One Lodge, Six Charters: Start Here with Advance Service Mizpah No. 586
Start exploring One Lodge, Six Charters, a series tracing Advance Service Mizpah Lodge No. 586 through its six predecessor lodges. Find your way into the lodge histories, temples, member profiles, and five consolidations that connect Manhattan, Astoria, Long Island City, Elmhurst, Jackson Heights, and Flushing.
Edward J. Knauer of Advance Lodge No. 635: From Chester A. Arthur's Office to the Master's Chair
From Chester A. Arthur’s law office to the Master’s chair of Advance Lodge No. 635, Edward J. Knauer built a life in law, fellowship and Long Island City politics. Twice elected Worshipful Master, he also led the city’s aldermen and became Queens County’s first Commissioner of Jurors.
At the Founding: Edward Chauncey Graham and Advance Lodge No. 635
Edward Chauncey Graham, a Manhattan-born insurance broker raised in Howard Lodge No. 35, helped found Advance Lodge No. 635 in Astoria. His story connects an old New York family with the lodge’s founding years.
From Forge to Council Table: John L. Morris, Charter Member of Advance Lodge No. 635
An Astoria blacksmith raised in Island City Lodge in 1866, John L. Morris helped found Advance Lodge No. 635. His story connects the lodge’s beginnings with the Odd Fellows’ hall and the Long Island City Board of Aldermen.
Keeper of Two Buildings: Joseph Gelson of Advance Lodge No. 635
Joseph Gelson tended Corona’s school buildings and helped Advance Lodge No. 635 build a home in Astoria. A school janitor-engineer, Past Master, chaplain and trustee, he appears in the records wherever an institution needed looking after—from the school’s alarm box to the committees behind its Grand Avenue temple.
Daniel Noble of Advance Lodge No. 635: A Queens Surrogate in the Astoria Lodge Room
Daniel Noble served as Queens County surrogate for thirty-one years, overseeing wills, estates, and guardianships. Raised in Advance Lodge No. 635 in 1888, he remained identified with the Astoria lodge throughout a public career shaped by Long Island City politics, courtroom disputes, and concern for the county’s records.
Townsend Scudder of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580: Congressman, Judge, and Grand Master of New York
Raised in Glen Cove in 1889, he went on to Congress, the bench and the Grand Master's chair. His name kept turning up at the cornerstones and installations of the Queens lodges that became Advance Service Mizpah No. 586.
James D. Torrey of Advance Lodge No. 635: The Show Printer Who Became the Lodge's First Treasurer
He printed the posters that sold circus tickets and published a Civil War history in monthly parts. In Astoria, a new lodge handed him its purse.
Caleb G. Francis: The Connecticut Merchant Who Became Advance Lodge's First Secretary
A Connecticut-born merchant raised in Williamsburgh, he kept the first records of a new lodge in Astoria. The scraps he left behind are worth reading closely.
Anthony “Speed” Hanzlik of Advance Lodge No. 635
Anthony “Speed” Hanzlik founded Speed’s Airport in College Point, the airfield that became Flushing Airport, and managed it until his death in 1974. Raised in Advance Lodge No. 635 in 1938, he connected Queens aviation history with the lodge’s membership through a life of flying, testing pilots, and keeping his airfield open.
A Founder Who Became Master: William M. Berger of Advance Lodge No. 635
William M. Berger was a young New York merchant when he was raised a Mason in 1866 and became a charter member of Advance Lodge No. 635 in Astoria. By 1878, he was its Master—one of seven charter members who went on to lead the lodge.
Mortimer's Mysteries: W. Golden Mortimer of Advance Lodge No. 635
Before becoming the first president of the Society of American Magicians, W. Golden Mortimer toured as a conjurer, practiced medicine, and led Advance Lodge No. 635 in Astoria. His story connects New York’s Masonic history with the guarded traditions of stage magic.
Two City Halls, One Mayor: The Masonic Life of Horatio S. Sanford of Advance Lodge No. 635
In 1893, Horatio S. Sanford became mayor of Long Island City after a disputed election—and was raised a Master Mason in Advance Lodge No. 635. His story follows rival city governments, reform battles, a public library, and a later life in Oregon.
The Engineer's Room: Arthur E. Wenige and the Lodge Room Queens Built Twice
Advance Lodge could not find an architect. A brother it had raised in 1903 sent over the lodge-room drawings his firm had already used in Woodhaven, and the room built from them is still at work in Astoria.
James Prowse Jr. and the Cornerstone of Advance Lodge No. 635
A marble buffer and stone cutter, James Prowse Jr. donated the 1915 cornerstone of Advance Lodge's Astoria temple, then helped found Astoria Lodge No. 963 and became its Master in 1926.
Henry Clay Johnson of Advance Lodge No. 635
Astoria postmaster, New York assemblyman, and state arbitration commissioner Henry Clay Johnson also spent thirty-eight years in Advance Lodge No. 635. Follow his public career and Masonic service to the November 1915 ceremony where he delivered the oration at the cornerstone of the lodge’s new temple.
John Allen and Advance Lodge No. 635
John Allen served as a Long Island City school commissioner, spent more than six decades in Freemasonry, and organized a benevolent lodge bearing his name. Trace his connections to Advance Lodge No. 635 and the Ancient Order of United Workmen through newspaper reports, lodge records, and Astoria’s fraternal life.
The Workmen of Astoria
A picnic, a crowded ball, and an anniversary smoker trace the history of John Allen Lodge No. 330 in Astoria. Explore how the Ancient Order of United Workmen brought fellowship and financial protection into local fraternal life—and how individual members connected it with Advance Lodge No. 635.
Fifty Years an Odd Fellow: James M. Whitcomb and the Founding of Advance Lodge No. 635
James M. Whitcomb helped found Advance Lodge No. 635 and served as its Treasurer, but his fraternal life began with the Odd Fellows in 1846. His story connects fifty years in that order with Astoria’s waterfront, volunteer fire service, and civic life.
From Hunters Point to Astoria: Charles Risdale and the Founding of Advance Lodge No. 635
English-born blacksmith Charles Risdale became a Mason at Hunters Point in 1866 and helped found Advance Lodge No. 635 in Astoria. His story connects Queens’ early lodges, Odd Fellows, and volunteer firemen—and traces a lodge lineage that survives today.