George Pomutz: The Civil War General, Freemason and Consul Who Died a Pauper in St. Petersburg

A portrain of Civil War General George Pomutz

General George Pomutz

Part 5 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: George Siems · Next: George Duryea →

A Hungarian revolutionary became a Union general, a friend of Ulysses S. Grant and America's consul general in Russia. When he died, strangers paid for his grave. Among his papers was a cigar, and proof that he belonged to Pythagoras Lodge in New York.

In 1891, an American consul in St. Petersburg opened two locked boxes that no one had claimed for nearly ten years. Inside were the papers of General George Pomutz, who had died in the Russian capital in 1882 and been buried by the charity of a handful of Americans. There were deeds to farms in Iowa and Missouri, letters from Union generals, invitations to imperial balls, and a cigar wrapped carefully in the colors of the American flag. And there was evidence that the dead general had been a Freemason of Pythagoras Lodge in New York City (Rochester Journal and the Post Express, May 11, 1891).

From Gyula to New Buda

Pomutz was born on May 31, 1818, in Gyula, Hungary. He fought in the Hungarian Revolution of 1848 against the Habsburgs and, after its defeat, went into exile in America with a group of Hungarian and Romanian refugees. They settled in southern Iowa and laid out a colony they called New Buda in Decatur County. Pomutz became an American citizen on March 15, 1855 (Wikipedia, "George Pomutz"; IAGenWeb, "New Buda").

Shiloh to Atlanta

When the Civil War came, Pomutz joined the 15th Iowa Infantry as a first lieutenant. At Shiloh on April 7, 1862, he was badly wounded in the hip but stayed in the saddle until his horse threw him (Hungarian Ottoman Wars). He served as provost marshal of the XVII Corps under General Francis P. Blair, then returned to his regiment and commanded it at the Battle of Atlanta. On March 13, 1865, he was made a brevet brigadier general. His old commander, William W. Belknap, later Secretary of War, wrote of him with warm admiration (Civil War Notebook).

America's man in the Tsar's capital

On February 16, 1866, Pomutz was appointed United States consul at St. Petersburg. He became consul general on June 17, 1874. His command of languages made him useful in a delicate post: the 1891 report credited him with helping President Grant settle the diplomatic quarrel known as the Catacazy affair, which grew out of the conduct of a Russian minister in Washington (Rochester Journal and the Post Express, May 11, 1891).

He gave up the consulate in 1878 to make way for an appointee of the new Hayes administration, but he stayed in St. Petersburg. A few years later he died there, on October 12, 1882. No family came forward. The small American colony took up a collection for his burial in the Smolensky Cemetery, and his old regiment later helped pay for a stone (Wikipedia).

The cigar in the box

The 1891 report, written by Consul Crawford, read like a short story. Among letters from Grant, Sherman, Logan and other Union generals, Crawford found a cigar tied with the national colors and a label in Pomutz's hand: "The last cigar of a box given me by General Grant when he visited St. Petersburg in his trip around the world." Grant had passed through Russia in 1878 on his famous world tour.

Crawford also found that Pomutz was "a member of the Ancient Order of the Free and Accepted Masons, Pythagoras Lodge, in the city of New York." He urged that if the Masonic fraternity knew the story, its members would send enough money to keep the general's grave dressed every year.

Pythagoras Lodge No. 86

Pythagoras was a natural home for a cultured European exile in New York. Chartered in Manhattan on April 20, 1841, it was one of the city's German-speaking lodges, and it drew immigrants from across Central Europe. Its history was as restless as Pomutz's own: in the early 1850s part of it worked under the Grand Lodge of Hamburg before rejoining New York's Grand Lodge. On March 21, 1993, Pythagoras Lodge No. 86 merged into Trinity Lodge No. 12, the senior lodge of the German District, which now meets at the Whitestone Masonic Temple in Queens.

A grave that disappeared

The memory of George Pomutz outlived his grave. The Smolensky burial site appears to have been lost in the twentieth century. In 1944, Romanian Americans raised money for a wartime ship to carry his name, and Iowa, Hungary and Romania all claim him as their own (Wikipedia). For the lodges of the German District, he is something simpler: a brother of Pythagoras, carried home to New York in a consul's report, with a general's last cigar still tied in red, white and blue.

Sources

  • "In a Pauper's Grave: The Death of Ex-Consul-General Pomutz in Russia," Rochester Journal and the Post Express, May 11, 1891.

  • "George Pomutz," Wikipedia.

  • "George Pomutz," Civil War Notebook, from William W. Belknap, History of the Fifteenth Regiment, Iowa Veteran Volunteer Infantry.

  • "Pomucz György (1818 to 1882)," Hungarian Ottoman Wars.

  • "New Buda," IAGenWeb, Decatur County.

  • Grand Lodge of the State of New York, charter and merger records for Pythagoras No. 86 and Trinity No. 12.


Continue Reading

← Previous: George Siems · Next: George Duryea → · Notable Freemasons of Queens

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Colonel George Duryea: The Zouave Officer Who Became Master of Glen Cove Lodge No. 580

Next
Next

Dr. John J. Kindred: The Astoria Physician and Congressman Who Opened the Advance Masonic Temple