Forest Hills Lodge No. 946 and Community Lodge No. 1028 · Masonic Buildings in Queens
A Georgian Colonial temple raised in 1920 by a four-year-old lodge in a fourteen-year-old neighborhood, shared with a bank from 1929, and a bank branch until 2018.
A lodge in a new neighborhood
Forest Hills was barely a neighborhood when its Masons organized. The Cord Meyer Development Company bought about 600 acres of farmland called Whitepot in 1906 and named the tract for nearby Forest Park (Wikipedia). Ten years later, on December 18, 1916, Grand Master Thomas Penney granted a dispensation for Forest Hills Lodge, which became Forest Hills Lodge No. 946. Its early meetings were held at Arcanum Hall in Elmhurst. Its charter committee was Dickran M. Sarkisian, John Miller, Robert Whyte, J. M. Pahl, Andrew Galbraith, Adam Treu and V. E. Engelbach (Michael Perlman, Rego-Forest Preservation Council).
Building the temple, 1919 to 1920
Early in 1919 the lodge bought a corner lot for under $10,000, with 64 feet on Queens Boulevard and 150 feet along the side street, then called Gown Street. The Masons financed the land and building through a holding company, Forest Hills Community Hall, Inc., at a total investment of more than $50,000.
On October 9, 1920, Grand Master Robert H. Robinson laid the cornerstone after a parade with a marching band, escorted by Knights Templar. The lodge moved into its new home on November 16, 1920. The building was in the Georgian Colonial style (Macaulay Honors College, "From Masonic Temple to Bank"). A 1927 map of Forest Hills Gardens marks the Masonic Temple on Continental Avenue, now 108th Street (Forest Hills Times). By 1924 the lodge had 187 members.
A community hall
As its holding company's name promised, the temple served the whole neighborhood. It hosted a show for the Silver Cross Day Nursery, a 1923 concert by the Forest Hills Choral Club, a 1928 fashion revue, and, from 1933, political meetings including those of the City Fusion Party. In 1932 the Forest Hills Jewish Center held its High Holiday services there. A 1922 concert in the temple raised money to build St. Luke's Church.
Sharing the building with a bank
In 1928 the Masons announced that a new bank would share the building. Boulevard Bank and Trust Company opened there in 1929. Its founders were Forest Hills businessmen, and its officers included Dickran M. Sarkisian, a charter member of the lodge, as founder and vice president, and Frederick Gretsch, as a vice president (Flickr building timeline).
The lodge stayed upstairs. In November 1936 the Times Union announced the District Deputy's official visit to "Forest Hills Lodge, 946, which meets in the temple on Queens blvd., Forest Hills." On June 1, 1948, Sterling National Bank and Trust Company took over Boulevard Bank and opened its Forest Hills branch in the building.
The lodge moves on
According to Perlman, about fifty years after its founding Forest Hills Lodge moved to new quarters at 101-01 Metropolitan Avenue. The Queens Boulevard building remained a Sterling branch for seven decades, until it closed on August 28, 2018, in a consolidation with Astoria Bank. That year the Rego-Forest Preservation Council urged that "the original home of Forest Hills Masons" be preserved.
Sources
Michael Perlman, "Sterling National Bank To Close Longtime Branch August 28: Preserve The Original Home of Forest Hills Masons!", Rego-Forest Preservation Council, August 2018.
"From Masonic Temple to Bank," Forest Hills Peopling project, Macaulay Honors College, 2014.
Sterling National Bank, formerly Boulevard Bank and Masonic Temple of Forest Hills, Flickr building history.
Michael Perlman, "A 1927 Forest Hills Map with a Story to Tell," Forest Hills Times, March 22, 2023.
"In L.I. Masonic Circles," Times Union, November 15, 1936.
"Forest Hills, Queens," Wikipedia.
Continue Reading
Forest Hills Lodge No. 946 and Community Lodge No. 1028 · Mizpah Masonic Temple, Elmhurst
Related on BreteMurphy.com