Part 22 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: Bayside Temple Shelter Plan · Next: Jerry Boertzel →
A wealthy Jamaica builder took the United States Treasurer to court to stop paying chaplains. When he died in 1929, atheist leaders spoke over his casket, and then the brothers of Springfield Gardens Lodge No. 1057 bowed their heads and said the Lord's Prayer.
The funeral chapel in Jamaica had seen many services, but never one quite like this. On a February night in 1929, the president of the American Association for the Advancement of Atheism stood over the body of James I. Elliott and spoke of religious belief "in scathing terms." So did the president of the Freethinkers of America. When they finished, a contingent of Freemasons stepped forward and recited the Lord's Prayer over the casket. The Times Union of Brooklyn described the scene: "The atheists held up their heads in defiance while the Masons bowed theirs in prayer" (Times Union, February 12, 1929).
A builder from Nova Scotia
Elliott was born in Berwick, Nova Scotia, in 1859. He moved to Worcester, Massachusetts, in 1877 and came to New York in 1904. For the last twenty-two years of his life he lived in the Jamaica area, finally at 131-70 222nd Street in Springfield Gardens, and he made a fortune as a building contractor in the years when southeast Queens was filling with new houses. At his funeral, speakers remarked on his "enviable business reputation."
The atheist's lawsuit
In middle age Elliott became one of the most militant unbelievers in America. He rose to chairman of the board of the American Association for the Advancement of Atheism, the society founded in New York in 1925 by Charles Lee Smith, a man who later became the last person convicted of blasphemy in the United States (Wikipedia, "Charles Lee Smith").
In 1926 Elliott went to court. He sued the Treasurer of the United States in the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia to stop the government from paying the salaries of the chaplains of Congress and of the army and navy. The trial court dismissed his bill, and he appealed. On January 9, 1928, the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia ruled against him in Elliott v. White, the appeal from "a decree in the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, dismissing appellant's bill for an injunction to prohibit the appellee, as Treasurer of the United States, from disbursing funds of the United States appropriated for salaries of the chaplains of the Senate and House of Representatives and of the army and navy of the United States." In the court's brief words, "the decree is affirmed, with costs."
The court never decided whether the chaplains were constitutional. It held that Elliott had no standing to bring the case. Relying on the Supreme Court's 1923 Frothingham decision, it rejected his argument that he sued as a citizen rather than a taxpayer (Counsel Stack, Elliott v. White).
A case that outlived him
Elliott lost, but his case did not disappear. More than fifty years later, when another atheist challenged the congressional chaplains, a federal judge in Washington dismissed the suit on the strength of the old decision, noting that a taxpayer's action of that kind "is precluded by our Court of Appeals' decision in Elliott v. White" (Murray v. Morton, 1981). Legal writers in the 2000s still described it as "the only D.C. Circuit decision definitively addressing the standing issue" for challenges to congressional chaplains. A Jamaica contractor's lawsuit became a precedent that the courts were citing generations after his death.
The Mason who left
Long before he became an atheist leader, the Times Union reported, Elliott "had joined the Masons." American Freemasonry requires every candidate to declare a belief in a Supreme Being, so a man who later championed atheism had, at some point, stood in a lodge and professed belief. By the time of his death he had not been affiliated with a lodge for years.
The members of Springfield Gardens Lodge No. 1057, his neighbors' lodge, did not forget him. They "volunteered and received permission from Mrs. Mary Elliott to conduct Masonic services." So the funeral at Collison's chapel had two halves. First came the eulogies by Charles Smith and Joseph Lewis, the leading voices of organized atheism in New York. Then came the Masons, praying over the casket and asking forgiveness for what they called Elliott's "fallacies and blindness."
The headline writer at the Times Union had a field day: "Atheists Divide Last Rites With Believers for Elliott," and below it, "Rich Jamaica Man Balked in His Last Defi by Lodge."
Fresh Pond
Elliott had views on burial too. He considered cemeteries "intolerable eyesores," and in keeping with his wishes his body was taken the next day to the Fresh Pond Crematory in Middle Village and cremated. His widow, Mary, survived him.
It is hard to say who had the last word. The atheists spoke first and the Masons spoke last, but Elliott had already chosen his ending: no grave, no stone, and a lawsuit in the federal reporters that still carries his name.
Sources
"Atheists Divide Last Rites With Believers for Elliott," Times Union (Brooklyn), February 12, 1929.
Elliott v. White, 23 F.2d 997, 57 App. D.C. 389 (D.C. Cir. 1928), via Counsel Stack and Hall Approved.
"Charles Lee Smith," Wikipedia.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Bayside Temple Shelter Plan · Next: Jerry Boertzel → · Series Guide
Related on BreteMurphy.com