Part 21 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: Cathedral Lodge Skit · Back to Notable Freemasons of Queens →
At the height of New York's homelessness crisis, a community board put the Bell Boulevard temple on a list of possible shelter sites. The lodge's leader learned about it from a reporter.
On a January day in 1983, a Daily News reporter called Kenneth E. Wagner, the presiding officer of Bayside Lodge No. 999, for a comment. That was how Wagner learned that his lodge's temple at 35-25 Bell Boulevard had been proposed as a shelter for the homeless (Daily News, January 28, 1983).
A city in crisis
New York was in the middle of a homelessness emergency. Thousands of people were sleeping in subway cars, train stations and doorways, and the city was under court orders to house them. The 1981 Callahan decision had established a right to shelter for homeless men in New York City, and a new lawsuit filed in 1983, McCain v. Koch, sought the same protection for homeless families (City Limits, "A Brief History of Homelessness in New York"; Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse). Rabbi Marc Tanenbaum of the American Jewish Committee estimated in a broadcast that January that the city had about 36,000 homeless people (American Jewish Archives).
Mayor Edward I. Koch asked the city's community boards to identify possible shelter sites in their own neighborhoods. Community Board 11 in northeast Queens answered with two: the shuttered P.S. 130 at Francis Lewis Boulevard and 42nd Avenue, and the Bayside Masonic Temple.
"I wouldn't give permission"
Wagner was blunt. "It's not possible," he told the Daily News. "The building is rented out almost every day for Masonic lodge meetings and to community groups. There is a big library in it. There's no way it could be used as a shelter. I wouldn't give permission."
The board's chairman, Bernard Haber, said the board was not recommending the temple, only answering the Mayor's request. A spokesman for the Human Resources Administration said the building would be looked over and, if it suited, the Masons might be approached about leasing it.
Bell Boulevard reacts
The Daily News walked the block. Across the street, at the Knights of Columbus hall, Ed Buckley was glad his building had been left off the list: "We only have room to sleep 15 people here." He expected residents and storekeepers to oppose a shelter. Ben Fried, a hardware store owner and president of the Bell Boulevard Merchants Association, said Bayside would not be happy but that he would not lead a protest. A neighbor, Josephine Falkowski, said it would not bother her: "I sympathize with the aged persons. I'm up there in the 60s myself."
The Rev. William Schultz, pastor of Redeemer Lutheran Church across from the temple, said Scripture supported helping the needy, "but times like these are a challenge, the right thing may not be the convenient thing." He supported the city's effort to help the homeless, in Bayside if necessary.
The temple stayed a temple
The temple never became a shelter. It remained what Wagner described: a busy lodge building with a library, rented to Masonic lodges and community groups nearly every day. Its history, from its cornerstone laid by Grand Master Arthur S. Tompkins to its years as one of the main Masonic centers of northeast Queens, is told in The Bayside Masonic Temple on Bell Boulevard.
The episode is a small one, but it catches a moment. In the winter of 1983, the city's need was so great that a lodge hall full of books and meeting rooms could appear on a list beside an empty school, and a quiet Bayside street found itself arguing about what a neighborhood owes the people who have nowhere to sleep.
Sources
Gus Dallas, "Mason Jarred by Shelter Proposal," Daily News, January 28, 1983.
"A Brief History of Homelessness in New York," City Limits.
Rabbi Marc H. Tanenbaum, "Mayor Koch, Religion, and the Homeless," WINS commentary, January 30, 1983, American Jewish Archives.
Continue Reading
← Previous: Cathedral Lodge Skit · Back to Notable Freemasons of Queens → · Notable Freemasons of Queens
Related on BreteMurphy.com