When the Masons Held Up the Police: Jamaica Lodge No. 546 and the 1902 Town Hall Standoff

Part 16 of Lodge Lives: Notable Masons of Queens and Old Queens County · ← Previous: Hermann Zimmermann · Next: Ernest Grant Manning →

The city tore out a lodge room in Jamaica's old Town Hall to make a police dormitory. Then it learned the Masons still held the lease, and had just paid the rent.

In the summer of 1902, the New York City Police Department was ready to move. Since the consolidation of Greater New York four years earlier, the headquarters of the Queens police had been in Long Island City, and the borough's inspector, Elias P. Clayton, wanted it in Jamaica, the growing hub of the borough. Jamaica's leading men wanted it too. The plan was to move into the old Town Hall on Labor Day. Then the Freemasons of Jamaica Lodge No. 546 spoiled it, or so the newspapers said (Brooklyn Eagle, August 26, 1902).

The old Town Hall

Jamaica's Town Hall stood at the corner of Fulton Street and Flushing Avenue, today's Jamaica Avenue and Parsons Boulevard. Completed in 1870, it served as the civic center of the old Town of Jamaica (Hatching Cat, "The Cat Who Cried Murder"). A history of Jamaica Hospital recalls that the one building served at various times as "Town Hall, Opera House, jail and hospital" (Jamaica Hospital Medical Center). After consolidation it became a police station.

It was also, for more than thirty years, the home of Jamaica Lodge. The lodge rented the third floor, renewing the lease every time it expired, from the time the building was finished.

Sergeant O'Brien's crew

Police Commissioner Partridge sent Sergeant O'Brien, the department's "mechanical head," to fit the building for headquarters. The Seventy-eighth Precinct already used two floors and the cells in the basement. The plan was to turn the old lodge room on the top floor into sleeping quarters for the patrolmen and to partition the auditorium into offices for the inspectors.

O'Brien arrived from Mulberry Street with blueprints, lumber, plumbers, painters and carpenters. The lodge room, the Eagle wrote, "still bore all the earmarks of a place devoted to the mysterious doings of the Masons," including the lodge's safe and the raised platform that runs around every lodge room. But the Masons had moved out on April 1, and no one had paid rent since. O'Brien's men moved the safe, tore up the platform, laid a solid floor for the cots and put up partitions. By late August the dormitories were nearly ready.

The lease

At the last minute, the lodge put in a claim. Its lease, made in 1897 just before consolidation, did not expire until April 1, 1907. On August 22 the lodge had paid another quarter's rent, and the city's financial office, apparently without realizing what it was doing, had accepted the money and given a receipt.

The papers enjoyed it. "Now the Masons have the city by the throat," the Eagle declared, and it described the lodge's position as "something that looks like a hold-up." Deputy Commissioner Ebstein was furious. The Brooklyn Citizen quoted him: "It looks very much as if the department was cornered" (Brooklyn Citizen, August 26, 1902). There was talk that Jamaica might not get police headquarters after all.

The lodge answers

Two days later the story turned. A committee from the lodge, made up of B. Frank Wood, District Deputy Grand Master J. Maynard Kissam and J. Tyler Watts, met Major Ebstein, and the lodge agreed to release the lease. Watts called any suggestion of a hold-up "an absurdity and without a particle of foundation."

Wood, a past master of Jamaica Lodge, issued a statement that set out the lodge's side. The lodge had already moved into its new Masonic Temple, and it had told the city more than once, as recently as a month earlier, that it was ready to give up the lease. It had paid the quarter's rent only because the city's finance department asked for it. And it had not been treated well: when a trustee went to the old rooms, he found a pane broken out of the door, a partition torn away and the platforms ripped out. Still, the lodge offered to let the police move in at once and to accept whatever settlement the Sinking Fund Commissioners thought fair. Far from exploiting the city, Wood wrote, the lodge was "disposed to waive valuable rights, rather than interfere in the slightest degree with public interests."

The Brooklyn Daily Times ran the settlement under a headline any Mason would enjoy: "Forgiven by the Goat." The Masons, it reported, "have forgiven the indignity cast upon their goat. The goat has also forgiven" (Brooklyn Daily Times, August 28, 1902).

What came after

The police got their headquarters, and Jamaica got its new status. The new home Wood mentioned was the lodge's own temple on Union Avenue, told in The Jamaica Masonic Temple on Union Avenue. The old Town Hall stood for decades more before it was torn down, and a federal building now occupies the corner. For one week in 1902, though, a Masonic lease in a desk drawer stood between the police department and its plans for Queens.

Sources


Continue Reading

← Previous: Hermann Zimmermann · Next: Ernest Grant Manning → · Notable Freemasons of Queens

Related on BreteMurphy.com


 

Brete Murphy

A Freemason, a local historian, well versed in symbolism, comparative religious studies, esoterica, and a member of several societies. I am currently the Historian of Advance Service Mizpah Lodge 586 in Astoria , New York.

https://www.bretemurphy.com/
Previous
Previous

Ernest Grant Manning: The Queens Village Mason Who Helped Plan the Parkways of Queens and Nassau

Next
Next

Hermann Zimmermann: The Swiss Wrestling Champion Who Was a 60-Year Mason of Heritage Lodge No. 284