Paton and Wolcott Noble: Brothers of Advance Lodge No. 635 in Long Island City

In the winter of 1895 and the spring of 1896, two sons of a Long Island City legal family were raised in Advance Lodge No. 635. One kept order in a Queens courtroom; the other made his way through the Democratic politics of the borough.

Start Here: Freemasonry in Queens · Series Hub: Notable Freemasons of Queens · Lodge History: Advance Lodge No. 635

← Previous Article | Next Article →


In the space of a single season, two brothers from one of Long Island City's best-known legal families made the same journey to the same altar. Paton Noble was raised a Master Mason in Advance Lodge No. 635 on December 17, 1895, and his older brother Wolcott followed on April 14, 1896, four months later. The records do not say whether they planned it together, but the sequence reads like one brother holding the door for the other. For the Nobles, the lodge in Astoria became one more room in a family life already lived largely in public, among law offices, courtrooms and political clubs in a city that was about to disappear into Greater New York.

A House Built on the Law

The Noble name carried weight on the Queens side of the East River long before either brother knelt at Advance's altar. Their father, Solomon B. Noble, was a lawyer who had sat in the New York State Assembly, and he practiced in Long Island City with his son Daniel under the firm name S. B. & D. Noble. Daniel had been schooled in Brooklyn and then sent to Germany with two of his brothers from 1870 to 1876, an unusual education for boys of that era, before finishing at Columbia Law School in 1881.

Daniel Noble's career set the tone for the household. Elected justice of the peace in Long Island City in 1892 and Queens County District Attorney the following year, he became Surrogate of Queens County in 1898 and held that seat until age forced his retirement in 1929. He, too, was a Freemason. Solomon Noble died in 1895, the same year Paton came to Advance, and from then on the family's public face belonged to the sons: Daniel, Paton, Wolcott and John.

The Clerk of Hunter's Point

When Paton presented himself to Advance Lodge, the Grand Lodge register entered him as thirty years old and working in real estate. Within a few years he had found his true calling behind a different kind of desk. By the summer of 1898 he was chief clerk of the Hunter's Point Court, and the Long Island City Daily Star recorded that July how he and Thomas J. Connerty, chief clerk of the Third District Court at Far Rockaway, traded posts for two weeks, each man minding the other's docket while a colleague rested.

The swap is a small item, but it shows Paton at the center of the borough's legal machinery in its most unsettled year. Consolidation in 1898 folded Long Island City into the new City of New York, and its courts were reorganized along with everything else. Paton came through the change with his standing intact. By 1904 he was Chief Clerk of the First District Police Court of Queens, and he was described as well known both politically and socially in Long Island City. Lawyers, court attachés and officers alike counted him exceedingly popular.

There is a quiet kinship between the two rooms in which Paton spent his evenings and his working days. A courtroom and a lodge room both run on procedure: an officer presiding from the east or the bench, a clerk or secretary keeping the record, every person in an assigned place and every motion made in proper form. A man trusted to keep a magistrate's calendar straight would have recognized the order of a lodge at labor. He lived at 152 Twelfth Street in Long Island City, a short distance from the courthouse that defined his career. Paton Noble died in November 1904, not yet forty, and still holding the chief clerk's desk.

A Brother on Crescent Street

Wolcott Noble was born in Chatham, in Columbia County, New York, on August 25, 1861, the elder of the two Advance brothers by about four years. When he was raised in April 1896, at thirty-four, the lodge record placed him at 717 Crescent Street, well inside the Long Island City and Astoria orbit from which Advance drew its members. The lodge then met in its old hall at Main Street and Fulton Avenue, today the top of 22nd Street where Main Street meets Astoria Boulevard, two decades before the Grand Avenue temple rose.

Where Paton served the courts, Wolcott worked the politics that staffed them. Queens in the 1890s was the domain of Mayor Patrick J. Gleason and his rivals, a world in which a brother's election could turn on the favor of a faction. Daniel had first won office with Gleason's help and later broke with him. Wolcott moved through that same landscape, and when he died the newspapers remembered him not merely as the Surrogate's brother but as a well-known Democratic politician of Queens in his own right.

Last Light at Hunter's Point

Wolcott outlived Paton by nearly nine years. On Sunday, June 29, 1913, he was found dead in the Elks Club House at Hunter's Point, felled by heart disease at fifty-one. The setting suits the man. The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks had organized Queensborough Lodge No. 878 in 1903 and kept its home in Long Island City for two decades, and its clubhouse was a gathering place for the same circle of officeholders, lawyers and party men among whom Wolcott had spent his life. He died, in other words, among the kind of company he had always kept.

Daniel carried the family name another quarter century, serving on the Surrogate's bench until 1929 and dying in 1937. By then the brothers who had followed one another to Advance's altar were long gone, and Long Island City itself had become a neighborhood rather than a city.

Two Names in the Advance Lodge No. 635 Register

In the Grand Lodge register, Paton and Wolcott Noble occupy two lines entered four months apart, one marked real estate, one marked with an address on Crescent Street. Read against the rest of their lives, those lines open onto a family that spent itself in public service: one brother at the clerk's desk of a Queens courtroom, one in the clubs and campaigns of the borough's Democrats, both answering to the same lodge in Astoria. Advance Lodge No. 635 was full of men who built, printed, blasted and governed the place around it. The Noble brothers belong to that company as the men who kept its courts in order and its politics in motion, and who chose, within a single season, to call the same lodge home.


Endnotes

Lodge and Grand Lodge records

  • Grand Lodge of the State of New York, membership register: Paton Noble, Advance Lodge No. 635, raised December 17, 1895, age 30, occupation real estate.

  • Grand Lodge of the State of New York, membership register: Wolcott Noble, Advance Lodge No. 635, raised April 14, 1896, age 34, residence 717 Crescent Street.

  • The History of Advance Lodge No. 635 (lodge history booklet), for the lodge's charter and early meeting place.

Newspapers

  • Long Island City Daily Star, July 21, 1898, local news column (Paton Noble and Thomas J. Connerty exchange chief clerk posts). Transcription via Brooklyn Genealogy Info.

  • The New York Times, November 14, 1904, p. 12 (Paton Noble as Chief Clerk of the First District Police Court of Queens; residence; standing in Long Island City).

  • The New York Times, July 1, 1913, p. 9 (obituary of Wolcott Noble: born Chatham, N.Y., August 25, 1861; died at the Elks Club House, Hunter's Point; Democratic politician of Queens).

  • "Daniel Noble Dies; Long a Surrogate," The New York Times, May 31, 1937, p. 16.

  • "Dan Noble Dies; Queens Pioneer," Brooklyn Daily Eagle, May 31, 1937.

Published histories and reference works


Continue Exploring

Start Here: Freemasonry in Queens

Series Hub: Notable Freemasons of Queens

Lodge History: Advance Lodge No. 635 · Queens Masonic Lodge Histories

Buildings: Masonic Buildings in Queens · The Advance Masonic Temple

Related Member Profiles

← Previous Article | Next Article →


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Next
Next

Peter G. Van Alst Jr.: Astoria Surveyor of Advance Lodge No. 635