John Hetherington of Advance Lodge No. 635: From Belfast to the Queens Surrogate's Bench

An Irish-born attorney entered an Astoria lodge at thirty. In time he presided over it as Master, and later the people of Queens brought him their wills.

In this article: A Boy from Belfast · Six Days Shy of Thirty-One · At the Prosecutor's Table · A Bench in Long Island City · The Court of Last Wishes · The Matter of a Birthday · Ballots, Benefits and the Lodge Room · Ninety-Six Years · Endnotes


Justice John Hethrington of Advance Lodge No. 635, Astoria, New York

John Hethrington, Advance Lodge No. 635 (photo from the personal collection of Brete Murphy)

On December 15, 1903, the register of Advance Lodge No. 635 in Astoria recorded a new brother in a single line: John Hethrington, thirty years old, attorney, born in Ireland. The clerk dropped an "e" from the name and gave nothing more than his age, his trade and his birthplace. The entry gives no hint that this young lawyer would one day sit in the East as Master of the lodge, serve as a district deputy among the lodges of Queens, and spend twelve years as the judge to whom the borough brought its wills. It also gives no hint of how long he would stay. Hetherington lived to ninety-six, and his obituary in 1969 still made a point of calling him a past master of Advance Lodge.

A Boy from Belfast

He was born in Belfast on December 21, 1872. Decades later a New York court would have to confirm that date. He came to the United States with his family at about fifteen and settled in Astoria. By 1930 he had lived there for more than forty years, long enough to have watched the village grow into part of a city. He became a naturalized citizen in 1894.

Law came next. Hetherington studied at New York University Law School and began practicing around 1898, the year Long Island City and the rest of western Queens were folded into Greater New York. The city of Long Island City, incorporated in 1870, ended just as his career began. He spent his working life as a lawyer of the new borough, one in which courts, offices and political loyalties were all being rearranged.

Six Days Shy of Thirty-One

When the Advance register took his name, he was six days short of his thirty-first birthday. The lodge was then nearly forty years old. It had worked under dispensation in 1866 and received its charter in 1867, drawing its members from the carpenters, blacksmiths, merchants, engineers and professional men of Astoria. A practicing attorney fit easily into that company, but the register suggests he arrived in good company too. The same date appears for Arthur E. Wenige, the young architect whose firm would one day give the lodge the plans for its lodge room. That night two men entered the lodge who would each, in his own field, help shape it for decades.

A clerk could hardly have guessed that the attorney would last the longest. Over the following years Hetherington took on more and more responsibility in the lodge, until he was installed as its Master. He later served as district deputy, the Grand Master's representative to the lodges of his district. That office calls for a steady temper and a working knowledge of Masonic law, and he had already practiced both kinds of discipline in the courtroom.

At the Prosecutor's Table

His public career began in the Queens County District Attorney's office. From 1909 to 1914 Hetherington served as chief assistant district attorney. He came in under District Attorney Frederick G. DeWitt and stayed on when Matthew J. Smith took office in 1911. Then he went back to private practice, now with a reputation earned in the borough's criminal courts.

He was a Democrat and a dependable one. In 1930 a reporter described him as a longtime supporter of the regular party organization who generally kept out of factional quarrels, which was a real accomplishment in Queens politics. Inside the lodge, a man known for avoiding feuds would have been just as valuable.

A Bench in Long Island City

In 1919 the voters sent him to the Municipal Court. From 1920 to 1930 he sat for the Long Island City district, hearing the ordinary civil disputes of the waterfront and its neighborhoods: unpaid bills, small contracts, quarrels between landlords and tenants. When his term came up in 1929, he ran with both the Democratic and the Republican nominations. In a partisan borough, few signs of a judge's standing say more than that.

The Court of Last Wishes

On May 7, 1930, Richard S. Newcombe died at forty-nine, only months after taking up his duties as Surrogate of Queens County. The vacancy was important. The Surrogate's Court handles wills, estates and guardianships, so it sees families at their most exposed. On July 9, 1930, Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt appointed John Hetherington to the post. Lawyers, judges and civic figures had backed him, and Queens Democratic leader John Theofel had endorsed him. That November the voters elected him to the office.

For the next twelve years the borough's wills passed across his desk. The Brooklyn papers followed the work: contested wills sent to juries, a will admitted to probate after testimony that the testator had acted of his own free will, and the estate of theatrical producer William Harris Jr. filed in his court. In 1932 the Court of Appeals upheld his ruling that a Flushing widow, Mrs. Mary D. Des Anges, was entitled to stock worth more than $45,000 under her husband's will.

The work had a kinship with the lodge's own obligations. Freemasonry has long promised care to the widows and orphans of its members, and the Surrogate's Court exists largely to protect the same people. Hetherington spent his career on the bench making sure people received what had been left to them.

The Matter of a Birthday

His own records needed correcting too. New York's constitution barred a surrogate from serving past the end of the year in which he turned seventy. In January 1931 Hetherington had filed a certificate giving his birth year as 1873. In May 1942 he filed a corrected one giving 1872. The difference decided whether his office would fall vacant at the end of 1942 or a year later, and a petitioner went to court to stop the seat from appearing on that November's ballot. The court found that Hetherington was born December 21, 1872, ruled that the vacancy was real, and let the election go forward. The Advance Lodge register had recorded the right age back in 1903: thirty years old on December 15 of that year.

He retired from the bench at the end of 1942 and went back to practicing law, this time with his son.

Ballots, Benefits and the Lodge Room

His public life outside the courts ran through the same institutions that held Astoria together. He led fundraising for the Queens Young Women's Christian Association and for Methodist Hospital. That was the practical, civic kind of charity that lodge members of his generation took for granted as part of the work. Through all of it, his career moved in step with his Masonic one. The attorney who joined in 1903 had become chief assistant district attorney within six years, and by his fifties he was both a judge and a past master.

Ninety-Six Years

John Hetherington died on April 3, 1969, at the Forest Hills Nursing Home in Queens, at ninety-six. A son, a daughter, Mrs. Emily M. Glover, grandchildren and great-grandchildren survived him. The New York Times obituary listed what a long public life had amounted to: prosecutor, Municipal Court justice and Surrogate of Queens County. It also listed past master of Advance Lodge.

The Masonic line did not need to be there, and its inclusion says something. For twelve years Hetherington decided how other people's wishes would be carried out after they died. At the end, the people who wrote his own record judged that the lodge he had joined at thirty belonged in it. The register entry from 1903 had his name slightly wrong. Advance Lodge's history has the rest of it right: he joined as an attorney from Belfast, presided over the lodge as Master, and remained one of its members for the rest of a very long life.

↑ Back to top


Endnotes

Lodge Records

  • Advance Lodge No. 635, F. & A.M., Astoria: membership register entry for "John Hethrington," age 30, attorney, born Ireland, dated December 15, 1903. Transcribed by Brete Murphy.

  • Advance Lodge No. 635 records concerning Arthur E. Wenige (December 15, 1903) and the lodge-room plans. As seen by Brete Murphy.

Newspapers

The New York Times, July 10, 1930.

The New York Times, April 6, 1969.

("Court Sustains Stock Bequest of Des Anges"). Newspapers.com.

  • The Brooklyn Daily Eagle court items before Surrogate Hetherington, 1931, transcribed at Brooklyn Genealogy Info: [April–June 1931](Oops

Oops

-and [July–September 1931](Oops

Oops

Court and Public Records

New York Supreme Court, 1942 (Rubenstein, J.), on Surrogate Hetherington's birth-date certificates and the constitutional age limit. CourtListener.

  • New York State Constitution of 1894, as amended, Art. VI, § 19 (age limit for surrogates).

Local History and Context

  • ["Newcombe Square, Restored: Paying Tribute to the Honorable Richard S. Newcombe."](Community Eyes Restoration of Newcombe Square on Queens Boulevard

Community Eyes Restoration of Newcombe Square on Queens Boulevard By BQE Admin

Views: 268By Michael Perlman Chairman, Rego-Forest Preservation Council Amidst the hustle and bustle of Queens Boulevard is the long-forgotten and neglected Newcombe Square, bordering Forest Hills and Kew Gardens. At 0.04 acres, this small but histo

Forest Hills Times, April 16, 2026.

Queens Name Explorer, Urban Archive.

Wikipedia.


More from the Queens History Blog: All Articles

· George U. Harvey: Queens Borough President and Mason

↑ Back to top

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Julius H. Striedinger After Hell Gate: Canals, Mines and a Death at Sea

Next
Next

Isaac E. Ditmars of Advance Lodge No. 635: The Nova Scotian Who Helped Build Gilded Age New York