 2005, as cited in Carter Horsley, "Hayden House at 11 West 81st Street," CityRealty.
"Czech Republic Plans to Gut UES Mission Building on Madison Avenue," DNAinfo New York, 2016.
Government and Preservation Records
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, R. H. Macy & Co. Store, 14th Street Annex Designation Report (LP-2474),
December 20, 2011, prepared by Jay Shockley.
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, St. Vincent Ferrer Priory and School Designation Report (LP-1052),
May 19, 1981, prepared by James T. Dillon.
Organizational Records
ed. Charles T. Mott.
- [Year Book of the Holland Society of New York, 1890–1891](Individual : DITMARS - Year book of the Holland Society of New York - 1890-1891 - Search the Genealogy Library
Individual : DITMARS - Year book of the Holland Society of New York - 1890-1891 - Search the Genealogy Library Search individuals in the Geneanet Genealogy Library
- Art-Worker: A Journal of Design Devoted to Art-Industry (New York, 1878), contributor listing as cited in later scholarship on American ornamental design.
Legal Records
New York Court of Appeals, decided February 22, 1916.
Other Sources
Basilica of St. Patrick's Old Cathedral.
Urban Archive, "Astor Building" (Mercer Hotel), 99 Prince Street.
[Lehman College Art Gallery, "Schickel & Ditmars, Architects"](Public Art & Architecture in the Bronx | Lehman College
Public Art & Architecture in the Bronx | Lehman College By Lehman College
Daytonian in Manhattan, "The William Schickel House, 52 East 83rd Street".
Dennis S. Francis, Architects in Practice, New York City 1840–1900, and James Ward, Architects in Practice, New York City 1900–1940, as cited in LPC reports.
Continue Reading
Another architect from Advance Lodge: Arthur E. Wenige and the Advance Lodge Room
More Advance Lodge members: Notable Freemasons of Queens
The lodges behind the members: Queens Masonic Lodge Histories
Start at the beginning: Freemasonry in Queens