Two Lodges, One Corner: Oscar Coles, Henry C. Atwood and the Road to Harmony

By Brete Murphy · November 12, 2026

Notable Figures · The Seven Lodges

In 1851, Grand Master Oscar Coles installed the officers of a Manhattan lodge bearing his own name. Its first Master was a waterfront chandler whose business address later appeared in a notice for Coles & Thorn. Nearby in the historical record stood a lodge named for Henry C. Atwood, a leader of a rival Grand Lodge. Their institutional connections eventually reached Harmony and Francis Lewis, which now meet in College Point.

Harmony Lodge: Main History · Harmony’s Six Lodge Histories · The Seven Lodges


On Christmas Eve in 1851, Oscar Coles installed the officers of a new Manhattan lodge.

The lodge bore his name.

According to Harmony Lodge’s historical account, Oscar Coles Lodge No. 241 held its first meeting on December 24, 1851, at the corner of Broome and Crosby Streets. Coles, then Grand Master, acted as Installing Master.

The name was a tribute to a living man. The number would prove more durable.

In 1867, the lodge became Constitution. Through later consolidations, No. 241 continued into Harmony Lodge, now associated with College Point, Queens.

At the same Manhattan intersection, the author’s research places another lodge with a living namesake: Atwood No. 208.

The proximity creates an arresting historical connection. One lodge honored a leader of the St. John’s Grand Lodge. The other honored a Grand Master whom Harmony’s history remembers for helping reunite that body with the Grand Lodge of New York.

But the story was not a simple passage from division to permanent peace. Other disputes continued, and St. John’s itself would be revived.

A Merchant from Brooklyn

The biographical records assembled for this article place Coles’s birth in Brooklyn in January 1814, the son of Jordan and Martha Coles.

His later life belonged partly to the waterfront economy. The author’s newspaper and business research associates him with firms named Coles & Waterbury and Coles & Thorn. The precise partnerships and their dates still require confirmation.

The maritime connection, however, now has a contemporary address attached to it.

A February 24, 1853 reference in the New York Herald, page 4, identifies Coles & Thorn as ship chandlers at 91 West Street.

That notice establishes the firm’s trade and address before the Civil War. It does not explicitly name its partners.

The distinction matters because the lodge’s first Master was Alfred F. Thorn—and a directory places him at the same address several years earlier.

Alfred F. Thorn and the West Street Connection

Harmony’s history describes the organizers of Oscar Coles Lodge as seafaring men employed as merchants or sailors. It identifies Alfred F. Thorn as their first Master.

Thorn’s occupation fits that account.

In Doggett’s New-York City Directory for 1846 and 1847, printed page 387, his entry reads:

“Thorn Alfred F. chandler, 91 West”

The surname, trade and premises align closely with the 1853 newspaper reference to Coles & Thorn at 91 West Street.

That is a stronger connection than the coincidence of a surname alone. It suggests that the lodge’s first Master may have been the Thorn partner in the firm.

It does not yet prove the identification. Nor does either excerpt explicitly establish that Oscar Coles was the Coles partner.

A partnership notice or directory cross-reference naming both men would close that gap.

A Later Directory Entry

Trow’s New York City Directory for 1859–1860, printed page 843, lists an Alfred Thorne as a shipchandler at 118 West Street.

The middle initial is unclear in the available transcription.

The later entry may refer to the same man, with a terminal “e” added to his surname and a different business address. Until the original image and additional records settle the identity, it should not be used to claim that Alfred F. Thorn moved his business from 91 to 118 West Street.

For now, the records establish a useful research sequence:

Date Record Entry or business reference
1846–1847 Doggett’s directory, p. 387 Alfred F. Thorn, chandler, 91 West Street
February 24, 1853 New York Herald, p. 4 Coles & Thorn, ship chandlers, 91 West Street
1859–1860 Trow’s directory, p. 843 Alfred Thorne, middle initial unclear, shipchandler, 118 West Street

The first two records create the strongest link. The third is a possible continuation, not yet a confirmed one.

These details place the lodge’s founding leadership within the working geography of the waterfront without requiring an unproven partnership to carry the argument.

Read Constitution Lodge No. 241 →

A Fraternity with More Than One Grand Lodge

Coles became Grand Master during a period when New York Freemasonry was still working through competing claims of authority.

The Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library’s Grand Lodge Archives finding aid distinguishes several bodies:

Body Dates listed in the archival chronology
St. John’s Grand Lodge 1837–1850
Phillips Grand Lodge 1849–1858
Revived St. John’s Grand Lodge 1853–1859

These dates prevent an important misunderstanding: the union of 1850 did not resolve every division within New York Masonry.

The first St. John’s separation arose during the difficult recovery from the anti-Masonic movement associated with the Morgan affair.

The historical accounts used for this series connect the 1837 rupture with a dispute over a public procession and the discipline imposed on participating lodges.

Henry C. Atwood became a leading figure in the separate St. John’s body.

A different dispute, involving the rights of Past Masters, produced the Phillips division in 1849.

These were related parts of a troubled institutional history, but they were not one uninterrupted quarrel with a single settlement date.

The Union of 1850

The author’s Grand Lodge compilation dates the union of the original St. John’s body with the Grand Lodge of New York to December 27, 1850.

The settlement brought lodges into the reunited jurisdiction and provided a framework for their recognition.

Atwood was received as a Past Grand Master.

Harmony’s own history describes Coles as a driving force in the reunion. That is an institutional account of his contribution, rather than a complete record of the negotiations.

The Livingston Library’s finding aid identifies a Grand Master’s papers series for Oscar Coles in 1851.

His election placed him at the head of the Grand Lodge after the 1850 union, but while the Phillips division remained unresolved.

“Reunited” therefore describes a particular settlement. It should not be read as “free of every competing Grand Lodge.”

A Lodge Bearing His Name

Harmony’s history traces the new lodge’s petition to members of Lafayette Lodge No. 64.

The organizers selected the name Oscar Coles Lodge in honor of the newly elected Grand Master.

On December 24, 1851, Coles installed these officers:

Office Name recorded in Harmony’s history
Master Alfred F. Thorn
Senior Warden Cornelius W. Brush
Junior Warden John H. Black
Treasurer Samuel Auld
Secretary Robert McCor
Senior Deacon Benjamin Beyer
Junior Deacon George Anderson

The spellings above follow the published lodge history.

An installation list is not necessarily a complete charter roster. Nor does Coles’s role as installing officer establish that he was a member of the lodge named for him.

His importance here is clear without making that additional claim: he was its namesake, the sitting Grand Master and the officer who installed its first recorded leadership.

Thorn’s directory entry adds a different kind of evidence. It connects the first Master to a specific occupation and address before the lodge was organized.

Two Lodges at Broome and Crosby

Harmony’s history places Oscar Coles Lodge at Broome and Crosby from its beginning.

The author’s Atwood research, including a December 1852 newspaper reference, places Atwood Lodge at that intersection as well.

That does not establish a shared building.

A corner can contain several premises, and the surviving descriptions do not yet supply a common street number or room.

The defensible connection is geographical: both histories point to Broome and Crosby within the same early-1850s period.

The symbolic contrast is nevertheless striking.

One lodge bore the name of Atwood, associated with the St. John’s separation. The other bore the name of Coles, remembered by its successor for helping bring that body into union.

The possible Coles–Thorn partnership would add a business connection within the second lodge’s founding circle. It should not be extended into a connection with Atwood’s officers without further records.

Read Metropolitan Lodge’s Atwood Connection →

Atwood, Metropolitan and Cyrus

The Atwood branch requires care because its history includes both a division of members and the continuation of a warrant.

According to the Grand Lodge records compiled for this series, Atwood received its No. 208 warrant on March 4, 1851, following the December 1850 union.

In 1852, members divided.

The departing group formed Metropolitan Lodge No. 273, chartered on December 9, 1852.

The No. 208 warrant continued separately and took the name Cyrus on January 30, 1854.

Atwood was therefore an antecedent of Metropolitan through the men who left it. It was not simply renamed Metropolitan, and its warrant did not become No. 273.

The reason for the Cyrus name change has not been established in the material assembled here.

The revival of St. John’s in 1853 provides context. It does not, by itself, prove why the lodge changed its name.

Read Francis Lewis’s Historical Members Directory →

Why Oscar Coles Became Constitution

The explanation for the other name change is more explicit.

Harmony’s history records prolonged discussion about the propriety of naming a lodge after a living Grand Master.

The members eventually resolved to adopt Constitution Lodge No. 241. Grand Lodge permission was granted on June 8, 1867.

Coles was still alive.

The change did not erase the founding connection. It replaced a personal name with an institutional one while retaining the lodge’s number.

The distinction survives in Harmony’s historical account, which continues to identify the lodge’s original name and its first installation.

Captain Coles at Bellport

The later newspaper material assembled for this article presents Coles in a different setting: summer life on the Great South Bay.

Resort coverage in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle identifies Captain Oscar Coles with Aiken, South Carolina, and Bellport’s Bell House. It describes his sloop yacht, Edith, and his enthusiasm for life on the water.

The title “Captain” belongs to that newspaper portrait. The material presented here does not establish a military commission.

His October 1899 obituary also claimed friendships with Abraham Lincoln, Edwin Stanton and Cornelius Vanderbilt.

Those are the obituary’s claims. They require correspondence, contemporary business records or other independent evidence before being treated as established personal relationships.

Coles died in Bellport in October 1899.

The supplied obituary and memorial records disagree over his age: the obituary gives eighty-six, while the reported January 1814 birth would make him eighty-five.

His exact birth and death dates should therefore be settled from primary records before a precise age is attached to the article.

The burial research places him at Green-Wood Cemetery in the George W. Browne family mausoleum, beside his wife, Marie Louise.

From Manhattan to Queens

Constitution’s institutional history continued long after its namesake’s death.

Harmony’s published account states that Constitution voted to combine with Maspeth in 1974, when many of its members were living in Queens.

The author’s Grand Lodge compilation dates that combination to May 8, 1974.

The later consolidation sequence brought the Constitution-Maspeth branch together with the Cardozo-Rufus-King-David and North Shore branches as Harmony No. 241 on November 21, 1990.

Metropolitan followed a separate route.

It combined with Whitestone in 1972. Metropolitan-Whitestone and Bayside became Francis Lewis No. 273 in 1986. Brandeis joined that line in 2015.

The two continuing lodge histories thus preserve different institutional relationships to the early-1850s Manhattan corner.

Harmony carries the Constitution line directly.

Francis Lewis carries Metropolitan’s line, with its antecedent connection to the men who departed from Atwood.

Read Harmony’s Six Lodge Histories →

Read The Number That Traveled East: Francis Lewis’s Lineage →

Under One Roof

According to the author’s November 2026 confirmations, Harmony and Francis Lewis now meet at the Anchor-Astoria temple in College Point, alongside Anchor-Astoria and Cornucopia.

Francis Lewis began meeting there in September 2025.

The present arrangement should not be mistaken for the inevitable outcome of events in 1851. Different memberships, property decisions and consolidations shaped the intervening years.

Yet the connection is worth preserving.

The histories once associated with Broome and Crosby now meet again in the same building—not as rival Grand Lodges, but as separate lodges sharing premises within the same jurisdiction.

Coles’s namesake set aside his name in 1867. It retained No. 241 and the record of his part in its beginning.

The directories preserve another part of that beginning: a chandler named Alfred F. Thorn, working at 91 West Street before he became the lodge’s first Master.

One record supplies the ceremony. Another supplies the working address. Together, they bring the lodge’s founding world into sharper focus.

Read Where the Lines Meet: The College Point Temple →

Sources and Research Notes

Harmony’s Institutional History

Harmony Lodge No. 241: Lodge History.

Also published through the Grand Lodge of New York’s Harmony history page.

Used for:

  • The December 24, 1851 first meeting.
  • Coles’s role as Installing Master.
  • The first-officer list.
  • The maritime character of the founding group.
  • The Broome-and-Crosby location.
  • The explanation for the Constitution name change.
  • The June 8, 1867 approval.
  • The account of Constitution’s 1974 combination with Maspeth.

The two web versions repeat substantially the same institutional narrative; they are not treated as independent corroboration.

Alfred F. Thorn in Doggett’s Directory

John Doggett, Jr., Doggett’s New-York City Directory for 1846 and 1847 (New York: John Doggett, Jr., 1846), printed p. 387:

“Thorn Alfred F. chandler, 91 West”

Digitized volume, Columbia University Libraries / Internet Archive.

The quotation and printed page number follow the author’s transcription.

The Internet Archive record labels the volume 1846/1847 but gives 1845 in a separate publication-date field. The edition and 1846 imprint used here follow the supplied title-page and copyright transcription.

Coles & Thorn at 91 West Street

New York Herald, February 24, 1853, p. 4.

Library of Congress digitized newspaper page.

The indexed text identifies Coles & Thorn as ship chandlers at 91 West Street.

The reference establishes the firm’s name, trade and address. It does not explicitly identify either partner.

The matching address strengthens, but does not complete, the identification of Alfred F. Thorn with the firm.

Alfred Thorne in Trow’s Directory

Trow’s New York City Directory, 1859–1860 (New York: J. F. Trow, 1859), printed p. 843.

Digitized volume, Columbia University Libraries / Internet Archive.

The author’s transcription lists Alfred Thorne, shipchandler, at 118 West Street. The middle initial is unclear.

The entry is treated as a possible continuation of Alfred F. Thorn’s business history, not a confirmed identification.

The following entry for Alfred L. Thorne at 96 East Sixteenth Street is separate and is not used as the shipchandler’s home address.

Grand Lodge Divisions and Archival Records

Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library: Grand Lodge Archives Finding Aid.

Grand Lodge Archives: General Finding Aid, PDF.

Used for the chronology of:

  • St. John’s Grand Lodge, 1837–1850.
  • Phillips Grand Lodge, 1849–1858.
  • Revived St. John’s Grand Lodge, 1853–1859.

The finding aid identifies Oscar Coles’s 1851 Grand Master’s papers as Series 5.11.

An archival series listing identifies research material. It does not, by itself, establish the contents of every document within it.

Grand Lodge Proceedings

Livingston Library: Digitized Grand Lodge Proceedings.

The library explains how registered patrons can access the digitized proceedings.

Its notice states that the digitized collection described there does not include the proceedings of the St. John’s, revived St. John’s or Phillips Grand Lodges.

Institutional Dates Compiled by Brete Murphy

The author’s Grand Lodge research supplies:

  • Atwood’s entry at the December 27, 1850 union.
  • Atwood’s March 4, 1851 warrant.
  • Metropolitan’s December 9, 1852 charter.
  • The January 30, 1854 Cyrus name change.
  • The May 8, 1974 Constitution-Maspeth combination.
  • Harmony’s November 21, 1990 consolidation.

These dates follow the author’s compilation rather than a fresh examination of the original proceedings for this revision.

Newspaper and Business Research on Coles

Brooklyn Daily Eagle, October 14, 1899, “Obituary: Long Island. Captain Oscar Coles.”

The author’s Bellport resort-column research supplies the Bell House, Aiken and yacht references.

Direct clipping URLs and complete issue dates for the resort columns were not supplied.

The claims of friendship with Lincoln, Stanton and Vanderbilt remain attributed to the obituary.

The precise membership and chronology of Coles & Waterbury, and Oscar Coles’s identification as a partner in Coles & Thorn, remain to be documented explicitly.

Burial Research

The author’s Green-Wood research identifies Section 43, Lot 57, and the George W. Browne mausoleum.

A Find a Grave memorial identified in the supplied research is a secondary reference for the burial and reported birth date.

The original cemetery register and vital records remain the preferred sources for resolving the age discrepancy.

Further Historical Context

Herbert Singer and Ossian Lang, New York Freemasonry: A Bicentennial History, Grand Lodge of New York, 1976.

The author also consulted lodge histories discussing the St. John’s and Phillips divisions.

Related Articles in This Series


Constitution Lodge No. 241 · Harmony Lodge: Main History · Harmony’s Historical Members Directory

Francis Lewis’s Lineage · The College Point Temple

The Seven Lodges: Series Guide · Connecting Stories · Queens History Blog


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Next
Next

A Man of Signals: Daniel Butterfield, Taps and Metropolitan Lodge No. 273